The San Francisco 49ers and Dallas Cowboys came close to reaching 100 points in Week 10. It was a game where defense was optional. The offenses had their way. Big plays were the norm, and two of the league’s most potent offenses didn’t disappoint.
Let’s get into the Winners and Losers from Week 10.
Winners
Brock Purdy
We try to stay away from listing core players in this section. Even Purdy’s biggest naysayers can’t use this performance or “it’s the Cowboys’ defense” against him.
Purdy led all quarterbacks in Week 10 with
a 0.77 EPA per pass. Second-place Matthew Stafford was 0.63. Purdy had the second-highest passing success rate at 63.6%. He completed nearly 80% of his passes and threw for three touchdowns. Sprinkle in a couple of much-needed scrambles, and it was your typical ho-hum performance from Purdy this season.
Five sacks may be alarming — you could argue only one was on the offensive line — but those were offset by 3 completions of 20+ yards in the air. A couple of improv plays off-script where Purdy manipulated the pocket around him, made unblocked defenders miss, and created first downs (one was a touchdown) when nothing was there.
There’s more evidence that shows Purdy’s excellence from Sunday. The offense averaged 0.48 EPA per play, the highest of any offense this season.
Purdy sliced and diced the Cowboys against man coverage. He completed 12 of 16 passes against man coverage for 273 yards and three touchdowns. That was the most yards in a game facing man coverage by any player since 2021. When Purdy scrambled, he was 4-for-4 for 135 yards and a touchdown. That number ties Patrick Mahomes (W4 2018) and Josh Allen (W15 2024) for the most scramble passing yards in a game since 2018. Against the blitz, Purdy went 6-for-6 for 197 yards and two scores.
Christian McCaffrey
McCaffrey topped 20 mph on his 66-yard touchdown. He did a fantastic job making himself available and getting into Purdy’s line of sight on the 74-yard touchdown.
Surprisingly, McCaffrey had a rushing success rate of only 23.1%. But he made several impact plays on those carries, gained 35 yards after contact, forced two missed tackles, and had two 10+ yard runs, including a 16-yard touchdown.
CMC is here because of his work through the air. He had a third-down target where he beat Caleb Downs for a much-needed first down. McCaffrey came through in the clutch when the offense needed a big play.
McCaffrey became the first running back in NFL history with multiple 65+ yard touchdown receptions in the same game. He had the most receiving yards by a running back since Jamaal Charles’s 195 yards in Week 15 of 2013.
Kaelon Black
Welcome to the show, rook.
Black forced three missed tackles — two of them on one play. He had 53 rush yards, 44 of which came after contact. Again, the success rate was below average (27.3%), but the big plays more than make up for it. Black contributed 13 yards through the air, but he’s here for running over a first-down and finishing in the end zone.
Deebo Samuel
Deebo had a 70-yard touchdown on a play where Cowboys defenders didn’t figure out he had the ball until he was 20 yards downfield. Samuel had two other carries for four yards. He caught a screen for a touchdown. He had two other catches for 20 yards. He was efficient, effective, and electric. Samuel ran just under 20 miles per hour on his touchdown run.
Keenan Allen
I’d argue that Allen helped get the offense off the mat. The player who wasn’t on the roster this time last week had the second-most targets. Allen caught five passes for 61 yards. He had a 25% target share — which is Mike Evans territory.
Four of Allen’s receptions resulted in a first down, and he should’ve had five if Purdy didn’t miss him toward the end of the game.
We expected Allen to be impactful underneath, but he showed that he can create separation at the intermediate level of the field, both on in- and out-breaking routes.
Jordan Watkins
Watkins kicked things off with a 22-yard reception. He had a 27-yarder where Purdy bought time, waiting for someone to get open, while Watkins picked himself up off the ground and made himself available. It was only two catches, but Watkins has proven to be a big-play threat.
Watkins had a couple of blocks that helped spring plays for the offense. He’s developing nicely and rounding into a complete player.
George Kittle
Kittle had a 20+ yard screen pass. He had four first-down receptions on nine targets. Every time he touched the ball, it felt like an impact play. Kittle caught three of his four contested targets, something he struggled with over the past couple of games. He had 46 yards after the catch. It wasn’t a vintage Kittle day, but if 74 yards feels like an off day, you know you’re dealing with a star.
Losers
Connor Colby
Of the 115 offensive linemen to play at least 50 snaps in Week 10, Colby ranked 112th with a 17.1% pressure rate allowed. He had six pressures. Usually, Colby makes up for it in the run game. That was not the case on Sunday. You try to give the seventh-rounder some grace, especially going against Quinnen Williams. But you have to be competitive, and Colby simply was not. His lows are in the basement, and teams will start going out of their way to stress Colby.
Deommodore Lenoir
Lenoir was targeted 17 times against Dallas. That is not a typo. Over half of those came in the first half. That’s the third-most targets for a cornerback in a game since 2022.
Coming into the game, Renardo Green was up against CeeDee Lamb, and Lenoir was up against George Pickens. On the surface, it makes sense. Put your better corner on their best receiver, and try to minimize the damage.
Lenoir broke up the first two passes his way on the first drive, and you thought, ‘OK, he’s confident, and will hold his own.‘ Dallas completed the next five passes his way. We’ll talk ad nauseam about the pass rush, but the coverage was worse, and Lenoir is leading the charge.
It’s 46-32. 1:56 remains. Keion White beats his man cleanly. Dak Prescott gets hit at the top of his drop. Lenoir allows an 11-yard curl to Pickens. First down.
Far too many occurrences where there was pressure, but the coverage wasn’t in a position to contest the throw. Despite all those targets, Lenoir forced tight-window throws only 25% of the time. That’s not competitive. You don’t have a chance to survive.
Interior line play
The Cowboys ran 76 plays. Let’s add some context to the poor play. The defensive line was clearly gassed and running on fumes. With that said, the interior was getting pushed around in the first half, and fortunate Dallas didn’t run the ball on them more.
Osa Odighizuwa had three run stops and four pressures. That’s about as well as he can play. DeForest Buckner had three pressures. Sebastian Valdez had two, and James Thompson had one. Pass-rush win rate is a better indicator of how a player performed. Only Odighizuwa was in the double digits. Buckner, who played 55 snaps and 39 pass-rushing snaps, only won on 5.1% of his rushes. He has to be better.
Epeshians Prysock
A tough spot for a rookie to get extended action. Prysock went in for Renardo Green after Green left with a back injury. Prysock played 28 snaps. He allowed all three of his targets to be completed for 28 yards, including a touchdown. He also missed a tackle. Prysock didn’t need to grab the receiver in the end zone, since he was already in position. That penalty nearly cost the Niners the game.
Penalties
The 49ers have been sloppy for three weeks now, and the penalties are starting to add up. They had 11 against Dallas, giving the Cowboys a full football field (100 yards) of penalties. The Cowboys had four first downs from penalties.
The operation was smooth for the first month and a half of the season, but the Niners have been trending in the wrong direction with the zebras.
The refs
Bring on the robots. It’s time. Malik Mustapha had a picture-perfect hit. The refs huddled up, talked it over, and still decided Mustapha made illegal contact. Why couldn’t replay assist chime in?
I counted at least four times when George Kittle fought through illegal contact during a route. There was an obvious penalty on a third-down target that wasn’t called. You don’t expect perfection from the refs, but some of the calls and non-calls in this game were egregious.
Late-down defense
If you break up the 49ers into late and early downs, it’s a tale of two games. The Cowboys were in the 56th percentile running the ball on early downs, compared to the 100th percentile on late downs.
Forcing the Cowboys into 21 late-down conversions is a sign that you’re doing your job on early downs. But Dallas converted 11 of those, including 4-of-5 on fourth down.
It was a unique challenge, and only two or three other teams can attack the Niners the way Dallas did, but it’s still no excuse to allow as many plays or give up as many late-down conversions as the Niners did.
IDKs
The pass rush
Again, 76 plays. Dallas had drives of 8, 11, 7, 7, 8, 10, and 12. Good things do not happen when you’re on the field that often.
We touched on Odighizuwa’s production. The edge-rushing group won, and they did so far more than most fans are willing to admit. Remember, coming into this game, Prescott was the fifth-least-sacked quarterback in the NFL. Last week, Kirk Cousins was second. Context is key when we’re talking about sacks.
Among the edge rushers who played at least 50 snaps in Week 10, Nick Bosa ranked third in pass-rush win rate at 15.8%. Bosa had five pressures and would’ve forced a turnover had Dre Greenlaw caught the ball. That removes one score off the board.
I mentioned the Keion White QB hit on third down when Lenoir wasn’t in position. The Niners hit Prescott 10 times. That’s in the 95th percentile.
Filtering it down to at least 25 pass-rush snaps, White was 19th in pass-rush win rate, and Mykel Williams was 21st. That’s three players in the top 21. Mykel had a sack that was negated by a penalty (on Lenoir, of course), and that led to points.
That’s three plays where you’re taking three scoring drives off the board. We’d be having a much different conversation about the pass rush if the secondary didn’t make a mistake. But it’s a results-based business, and there were no sacks, so it’s understandable why there’s an uproar. Still, you have to ignore a ton of data to think the Niners didn’t get after Prescott in Week 10. That’s not accurate.
Winners
Renardo Green
Green matched up against Lamb and limited him to 23 yards on three catches. He held Pickens to 14 yards on three targets. Renardo also broke up a pass. It was a nice bounce-back for Green, who didn’t back down from the challenge the Cowboys presented.
Malik Mustapha
Mustapha played 59 snaps, which led the way for the three-man rotation. Ji’Ayir Brown played 57, while Marques Sigle played 44. The rotation needs to end. Not saying it would have made a difference, but Dallas scored when Mustapha wasn’t on the field.
They targeted Mustapha four times, and he broke up two passes and intercepted another. He did have a penalty and missed a tackle, but it’s clear to anyone with eyes that he’s one of the only reliable players in the secondary. In my mind, he’s closer to a Pro Bowl starter than an average one.













