While there is no Pete Alonso in this year’s free agent pool, former division rival Randy Arozarena is the best bet to fix Baltimore’s lackluster offense.
The Orioles had many problems during the 2026 season, but their most drastic shortcoming was their offensive output. Sure, marquee free-agent signing Alonso was awesome and delivered even more than was asked of him. However, the O’s simply didn’t coalesce as a lineup around the Polar Bear.
Before last season, many projected Baltimore to challenge
the Yankees for the title of best lineup in the American League. Instead, the Orioles’ 4.46 runs/game was 6th in the AL and just below the Major League average of 4.48 runs/game. The Baltimore lineup often struggled to put the ball in play, finishing with the AL’s second-worst batting average and second-most strikeouts.
Arozarena cannot single-handedly fix all of the Orioles’ offensive problems, but he has the most offensive upside of any bat in the current free agent class. The former Rookie of the Year and ALCS MVP is coming off the best season of his career as the only bright spot in a weak Mariners lineup. In 2026, Arozarena set career highs with a 5.7 bWAR, a .281 average and a .865 OPS. The former longtime Tampa Bay Ray also posted his sixth straight 20-20 season and his fifth season in the last six with 30+ doubles.
The Orioles struggled to make consistent contact as a team last year, an area where Arozarena made big leaps during his second full season in Seattle. The 31-year-old’s career year was fueled by a noticeable drop in his swing-and-miss rate, as he whiffed on a career-low 26.3% in 2026. That translated to a dramatic dip from a 27% strikeout rate in 2025 to a 21.6% strikeout rate in 2026—as Arozarena registered fewer than 150 strikeouts in a full season for the first time in his career.
The Cuban-born, Mexican outfielder can be a better version of what the Orioles got from Taylor Ward, while also giving Baltimore another weapon to deploy against left-handed pitchers. Baltimore’s outfielders only produced a .674 OPS last season, the third-worst mark in all of baseball. Among all qualified outfielders, Arozarena’s .865 OPS was 4th last season, while his wRC+ of 151 was second only to NL MVP Pete Crow-Armstrong.
The O’s have had long and well-documented struggles hitting left-handed pitching. Despite having baseball’s best lefty masher in Coby Mayo, the Orioles against LHPs finished 17th in OPS (.702), 26th in average (.233) and had the most Ks vs. lefties (503). Teaming Arozarena with Mayo would give the Orioles the best pair of southpaw smashers in the majors. The outfielder hit .306 with 11 home runs and a .950 OPS last year vs. lefties, joining Mayo as one of only five players with a .300+ average, 10+ HR and a .900+ OPS against southpaws.
Arozarena would also seamlessly slide into the Orioles lineup next year. Colton Cowser is the only outfielder currently on the roster who seems guaranteed playing time next year. Dylan Beavers had a disappointing rookie year and will probably only play against RHPs until he improves. After playing in only 139 games across two seasons in Baltimore, the oft-injured Tyler O’Neill could be on his way out of the organization. Unlike the infield, where the O’s have too many mouths to feed, it will be easy to find space for Arozarena in the outfield.
The only aspect of his game that makes Arozarena a questionable fit is his defense. Colton Cowser played Gold Glove-caliber defense last year, but the rest of the outfield was subpar. By pretty much every defensive metric, Arozarena is also a below-average outfielder. In FanGraphs’ Defensive Runs Saved, he finished with -2. He finished with -5 Outs Above Average (according to Statcast) while also possessing one of the weakest outfield arms in baseball.
The Orioles have typically been ok with starting at least one defensively inferior outfielder, as the shallow RF in Camden Yards can easily hide weak defenders. Signing a top-tier offensive outfielder like Arozarena might also allow them to call up elite defensive CF prospect Enrique Bradfield while shifting Cowser back to LF.
As arguably the top hitter on the free-agent market, it will likely take another $100M+ contract to secure the services of Arozarena. Last offseason, we saw Cody Bellinger sign a 5-year/$162.5M (32.5M/year) contract to return to the Yankees. As a slightly older player and a far inferior defender, I wouldn’t expect Arozarena to command $30M+/year. However, it wouldn’t be surprising to see him get a contract in the range of $100M/4 years or $125M/5 years.
The Orioles may have to even overpay if they truly want to get in on the Arozarena race. Teams like the Blue Jays, Phillies and Red Sox could all use corner outfield help, and we’ve often seen players choose teams with more recent success over competitive offers from the Orioles (Corbin Burnes in 2025, Kyle Schwarber in 2026).
However, if the Orioles can convince Arozarena to come to Baltimore, it’d be a huge step toward returning this organization to winning ways. Having made the World Series as a rookie with the Rays, led Mexico to a third-place finish at the 2023 World Baseball Classic and gone to the ALCS with Seattle in 2025, Arozarena is used to winning. Adding him to the Alonso-led Orioles offense, along with a potential bounceback from Gunnar Henderson, would give the O’s a batting order that can lead Baltimore back to the playoffs.













