WORCESTER, Mass. – Payton Tolle already showed his MLB potential last summer with an electric Fenway Park debut and meaningful innings for the Red Sox in a playoff push.
To start 2026, Tolle finds himself in a much lower-stress environment on the mound. The 2024 second-round pick got thrown into emergency circumstances for several starts with a plethora of starting pitching injuries last year. But Boston upgraded the rotation with the offseason additions of Ranger Suarez, Sonny Gray and Johan Oviedo.
Those moves took the pressure off arms like Tolle and Connelly Early, who now have time to improve their big-league arsenals as depth starters rather than immediate pillars of the rotation. Early got the nod for the Opening Day roster and got the ball for Boston’s series finale in Cincinnati against the Reds. Tolle returned to Triple-A Worcester and also made his first start of 2026 Sunday afternoon.
“I think it’s always just getting ready to go, getting ready to compete,” Tolle said at WooSox Media Day on Thursday. “Because then once the first one starts, it just keeps rolling and I’m excited to get it going, get it started. Because that offseason can get long sometimes. It was the fastest one that I’ve ever had but it feels like I’m ready to go.”
Tolle certainly looked ready to go with two strikeouts in his first inning of work against the Syracuse Mets dialing up his impressive fastball to 97 MPH. That hot start cooled off as Syracuse tagged him for six runs (four earned) in four innings of work, though he did strike out six hitters with 11 swings-and-misses.
His future as a big-league starter revolves around the ability to deepen his arsenal and find legitimate out-pitches among his secondaries. The fastball is real. The lefty knows what he has to show to take the next step.
“I think that it’s definitely come a long way,” Tolle shared. “We now have five pitches that I feel confident in throwing. It’s now just finding the locations of it. I’m not really searching for the grips anymore. I think all the pitches are in where they need to be metrics-wise, and now it’s just trying to get them over the plate, having good misses, putting them where I need to be. So I feel more like a complete pitcher.than I did last year because last year it exposed very early that all I got was a fastball. So I’m excited about it.”
Tolle certainly didn’t lack voices around him at spring training to learn from, whether in the general flow of pitching or in picking the brains of veterans who can spin the baseball.
“I think it was incredible to be able to have (Garrett) Crochet and Sonny (Gray), great guys to learn from,” Tolle said. “Talking to Sonny, like, you talk to guys that have been there, done that, had a ton of success, are able to do it as long as they have. Danny Columbe, another great one, (Garrett) Whitlock, like, we have a bunch of good guys that like talking about baseball and like answering our questions and having that is amazing to young guys like myself. Everybody being able to talk to guys. Me and (Tayron) Guerrero would call (Aroldis) Chapman ‘Sensei.’ We’re excited about it. I feel like it’s a good spot. I think the dynamic of the locker room is really good.”
The Red Sox will surely count on Tolle in a big way through stretches of this season. Even with that reality, he’s nowhere near a finished product. There are going to be ups and downs, such as the scuffles against Syracuse Sunday afternoon.
His responsibilities in 2026? Be ready when your number is called, but don’t be too hard on the ups and downs of the process.
“But I tried to take a step back every day, every night after. Like, ‘OK, what did we do today?’” Tolle explained. “It was good. What did we do today that we can learn from? Because if you just focus on the bad, it’s not going to go very well. Just, ‘what can I learn from, how can I make this take us to the next step?’ Most of that was just something simple, I just need to get my curveball to the floor. We were a little bit low with the heater today, we got to get that up top more. It was trying to be simple with it.”
