For all the drama surrounding the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes, and the will they or won’t they position the Tigers were in as the trade deadline approached, the Detroit Tigers ultimately kept to just two notable trades. They got good value for both Skubal and Casey Mize, but at the same time didn’t really address their biggest weakness in their high leverage relief corps. As they still seem bent on trying to secure a wild card slot, it’s a bit of a peculiar mixed bag in terms of their intentions, but ultimately their trades have
to be viewed as punting on the 2026 season without simply giving everything away to slash payroll. They had two valuable assets heading to free agency, and they did a solid job of cashing them in for good prospects with which to restock their farm system.
The Tigers currently have the 17th best odds of making the postseason and are +590 on FanDuel’s sportsbook to do so at the moment. FanGraphs is more optimistic, giving them a 22.6 percent chance of reaching the playoffs. It helps that they’re not entirely out of the divisional race, as well as having the shot at a wild card berth and currently just 2.5 games back of the final spot.
Those odds still aren’t great, and with Skubal and Mize out of the rotation, and no attempt to address the bullpen, those odds will also have to be adjusted to reflect the significantly weaker starting rotation they’ll be working with down the stretch. Ultimately, while the Tigers will say they’re still trying to make the postseason and will do what they can with what they have to do so, the totality of their moves adds up to capitulation without going whole hog and trying to dump the salaries of players like Gleyber Torres, Jack Flaherty, or Kenley Jansen.
Of course, teams have to want those players, and with Flaherty injured, and Jansen struggling, there wasn’t going to be much, if any, interest. Still, the decision not to deal Torres is the really interesting one. He wouldn’t return a whole lot in trade, but he’s also potentially blocking a currently hot-hitting prospect in Max Anderson. Perhaps Anderson will get the call anyway and they’ll simply piece together at-bats for the Anderson/Torres duo, but the best reason to keep Torres is to have that extra, professional right-handed bat in the lineup against the best teams in the postseason.
Overall, we’ll take the Tigers for what they did do, rather than trying to piece together why other moves weren’t pursued. The slightly mixed signals here make it tricky to figure out what they’re thinking in regard to their hopes to at least get into the postseason. The trades suggest a team throwing in the towel, and as sellers, they did pretty well overall. On the other hand, their proximity to a wild card berth, says they still have an outside shot. So declining to go after relief help was strange when that’s been the team’s main problem all season long. Whatever their intentions or hopes the rest of the season, they sold off talent and got quality prospect packages in return, and so we’ll grade them like a team that decided to cash in their chips rather than trying to sustain the momentum they built with their strong run in June and July. Threading the needle between selling and contending doesn’t appear to have been the plan at the end of the day.
Letter grades are a crude tool, but we’ll give the Tigers a solid B+ here. They didn’t land the dream package for Tarik Skubal, but they did better than many expected for a rental ace who hasn’t been at peak form for most of the 2026 season. The Casey Mize deal looks very good, especially as his injury issues have flared up again recently. The Padres may regret that one, and they have completely hollowed out their farm system in the process of adding Mize and lefty Robbie Ray from the Giants.
The Tigers didn’t quite land one of the top prospects the Dodgers could’ve offered, which would’ve taken this to an A grade, but that organization is so flush with top 100 outfielders that Zyhir Hope, despite drawing 50 and 55 grades depending on who you ask, wasn’t even one of their top three outfield prospects according to the major national prospect sites, at least. Either way, Hope is a really talented young player and will slot in as the Tigers top positional prospect over Bryce Rainer and Josue Briceño on many lists.
They chose the risk/reward play in River Ryan rather than holding out for a safer but significantly less talented starting pitcher like Emmet Sheehan or Justin Wrobleski, so they did take a chance there. The way their deadline work is viewed in retrospect may have a lot to do with whether the 27-year-old Ryan can ever stay on the mound consistently. Finally, they added two young pitching prospects in RHP Brady Smith and LHP Kash Mayfield who are still raw but talented enough to develop into mid-rotation starters within a few years time. Considering the lack of pitching development in the system over the past few years, this really improves their group of legitimate pitching prospects and, along with 2026 first round pick RHP Cameron Flukey, balances out the system pretty nicely at a point where a really strong young core of talent has already reached the Tigers major league roster.
Brought to you by FanDuel Sportsbook, the official sportsbook partner of SB Nation.
