NFL Draft evaluation is an imperfect art form. Despite decades and decades of experience and more and more resources devoted to ensuring a team gets their pick “right,” NFL general managers, scouts, and other front office members continually get it wrong. Whether it’s overlooking a flaw, failing to discover a character question, lacking similar visions with a coaching staff, or taking on too many gambles with a player, we constantly see some of the smartest people in football get the NFL Draft wrong time
after time.
There is no foolproof plan. The best talent evaluators are going to swing and miss from time to time, and nowhere is that clearer than with the Detroit Lions. General manager Brad Holmes pulled off three incredible draft classes from 2021 to 2023, but 2024 has been borderline disastrous (though only through two years), and it’s too early to say anything about 2025.
Still, every front office needs to have a coherent strategy in order to maximize its chances of hitting in the draft. So today’s Question of the Day is:
What is the most important aspect of talent evaluation in the NFL Draft?
My answer: I think film remains the most important thing, but I am starting to shift my thinking a bit.
Obviously, an athlete needs to be able to play. It’s not just about physical attributes they show in their play, but how well they understand the game. Can the read a defense? Can they anticipate what the opponent is going to do before they do it? Can they play in multiple schemes and positions? Do coaches trust them all over the field?
But having covered the Lions over the past five years, I do think “football character” carries more weight than many fans, analysts, and even NFL teams place on it. Most college prospects are going to hit a wall early in their NFL careers. The talent jump is massive, and those who have spent their entire lives being the best player on the team are often in for rude awakenings when they’re no longer the main character on the team. The players who can handle that frustration best, rise to the occasion, and continue to put in the work will have the best chance of succeeding. Not many in the NFL can make it without that ability, no matter how talented.
What characteristics do you value most in an NFL prospect when it comes to scouting the draft? Share your thoughts in the comment section below.
