With summer upon us, I recently found myself alone on a long, quiet drive home after dropping my daughter off for camp with her grandparents. As the miles rolled by and the hum of the tires turned over old memories, I wandered down a self-inflicted rabbit hole about how the brain works. Eventually, I landed on a fun mental exercise: if a buddy had gone into a coma before a Yankees player’s first start in pinstripes and woke up today, how would I explain everything they had missed?
Several players
proved better than others at filling time, but one player actually occupied the entire back nine of my drive as I found myself questioning both my own conclusions and the results from my hands-free mobile assistant. That player was none other than tonight’s starter, Carlos Rodón.
Using what you know now about Rodón, how would you describe his time in pinstripes to a friend who has missed this ride? For me, the starting point was to describe him as the Yankees’ new “big” lefty. Essentially the Ozempic CC Sabathia. Yes, I did crack myself up knowing I then have to explain what that meant. But, Rodón is the latest power lefty Brian Cashman has fallen in love with.
That was where that comparison stopped though. Rodón is no CC. However, his overall numbers in pinstripes actually line up well compared to another pitcher from the end of that era and the torch barrier after, Masahiro Tanaka. What numbers could those possibly be? Winning percentage, ERA, and WHIP.
For Rodón and Tanaka, respectively, those numbers in their Yankees careers are .588 and .629, 3.96 and 3.74, and 1.183 and 1.130. It is also worth noting that Tanaka was excellent during his first three seasons. If you isolate his final four regular seasons in New York, however, he posted a .565 winning percentage, 4.27 ERA, and 1.203 WHIP.
Tanaka ended up being a great comparison. In addition to the statistical similarities and being able to say, “we have a regular-season Tanaka chance to win tonight,” their first impressions were literally the exact opposite. Tanaka rode in on a big stallion, taking the city by storm before that dang UCL cut his dominant rookie campaign short. Rodón, on the other hand, got hurt in March and then turned in one of the worst seasons of his career.
Rodón’s debut season also had him send the kiss rejected around the Bronx. That moment, along with his body language when things go either right or wrong, reminded me of another Yankees pitcher: former big-ticket free agent signing A.J. Burnett. The righty from central Arkansas helped the Yankees to the 2009 World Series title, but other than that his time in pinstripes is remembered for the lows.
Burnett was famously intense, and the energy was infectious. However, that infection happened whether the energy was good or bad. Rodón is cut from that same cloth. There might be a game when you watch and say you’re glad the Yankees have that guy as he works himself into and out of a jam. Then the next start he issues five walks, give up a couple long home runs, and give some objects the old Paul O’Neil treatment in the dugout.
Rodón has never hidden his emotions, for better or worse. That emotional volatility has become just as much a part of his Yankees identity as his mid-90s fastball. It is also what makes every turn through the rotation feel like a rollercoaster ride and a true dice roll.
Like a true Yankees fan, my hypothetical friend always wanted to know what the guy has done in October. That is where I had to give them the happy/sad update that the Knicks have won a title, but our Yankees had not.
In addition to not having a ring, in 2024, Rodón went 1-2 with a 5.60 ERA and in 2025 he went 0-0 with a 9.72 ERA in two October starts. Unlike Tanaka, whose performances in the clutch, or when the lights are brightest if you will, elevated him to near-legendary status among Yankees fans, Rodón is still waiting for the playoff run that changes how people view him. A ring would help insulate him from criticism down the road, much like it has done for Burnett, but Rodón still has a lot of work to do to fully earn his pinstripes for most fans.
Essentially, where I landed on any other Tuesday night in June, just after the summer solstice: Rodón is a lot like watching Tanaka pitch in the regular season. However, if he does not have his command, it is hard not to feel like you are watching a left-handed version of Burnett. After a bad first impression, Rodón has proven to be easy to cheer for, even though sometimes he is hard to watch.
Most nights when he takes the ball, he gives the Yankees a chance to win. Some nights he even looks dominant enough that if you pulled out a notebook and pencil you just might find yourself writing down ace-like stuff. But then occasionally, the engine overheats and the tires come off. Either way, tonight the Yankees hand the ball to their big lefty. Here is to hoping we get Dón Dominance tonight, and not a dud.
