Welcome to SB Nation Reacts, a survey of fans across the MLB. Throughout the year we ask questions of the most plugged-in Diamondbacks fans and fans across the country. Sign up here to participate in the weekly emailed surveys.
At the start of the year, and through the early weeks of the season, it felt like Arizona could almost have assembled a full roster of players on one of the injured lists. However, it now feels like the tide may have turned, and the team are now looking to get these players back
and available again. For this week’s question, I want to take a look at one player who returned this week, and three who should be returning in future, and see which one you think will have the most impact. To that end, I purposely excluded Corbin Burnes and A.J. Puk, because they are really going to be back in September, if at all. That’s a little too far out for purposes here.
But here are the four candidates, in alphabetical order.
Lourdes Gurriel Jr.
He’s already back, having rejoined the team on June 15, and contributed a key RBI hit in that night’s 4-3 win over the Angels. Gurriel had missed the least amount of time of the four candidates, having been out for 21 games with a left hamstring strain. But he also missed the first twenty games this year recovering from ACL surgery in his other leg. The results have been underwhelming so far, with just a .563 OPS and worth -0.4 bWAR. He’ll need to pick up the pace significantly – and also, avoid further IL stints – if he wants the team to pick up his $14 million option for next season.
James McCann
McCann has been out for almost exactly a month, hitting the IL on May 19 with a strain of his right quadriceps – not something you want as a catcher. However, Torey Lovullo said on Monday that James will start playing in the Arizona Complex League next week. While the backup catcher spot is perhaps not particularly important, the fact that in his absence, the role has been filled by Aramis Garcia (OPS+ 28) and Adrian Del Castillo (55) mean there’s definite room for improvement. That’s in addition to McCann’s good reputation for calling games and working with the pitching staff. And besides, we need his arm out of the bullpen. 🙂
Justin Martinez
We haven’t heard much about J-Mart of late. He was originally expected to be the last of our three big pitching pieces back, but it now looks like he’ll beat Puk and Burnes. The last update was on May 10, when Torey Lovullo said Martinez had started throwing bullpens, and was already hitting 99 mph. It is his second Tommy John procedure, so caution is to be expected. But an August return would potentially be a valuable addition to the bullpen for the Diamondbacks, if they are looking to make a second-half push for a postseason spot. The bullpen, while much better than some years, still ranks only mid-table by most metrics.
Carlos Santana
Yeah, I know… However, the bar for the D-backs at 1B has been so incredibly low, that he might still actually be of help. Going into today’s game – where LuJames Groover went 0-for-4, so didn’t help – Arizona’s OPS at 1B was just .569. That is the lowest at the position for a season, by any major-league team since 1920. If Santana could simply hit, not even at his career average, but simply the figure he posted over 124 games last year for the Guardians and Cubs, the resulting ..633 OPS would be a clear improvement over what we’ve received in his absence. With Groover’s OPS now starting with a “3” after today, I suspect he’ll be the move made.
So, which of the players listed above, do you think will have the biggest impact on the team when they return? Here’s a poll, and as ever, feel free to explain yourself in the comments below!
