5-5 will do that to a program. Add a true freshman QB with obvious athleticism coached by the guy who coached Lamar Jackson in college. While the pain of the 2025 season continues to recede, the murky present remains precariously balanced between skepticism and hope. Some see a developing team that will compete for a playoff spot next season as the post-season tournament expands to 24. “The team’s just a few plays away from 8-2 right now.” Others see something much less than that. “This team’s just a few plays away from 2-8.”
Both sentiments have some evidence to support their perspective.
Quick thoughts, in no particular order…
UNC’s defensive game plan against Louisville was A+
Louisville came into the game as one of the most explosive offenses in college football. They averaged 7.76 yards per play, which led the nation. The Cardinals averaged 7.6 against conference competition, so their numbers weren’t boosted by gargantuan stat padding against a couple of creampuffs. UNC held them to just 4.7 yards per play, a full three yards below their season average. That’s a huge accomplishment.
How did they do it? It was a mix of things. For the first time all season, UNC brought pressure from unexpected directions. Greg Smith, usually an eraser on the back end, notched his first sack of the season. UNC didn’t log a ton of pressures, but the combination of varied rushes and coverages had Cardinals QB Lincoln Kienholz struggling to know where to go with the ball. A team with a 17% explosive rate on the season managed 4.6% against UNC.
Teams that live on a diet of explosive plays can start to press on that front if a defense frustrates them. Louisville had one drive where they simply fed their big back, Keyjuan Brown, between the tackles. Brown finished the game with 11 carries for 78 yards — 7.1 per carry — with seven of those carries on that one drive. The rest of the night, Louisville kept trying to get their speedy playmakers into space and force missed tackles, which the Tar Heels usually smothered. UNC made a bet Louisville would be too impatient to grind out the game between the tackles, and it worked.
Bill Belichick has three wins at home, two of them courtesy of FCS rent-a-wins. He’s 1-9 at home against FBS teams.
The one win came last season against a 4-8 Stanford team that finished the year as one of the worst in the P4 and got their coach fired. The nine losses started out as wipe-outs — 34, 23, and 28 point drubbings — but since then, the remaining six have been by a combined 23 points. Two of those came courtesy of Notre Dame and Miami. Still, 1-9 at home against FBS competition is a brutal record. Which brings us to….
Please stop bashing students for failing to cram Kenan Stadium and root rabidly for what’s been a poor product.
This sort of thing needs to end:
No college football team in the history of the sport willed itself into a winning program via game attendance. Win games, and fans will follow. Lose games, and fans will find other ways to spend their precious time and money.
While this team has shown marked improvement from last season (very low bar) and played admirably in spurts (encouraging), it’s failed to seize two huge opportunities this season. A win over what has turned out to be an awful Clemson team had a real chance to get College Game Day to Chapel Hill. A win over what has turned out to be a poor Syracuse team also had a real chance to get College Game Day to Chapel Hill. UNC squandered big leads in both of those games to lose to bad teams.
Yet, there seems to be a new strain growing within the Belichick Apologia that blames attendance, and specifically students, for failing to do their part to help UNC football level up. Nope. Lose eight of nine home games, and people understandably get frustrated seeing the same result over and over again.
The last home game of the season, NC State, feels increasingly like another inflection point for the program, a must-win to head into 2027 with some measure of positive vibes.
Bill Connelly, author of SP+, has Billy Edwards Jr as the 24th best P4 QB so far this season (and Gio as… #1).
#24. Billy Edwards Jr, UNC Tar Heels
September ranking: 63rd Total QBR (last 8 weeks): 73.9 Pass Yds: 1,636 (6.7 yds/db) Rush Yds: 99 (5.0 yds/rush) Total TDs: 15
Until Saturday, Edwards was leading a late-season offensive renaissance — relatively speaking, at least. UNC averaged 31.8 points in a four-week run that included two wins and a near-upset of Miami, but he was poor against Louisville and then left the game because of injury in the third quarter. He’s evidently day-to-day, so I won’t worry about including backup Travis Burgess here, but if Edwards is out, UNC’s odds of grabbing a sixth win diminish.
Efficiency metrics after Louisville: Survey SAYS….
The three big metrics on average now rate UNC the 43rd-best team in the country, static from the Louisville result. The UNC defense over-performed in that game, while the offense underperformed. The offense remains ahead of the defense, although last week’s showing narrowed the gap considerably.
Against FBS competition, UNC now has a positive point differential of +5 (223 points for, 218 points against). It’s a vastly improved team compared to last season, but still with a narrow margin for victory. Nine more total points could have this team at 8-2. 16 less could have it at 2-8.
SP+ was much higher on UNC last season than both FPI and FEI, mostly due to vastly different ratings for the defense. This season, SP+ is the most skeptical of UNC, mostly due to vastly different ratings for the offense. Belichick’s style of play doesn’t necessarily get rewarded more by one metric of the other. No, I haven’t done a deep dive yet on why SP+ has such a different view of the offense than FPI or FEI, but the two primary culprits are probably yards per play (70th nationally, raw stat) and lack of explosive plays (122nd nationally in plays of 20 or more yards, raw stat),
Overall: 43rd (-)
FEI: 38 SP+: 50 FPI: 36
Offense: 40th (down 7)
FEI: 29 SP+: 57 FPI: 33
Defense: 47th (up 6)
FEI: 49 SP+: 46 FPI: 46
ACC Rank: 6th (up 1)
FEI: 5th SP+: 8th FPI: 5th
How tough the schedule looks after nine games (2-4 against P4/ND schools):
FPI rates UNC’s difficulty of schedule so far 20th, while FEI puts the SoS at 15th nationally and SP+ at 14th. FEI thinks so far that the offense has faced a tougher challenge (16th nationally) than the defense (42nd). Reminder: it’s been decades since UNC faced a top 20 strength of schedule. Caveat: Miami and Notre Dame (both well played but losses) elevate these rankings considerably. Syracuse and Clemson increasingly look like missed opportunities, while the W over Duke still looks better with each passing week. So far, UNC under Bill Belichick is 5-13 against P4/ND schools.
Note: Blend is the team’s current ranking average in the three major CFB metrics (SP+, FEI, and FPI) out of 138 teams.
TCU (5-5). Blend 45 (-): UNC won.
TCU beat Kansas State 20-10, bringing the Horned Frogs to 5-5 as well. Nine games later, the tight game in Dublin that came down to one play looks like the obvious result, given how closely these two teams are rated.
ETSU (7-4). Blend N/A: UNC won.
The Bucs beat Wofford 20-17. Massey ranks ETSU 31st among FCS teams this season.
Clemson (6-4). Blend 49 (-): UNC lost.
Clemson lost badly to Georgia Tech and also lost both QBs who’ve started games for Clemson this season. Dabo Swinney yet again pulled out his, “We used to be great, and I’m responsible for that, so I don’t know why y’all are upset” routine in response.
Notre Dame (8-1). Blend 1 (-): UNC lost.
Notre Dame thumped Boston College 41-7 and now prepares for a SMU team that Wake Forest obliterated 49-7 last weekend.
Pittsburgh: (6-4). Blend 41 (-): UNC won.
The Panthers lost to FSU at home 16-10.
Duke (8-2). Blend 29 (-): UNC won.
Duke lost to Miami 36-25, as their two former stars, QB Darian Mensah and WR Cooper Barkate, went off for 382 yards passing and 134 yards receiving respectively.
Syracuse (5-5). Blend 72 (-): UNC lost.
The Orange staged a furious rally late to take down NC State. Maybe the Syracuse should play all their games in the state of North Carolina.
Miami (9-1). Blend 3 (-): UNC lost.
Beat Duke. The Heels at least have that in common with Miami.
Connecticut (5-5). Blend 86 (-): UNC won.
Took down James Madison 46-22.
Louisville (7-3). Blend 15 (-): UNC lost.
We’re on to Virginia.
Virginia (5-5). Blend 60 (-): Virginia romped Cal 36-7 and now stands as a slight favorite at home (-1.5). Both of these teams will be missing key defensive starters and back-ups, so this now looks like a Toss Up.
NC State (4-6). Blend 81 (-): Syracuse came roaring back to edge NC State at the wire on the Pack’s home turf. Until the Pack shows some signs of life, this rates a W.
At the moment, that projects to 6-6 or 7-5.













