If the Los Angeles Rams had extended Puka Nacua during the offseason instead of waiting out a long-term commitment, it’s possible that their best offensive weapon wouldn’t have made the decision to get potential season-ending knee surgery this week. That’s one way to interpret Sean McVay’s comments announcing the news — “Puka Nacua decided to get surgery” — and it’s a narrative already hitting the mainstream media. That Nacua has made this decision on his own behalf and without consulting with the Rams franchise
or making a mutual agreement to have surgery that likely ends his 2026 season.
Daniel Jeremiah went on The Rich Eisen Show on Friday and said his immediate reaction to watching McVay’s press conference for the first time was “It doesn’t sound like (the Rams and Nacua) were completely on the same page.”
No, it really doesn’t sound that way. Does it?
I have spent months warning Rams fans that something like this could happen.
Puka Nacua should not be playing without a contract extension
Whether you think it’s selfish or smart, Nacua’s decision to play this season without a contract extension could have ended up costing him at least $100 million. Would you take that risk if you were in Puka’s shoes?
Jaxon Smith-Njigba is one of the only receivers in the NFL who is in Puka’s exclusive league of elite receiver talent and the Seahawks extended JSN to a contract that pays him $168 million over four years, including $120 million guaranteed. And JSN was a first-round pick, so he already made $14 million on his rookie contract PLUS Seattle had to pick up his fifth-year option for 2027.
Nacua was in the same draft class as JSN, but because he wasn’t a first-round pick, he didn’t have a fifth-year option. If he did, the Rams certainly would have picked it up and then he would at least have a guaranteed $10-$20 million or so waiting for him in 2027. Right now, he has NOTHING waiting for him next year.
The Rams thought it was too risk to extend him and it’s hard to fault them given his injury history and off-field concerns. However, did they consider the risk of not extending him?
For the Rams to go “all-in” on winning the Super Bowl in 2026, they didn’t seem to consider that at some point Nacua might get a little bit injured and then realize, “Holy crap, I might have my career end right now having only made $7.7 million in my NFL career” and then decide that he needs to stop playing football until 2027.
That may actually be exactly what has happened and now Nacua might never play for the Rams again.
And why not? Because:
- The Rams were too afraid to extend a 25-year-old receiver who is arguably their best player
- McVay continued to use Puka in a way that indicated no concerns for his health
- After 19 targets in a game that was all but over, McVay called an end around for Nacua on the final offensive snap against Washington
Instead of ceding third-and-long, McVay called a play that virtually guaranteed Nacua would be tackled in bounds and tackled hard. It resulted in a sprained MCL and PCL and is obviously just enough of an injury for Nacua to realize that if he doesn’t play another snap this season, he could get $120 million guaranteed in 2027.
Whether it’s for the Rams or someone else. However, given the apparent “disagreement” on Nacua’s surgery decision, we could speculate that neither side wants to move forward with a long-term contract with the other side.
For the Rams, because they can’t control Nacua like they want.
For Nacua, because the Rams want to control him without a financial commitment.
This could have been avoided with a contract extension.
Nacua would have done whatever the Rams wanted him to do because he’s not risking his financial future. He would already have one. Instead, L.A. elected to give Aaron Donald $20 million — $13 million more than Nacua has made in his entire career — because it sounded like a cool idea.
They traded for Trent McDuffie and immediately made him the highest-paid cornerback in the NFL at the time. They gave Jaylen Watson $34 million guaranteed. They still have Colby Parkinson on a contract that pays him more cash in 2026 than Puka Nacua will make.
The Rams have extended Quentin Lake, Kyren Williams, Nate Landman, A.J. Jackson, and Kam Curl. But when it came to their best draft pick since Cooper Kupp — a receiver the Rams extended twice (once in 2020 when he was first eligible, and again for $80 million 2022 when he was close to 30) — the Rams balked at an offer for Nacua.
So 29-year-old Kupp with an injury history and coming off one of the most taxing seasons for a receiver that the NFL has ever seen is not a risk, but Nacua is?
Well, maybe he is. Maybe three years from now we’ll look back at “the sad tale of what could have been with Puka Nacua” in a new 30-for-30.
But again, the Rams have wasted more hundreds of millions of dollars on risky bets (a 29-year-old Allen Robinson got paid $26 million by the Rams to have 339 yards and he was way more injury prone than Puka) than all the hundreds of millions of dollars you and I could spend collectively for the rest of our lives.
So yeah, fans and the media could say “Puka did this” and elected to have a surgery that maybe he could have put off until 2027 and helped the Rams win the Super Bowl instead — sort of like Odell Beckham Jr. possibly doing something like that and then tearing his ACL in the Super Bowl and effectively ending his career — but what choice did the organization leave him?
By dangling $120 million of guaranteed money in Puka Nacua’s future instead of giving it to him now, the L.A. Rams took a much bigger risk because they’ve made it clear that they are not worried about what’s in it for him.
That could be why Nacua decided that he had to back himself. He couldn’t keep waiting for a pay day that may never come.













