The Buffalo Bills and Miami Dolphins have been seeing each other twice a year since 1966, and over those 60 years, both teams have had their turn making life miserable for the other.
In the early years, Miami dominated the rivalry, winning championships and making trips to the Super Bowl. Then came the Jim Kelly-Dan Marino era, when two future Hall of Fame quarterbacks battled for AFC supremacy. Kelly and the Bills made four consecutive Super Bowl appearances while Marino never returned after his
lone trip following the 1984 season.
These days, the rivalry belongs mostly to Buffalo. Since Josh Allen arrived in Western New York in 2018, he’s gone 14–3 against Miami, including a playoff victory. The Dolphins have managed to sneak in three wins — just enough to make Allen and the rest of Bills Mafia angry before the next meeting.
But the Dolphins coming to Buffalo this week look very different from the team that challenged the Bills’ hold on the AFC East just a couple of seasons ago. Tua Tagovailoa, Tyreek Hill, and Jaylen Waddle are gone. So are Minkah Fitzpatrick and Bradley Chubb, who now wears a Bills uniform. De’Von Achane is still in Miami but sidelined with an injury. And with starting quarterback Malik Willis also on injured reserve, Kyle McCord is preparing for just his second NFL start.
Miami may have a new look, but that doesn’t mean everyone on its sideline is unfamiliar with Buffalo. Several members of Jeff Hafley’s coaching staff have faced the Bills in previous stops around the league, while others have crossed paths with the coaches now leading Buffalo.
For this week’s Time Capsule, we’re looking beyond the players to revisit some of those coaching connections, the games they’ve been part of, and the history they’re bringing into Sunday’s matchup.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Jim Leonhard vs. Kevin Patullo
Buffalo defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard and Miami passing game coordinator Kevin Patullo have already been on opposite sidelines, and their last meeting didn’t end particularly well for Patullo. In October 2025, Leonhard was Denver’s assistant head coach and defensive passing game coordinator, while Patullo was running Philadelphia’s offense.
The Eagles entered the game undefeated and looked ready to stay that way, building a 17–3 lead early in the third quarter. But Denver’s defense kept Philadelphia off the scoreboard for the remainder of the afternoon, giving the Broncos’ offense time to mount a comeback.
Philadelphia quarterback Jalen Hurts completed 23 of 38 passes for 280 yards and two touchdowns, but Denver sacked him six times. The Eagles managed just 45 rushing yards and converted only two of 11 third-down attempts. After scoring on their opening possession of the second half, they never reached the end zone again.
Denver scored 18 unanswered points in the fourth quarter to win 21–17, handing Philadelphia its first loss of the season.
Patullo has some history with Buffalo, too. He spent three seasons with the Bills from 2010–12 before eventually landing in Philadelphia, where he was part of two victories over Josh Allen. The first came in November 2023, when Allen accounted for 420 yards and four touchdowns, only to watch Jalen Hurts score the winning touchdown in overtime. Philadelphia also edged Buffalo 13–12 in December 2025, despite struggling offensively throughout the afternoon. Now Patullo will be helping Miami offensive coordinator Bobby Slowik prepare for Leonhard’s defense.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Joe Brady vs. Bobby Slowik
Buffalo head coach Joe Brady and Miami offensive coordinator Bobby Slowik were on opposite sidelines in October 2024, when Brady was running the Bills’ offense and Slowik was calling plays for the Houston Texans. It was an afternoon Allen and the Bills would probably prefer to forget.
Houston jumped out to a 20–3 lead behind quarterback C.J. Stroud, who finished with 331 passing yards and a touchdown. Meanwhile, Allen struggled through one of the least productive passing performances of his career, completing just nine of 30 attempts for 131 yards.
Buffalo eventually fought its way back, tying the game at 20 in the fourth quarter. But with the score still tied and less than a minute remaining, the Bills took possession deep in their own territory and threw three consecutive incompletions. Houston got the ball back with enough time to set up Ka’imi Fairbairn’s 59-yard field goal as time expired, giving the Texans a 23–20 victory.
Now Brady is Buffalo’s head coach, and Slowik is running Miami’s offense. Will Brady’s experience against Slowik in Houston give him something useful to share with defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard as the Bills prepare for Sunday’s matchup?
_____________________________________________________________________________
Pete Carmichael Jr. vs. Joe Barry
Buffalo offensive coordinator Pete Carmichael Jr. and Miami senior defensive assistant and run game coordinator Joe Barry have faced each other twice as coordinators, with each coming away with a win. Both meetings came when Carmichael was running the New Orleans Saints’ offense and Barry was Green Bay’s defensive coordinator.
The first was in September 2021, when New Orleans handed Green Bay a 38–3 loss. Jameis Winston threw five touchdown passes, despite finishing with just 148 passing yards. The Saints scored on five of their first seven possessions, while Barry’s defense struggled to find an answer for Carmichael’s offense.
The second meeting, in September 2023, went much differently. New Orleans led 17–0 at halftime, but quarterback Derek Carr left the game with a shoulder injury in the third quarter. That put Winston back under center against Barry’s defense, but there would be no repeat of his five-touchdown performance. This time Barry had an answer for Winston, and the Saints failed to score again. Green Bay put up 18 points in the fourth quarter to win 18–17.
Barry figured out how to stop Winston the second time around, but he’ll have a different challenge Sunday. Carmichael now has Josh Allen running his offense, while Barry is working with a young Miami defense that has been surprisingly effective despite its inexperience. Whether that group can slow down Allen is another question — one we will get an answer to on Sunday.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Familiar Faces
There may be plenty of familiar names and shared history between these coaching staffs, but none of that will matter much once the ball is kicked off Sunday. By the end of the afternoon, they’ll have another game to add to their résumés — the only question is how that entry will read.













