What is the story about?
After each game, we’ll be sharing a comprehensive review that breaks down some of the controversial decisions from the officiating crew in the game. You may disagree in some cases, and that’s fine…
Penalty Count
Bills 7-35 (leading to zero Jets first downs)
Jets 7-53 (leading to two Bills first downs)
Note: This does not include penalties that are declined or off-set.
Plays where the call was obvious, uncontroversial or not visible on broadcast footage
Jets Penalties
- Defensive holding on Kingsley Enagbare on 3rd-and-goal at the one-yard line. There is no argument here as Enagbare, who was initially engaged as he would have been assuming his man was a blocker, had a fistful of jersey as the receiver tried to get away from him.
- Offensive holding on Joe Tippmann to negate a 19-yard Garrett Wilson catch. There was a loss of leverage here and his man beat him into the backfield while he was still reaching across and holding on, so this was probably reasonable.
- Olu Fashanu false start. Flinch before the snap.
- Too many men on the field on 1st-and-goal at the nine-yard line. Not sure what happened here, but Breece Hall seemed to be the only player who came off the field after it. You can say it had an impact because Hall caught a 10-yard pass two plays later which would have been a touchdown.
- Malik McClain holding penalty to negate a nice Isaiah Davis kickoff return. Lost leverage and pulled his man back, then dragged him to the ground.
- Armand Membou false start. Not sure about this one, as no movement from Membou or any other Jet was obvious from broadcast footage.
Bills Penalties
- Michael Hoecht offside on a punt. Jumped early. This took it from 4th-and-6 to 4th-and-short but the Jets were too close to their end zone to risk going for it.
- Ed Oliver neutral zone infraction, also on 4th-and-6. Reacted to the hard count. This time the Jets converted on the next play.
- Dawson Knox false start. Went very slightly early as the ball was being snapped.
- Dion Dawkins false start on a field goal. Well spotted by the officials as Dawkins shifted his weight before the ball was snapped.
- Offside on Bradley Chubb. Went early. This didn’t matter because Wilson caught a 25-yard pass anyway.
- Alec Anderson false start. Big flinch before the snap.
- Illegal shift on 3rd-and-7. Basically had two men in motion at the same time as the ball was snapped. Certainly neither was set for a full second.
- Hoecht offside again. Went early, but again it didn’t matter as Breece Hall ran for a first down.
- Spencer Hawes false start. Flinched, reacting to the right tackle moving but because he wanted to turn around and clarify something with Josh Allen.
Plays that require further
discussion
Jets Penalties
- Malachi Moore defensive pass interference. There was some hand-fighting going on here but it looked for all the world like Moore made every effort NOT to grab or impede the receiver’s ability to make the catch. It was reminiscent of one of those NBA plays where the person with the ball deliberately tucks his defender’s arm under his own to create the illusion of defense-initiated contact.
- Offensive pass interference on Mason Taylor to negate a 45-yard catch-and-run for Isaiah Williams. Collided with the defensive player trailing Williams on a crosser. In real time, it looked like Taylor changed direction and made a bee-line for the defensive player when the design of this play calls for him to make his initial route look naturally like it just happened to get in his way a bit. However, to a degree, it’s possible Taylor’s man was leaning on him a bit, perhaps cognisant of what was happening, which forced him into a collision. As for the defender Taylor blocked off, you need to contrast this with what Azareye’h Thomas did last week. In a similar situation, he actively avoided the contact and went around the defender, leading to a 31-yard gain, instead of letting the contact happen and drawing the flag. That’s likely because he knows there’s a chance they won’t get the call, whereas the Bills player was obviously confident he would.
Bills Penalties
- Illegal use of the hands on Davison Igbinosun. This was on the same play where Williams long catch-and-run did not count, and offset the Taylor flag. There was fairly incidental contact on Adonai Mitchell’s facemask but the Jets had a couple of big ones similar to this, including one on Thomas that negated an interception against the Bears. The difference here is that the receiver did not initiate the contact by leaning or ducking into the attempted jam as was the case on those two Jets penalties.
Notable no-calls etc
Here were some of the other notable missed calls, replay situations and controversial moments:
- Brandon Stephens’ early third down stop on James Cook was correctly marked short and also correctly not ruled as a fumble as his elbow hit before the ball was jarred loose. The fumble rolled out of bounds for what would have been a couple of yards loss to prevent it from being a makeable 4th-and-1.
- It goes without saying that every Bills’ tush push was a textbook example of “assisting the runner” but the NFL has turned a blind eye to that for years. The Jets ran their own, which didn’t have anything as egregious as Dalton Kincaid literally shoving Allen like a grocery cart across the line to gain.
- DJ Moore wanted pass interference on Stephens downfield early on but the no call was probably right. Stephens was leaning a hand on Moore quite a bit though, which isn’t a great habit even if you’re not actively preventing him from going in the direction he wants to.
- On the play where Omar Cooper got hurt, the block was legal as he timed it right after the pass was released. However, there could have been two penalties on the Bills here – a facemask on the player who tackled Kenyon Sadiq and an illegal hands to the face call on the play who shoved Cooper back.
- There was no defensive pass interference on the deep ball that Geno Smith underthrew to Mitchell. If only it was a worse underthrow – then Mitchell would have been drawn into Christian Benford, whose head was not turned, to create obviously flaggable contact.
- The electronic measurement system, which is pointless anyway because it still uses the official’s on-field spotting of the ball, had Cook marked less than an inch short on one play.
- The officials overlooked a blatant bear-hug by O’Cyrus Torrence on Harrison Phillips on a short yardage conversion. He literally had him wrapped up to prevent him from getting lateral, but you get away with these kinds of things on the interior.
- On Khalil Shakir’s jet sweep, Keon Coleman had his hand on the outside of Moore’s shoulder, pulling him back slightly from getting outside. He did let go of this pretty quickly, though.
- Brown flinched slightly before one of Buffalo’s successful sneaks and the officials did not notice.
- Benford had early contact with two hands on Wilson on a high throw to the pylon before half time. Under the old rules maybe that was uncatchable but that’s not a thing these days.
- The controversial hit on Smith had Aaron Glenn saying there’s no way they don’t make the same call if it was Josh Allen and he has a point. The difficulty here is that Smith initially starts to run and then sets and throws. To be clear on the rules, you’re not a defenseless player if you are attempting to run outside the pocket, but a helmet-to-helmet hit can still be called on a non-defenseless player. Additionally, he did ultimately throw the ball so roughing the passer can still be called even though he is outside the pocket. This could have been a flag if there was a low hit, but in this instance the Bills player was initially going in for the tackle and actively tried to roll away from contact as he saw the throw coming out. However, there could also be roughing for a late hit, or forcible contact to the head/neck area. There could also be a launching penalty because the player making the hit had one foot off the ground as he propelled himself at Smith. Maybe he led with the shoulder, maybe initial contact was below the neck area but the fact there was obvious forcible contact, a launch component and incidental contact to the head/neck after the initial hit means there was enough here to draw a flag. If you’re Josh Allen. (Regardless of what Gene Steratore says).
- Minkah Fitzpatrick had a hit on Allen near the sideline but it wasn’t late and was a two-handed shove to the chest, so that shouldn’t have been flagged and in this case wasn’t.
- Membou had his helmet knocked off again but, once again, didn’t get a call for illegal hands to the face. It looked clear that Oliver caused this by shoving at his chinstrap and the lower part of his facemask.
- One no-call that went in the Jets’ favor was Wilson pushing off at the top of his route to make a first down catch.
- It looked like Kincaid might have gone out of bounds further upfield on his long catch-and-run but he actually stayed in.
- Another hit on Smith that could have been flagged was when Cole Bishop dived at him to knock him down. This wasn’t a particularly dangerous or forceful hit, and wasn’t that late, but he easily could have pulled out of the hit and, as we know from the likes of Steratore trying to justify marginal-looking calls against the Jets in the past, that should lead to a penalty (for example the one on David Bailey a few games ago). There was also a launch component, although he led with the hands.
- On his touchdown catch, Moore was worried he might have fumbled before he broke the plane and unsuccessfully scrambled to get it back. It was not a problem, because he had broken the plane. In addition, he didn’t need to complete the catch to prevent an incompletion before going to ground because he took 4-5 steps with the ball before losing it. Had this happened in the field of play rather than the end zone it would be a fumble, rather than an incompletion.
- The Bills also wanted a hit on a defenseless receiver call against Fitzpatrick and were probably unlucky not to get it. Fitzpatrick came in clean and led with the shoulder at a contact point around the back/shoulder area. However, when you come in upright with that much force, there is usually some incidental contact up high. This was on the play where the Bills were called for an illegal shift.
- On his interception, you may have wondered if Thomas could have got up and run had he not been injured because it didn’t look like he was down by contact. However, Greg Dortch’s foot made contact with his hand on the way down, so he would have been ruled down.
- Mitchell had a catch overturned by the replay booth. He’s usually adept at those sideline toe-tappers but in this case the Bills player shoved him out before he landed so his second foot came down out of bounds.
- Finally, Cade Klubnik had a weird play where he was about to be sacked but pitched it towards Taylor for an apparent incompletion. However, the officials had blown it dead. He was never down, and “in the grasp” is no longer a thing, but presumably they would say his forward progress had been stopped.
Let us know what we missed – or misinterpreted – in the comments…













