With the announcement that conference championship games will end after the 2026 season as part of the 24-team CFB playoff expansion, I’ve been thinking a lot about Ohio State’s history and relationship with the Big Ten Championship game — and what it will say about the program if they miss out on the final occurrence.
In some ways, it would make for a poetic bookend. The last time the Buckeyes lost three games in a season was the inaugural year of the Big Ten Championship.
After finishing 6-7 having
been rocked by the Tattoogate scandal, Ohio State didn’t exactly get off on the right foot with the game, held annually in Indianapolis. They missed the following year, too—a 12-0 regular season in which they did not qualify for the Big Ten Championship because of the Tattoogate bowl ban.
Still, the Big Ten Championship game is supposed to be the Buckeyes’ territory. Despite their rocky start, OSU has been one of the defining programs, with appearances in 2013, 2014, 2025, and every year from 2017-2020, winning in 2014 and taking four straight from 2017 on.
In fact, since the game began in 2011, the Buckeyes have more appearances (seven) and wins (five) than any other program in the Big Ten (though I should note, six of the current Big Ten teams were not part of the conference in 2011).
There was a time when the Big Ten Championship game was an expectation rather than a special occasion, an annual chance for Ohio State to reaffirm its position as the standard-bearer for the conference.
Though OSU still has a path to Indianapolis this season, their 7-3 record and two conference losses have narrowed the road significantly, leaving the Buckeyes reliant upon a chaotic combination of other teams’ wins and losses in the final two weeks of the regular season.
Indiana has to lose to either Washington or Purdue, for example (which seems unlikely), as just one part of a very complicated “If this AND this AND this all happen” laundry list.
In short, it’s not happening unless something miraculous goes down. Which means it’s increasingly likely that, despite their storied history with the conference championship game, the Buckeyes might be watching the final iteration from their couches.
Missing the Big Ten Championship, while disappointing, isn’t the real concern for me, though I do think it’s sad that the Buckeyes are potentially going to see the conference championship disappear without reclaiming their title. Instead, I’m concerned more with what it says about the program that the Buckeyes have gone five consecutive seasons without winning in Indianapolis.
That’s right: The Buckeyes haven’t won a Big Ten Championship game since 2020, the COVID season. They didn’t even qualify for the game in 2024, the year they went on to win the National Championship.
While you could certainly argue that the Big Ten Championship holds less meaning in the 12-team playoff era, since the real goal is the CFP title, the Buckeyes are supposed to compete for Big Ten championships. Winning the conference has been part of the program’s identity for generations, even predating the existence of a championship game.
Five—likely about to be six—consecutive seasons without a conference championship is an extraordinary drought for a program with Ohio State’s resources, recruiting advantages and expectations. The sting gets a little worse when you consider Ohio State has remained nationally relevant and continued to put themselves in position to compete for major postseason honors.
We’re not talking about a below-average team or program who’s been floundering or wandering onto the field aimlessly for half a decade.
The burn gets hotter when you remember Michigan won three consecutive titles in that time (2021-2023). It reaches a peak when you remember how the 2025 Big Ten Championship—OSU’s only appearance since 2020—ended (with the Hoosiers winning 13-10 after the Buckeyes missed a 27-yard field goal).
It’s interesting that the Buckeyes have, for the better part of the last six years, been a great team—a national champion, even—but have not been the team that won their conference.
Certainly, the Big Ten expansion has changed the equation: The conference is deeper, the regular season travel requirements are different, and the path to Indy has a few more speed bumps. But the conference has changed for everyone, not just Ohio State, so it’s almost more frustrating that the Buckeyes haven’t figured out how to adapt.
Timing is everything, and the Buckeyes choosing this season—their final opportunity to reclaim the conference title—to go 7-3 is a bummer. It means their drought will ultimately be a defining historical footnote.
This season is not going down as a successful one no matter how the next few weeks shake out. No 7-3 season should be considered a success at a program like Ohio State. But the bigger question for me is how we’re evaluating success for this program in the first place.
Let’s take that previously mentioned 2024 national championship season: Playoff appearances and national championships are increasingly treated as the most important measure of a program’s success, so by all measures, the season was a success despite the fact that OSU lost to Michigan and failed to win the conference. In fact, at the time, even I was arguing I didn’t care about the conference title so long as they won it all.
Hindsight is 20/20, because now that we know the conference championship is going away at the end of this season, I’m feeling frustrated by the fact that winning the conference has seemingly stopped mattering at all.
Ohio State doesn’t need to win every Big Ten game or title to justify its standing as an elite program, but it should be expected to consistently position itself to win the conference. So while Ryan Day has accomplished a lot with the program, as he faces additional scrutiny given the team’s collapse this year, I’d also question why conference dominance doesn’t seem to hold weight for him.
That the Buckeyes haven’t won a post-COVID title feels like a legitimate aspect of his tenure we should be evaluating. And as the conference championship game disappears at the end of this season, it feels like a strange way to end the team’s legacy with the game.
The Buckeyes still have a chance, however slim, to get there. If they don’t, the program will have to live with this particular chapter of its history, but in a future without the Big Ten Championship game, I hope Day and his team can redefine what success looks like in the conference without lowering the expectations that they win it.













