Ohio State ended its two-game skid on Saturday, knocking off Northwestern 28-19.
Winning games is obviously better than losing games, and you have to give credit to the Buckeyes for fighting through another rough performance and ultimately earning the victory.
That said, this latest outing didn’t do a whole lot to quiet the doubters or show that Ohio State has learned from its mistakes.
While Ohio State emerged victorious, it felt like they did so largely as a result of a gap in talent between the two
sides. Ryan Day and his staff did very little to actually correct the issues that have plagued the Buckeyes in those prior two losses, even despite the final outcome.
One of the most glaring problems is Matt Patricia’s third down defense, which was again mostly dreadful against Northwestern.
Facing a team starting its backup quarterback, and lacking the supposed QB depth of a program like Ohio State, the Wildcats still managed to convert on 6-of-11 third downs through the game’s first three quarters. It wasn’t as if Northwestern was facing third-and-short either, as their average third down distance to go was 8.5 yards.
Of the seven big plays Ohio State allowed (passes of 15+ yards or runs of 10+ yards), four of them came on third or fourth down. The Buckeyes twice allowed passing plays of 20+ yards on third-and-long, and also gave up a 10-yard run on a third-and-2 late in the second quarter.
After doing a great job of limiting those explosive plays over the first six weeks of the season, Ohio State is now regularly allowing big chunk yardage — and mostly on third down. Patricia did go away from the three-man rushes that have doomed the Buckeyes’ defense in those spots in their prior two games, but they remained unable to get off the field in big spots time and time again.
The most highly paid defensive coordinator in the country has not nearly earned his paycheck this season. Ohio State is routinely getting out-leveraged with too many players stacked to one side, and the middle of the field has been wide open more often than not.
On the other hand, the Buckeyes’ pass rush was significantly improved in this game, as the Silver Bullets racked up five sacks against the Wildcats.
Will Smith Jr.‘s first quarter sack broke a streak of five-straight games (!!) without a single sack from an Ohio State defensive lineman. Kenyatta Jackson led the team with two sacks, the first multi-sack game for a Buckeye this season. Qua Russaw and James Smith also added one sack apiece.
It was definitely a step up on that front, considering Ohio State had registered one sack total against USC and Oregon combined, and it came on a corner blitz by Jermaine Mathews. The bar was extremely low, but it was an encouraging sign from Larry Johnson’s unit.
On the other side of the ball, basically any and all ‘improvement’ can be tied to the increased reliance on Jeremiah Smith, whom the Buckeyes had infamously forgotten about for two full quarters against Oregon.
Arthur Smith this week decided it would be a good idea to get the ball to your generational wide receiver early and often, and that proved successful. Jeremiah Smith finished the game with 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown, and was clearly a focal point for Luke Fahey and the offense.
Fahey himself was fine, but not spectacular. There were a handful of times where the freshman maneuvered his way around the pocket and made a nice play, but there was maybe an equal amount of times where he dirted the ball in front of a wide open receiver.
It seems to be a lot of feast or famine with Fahey, and it doesn’t help when his teammates do him no favors. Fahey threw perhaps his best deep ball as Ohio State’s quarterback against Northwestern, but it was dropped by Chris Henry Jr. on a pass that hit him perfectly in the hands and would have likely been an easy touchdown.
The run game was mostly a point of positivity, even behind an offensive line that was missing two starters.
Bo Jackson led Ohio State with 114 yards on 20 carries and a touchdown, good for 5.7 yards per attempt. Isaiah West added 10 carries for 45 yards, but also had a costly fumble down near the goal line that prevented the Buckeyes from adding points late in the game.
Ohio State fired special teams coordinator Robby Discher last week, but it didn’t change anything for the unit. The Buckeyes muffed a punt on the receiving end, averaged only 43 yards per punt on the kicking end and also allowed a 30-yard punt return. They were, however, gifted a turnover on a muffed punt for Northwestern.
Penalties were better, but remained costly. Ohio State had five penalties for 50 yards, including an illegal block that nullified a 15-yard gain for Devin McCuin and a pair of roughing the passer calls. Legend Bey was also called for taunting after an impressive play, negating the positive gain for the freshman.
At the end of the day, Ohio State won the game, but what really changed from the prior two weeks?
The Buckeyes did a much better job of making Jeremiah Smith the focal point of the offense, and the pass rush picked up a few sacks. Outside of that, we didn’t see a whole lot different from the previous two losses, other than a lesser opponent on the other sideline.
Ohio State’s third down defense has been a nightmare, it is still relying far too often on its terrible tight ends room to make key blocks, and Fahey, while playing a better game overall against the Wildcats, is still incredibly limited and inconsistent at quarterback.
There are positives to take from the victory for sure, but would Ohio State’s performance today have been enough to win them a game against a more talent-equated team like USC and Oregon before them?
It is hard to sit here and say we saw definitive improvement from week to week, and that falls on a coaching staff that has very famously been slow to identify a problem and make the necessary adjustments.
The Buckeyes did enough to win the game on Saturday, and that is important. However, if they have any hope of winning their final two games this season, they need to build on this win and find a way to correct the glaring issues that remain present for this team.













