The 2026 Cincinnati Reds took the unique route of building up morale and expectations based on unexpected (and unsustainable) early success only to collapse so hard, so far for the remainder of the season that they still finished dead last within their own division. Despite somehow finding themselves 9 games over .500 at 20-11 at the end of April, only the cityless A’s and hilarisad Colorado Rockies finished with a worse run differential than did the NL Central cellar-dwellers, meaning a whole stack
of things must have gone catastrophically wrong in the process to get there.
You can point your finger at a number of ends that sunk their ship. They couldn’t hit. They couldn’t field. They couldn’t pitch. They stopped running.
Each of those blanket statements carry a lot of truth, as that’s how you find a team so hopelessly buried in the standings at season’s end. But in digging back through all the gross and negligent numbers posted by that last place attempt at a franchise, one began to stand out to me perhaps more than any other given the previously stated desires and goals of the front office when putting this roster together.
No single player on the Reds roster right now is more emblematic of the gulf between the fantasies of the powers that be and the realities that are (and have been) than 3B Ke’Bryan Hayes. Hayes was not drafted and developed by this front office – they sought him out from a division rival based on everything they thought they’d watched and seen for years. When the cards were in their hands and they could have pursued literally anyone during their unexpected (and unsustainable) run to the final NL Wild Card spot in 2025, it was Hayes they went and acquired, doing so while paying a pretty penny for a piece the most similar franchise to them in the sport could not wait to get rid of.
We need not look each other in the eyes when discussing the offense that Hayes has brought to the table in that time. We can stare at our feet and both mumble that he’s been by far and away the worst offensive player in the sport in that time, posting a stretch of awfulness that rivals the worst by any player who’s ever played before.
We can even hem and haw before talking in theoreticals about how his presence as the team’s targeted 3B altered the entire intended fabric of the infield as it forced Sal Stewart, reigning Rookie of the Year, off of his usual defensive spot and down the spectrum to 1B while still just a budding 22 year old.
Instead of all that, though, there’s one thing in particular that drives me absolutely bonkers regarding the situation, and that’s the defense provided by Hayes. This isn’t me going insane about how bad his defense is, as he’s genuinely (and accurately) regarded as one of the great defenders of his time. He’s got Gold Gloves and Platinum Gloves on his trophy case, and rightfully so – and that is why Nick Krall made a point of going to get him.
As Krall himself stated after canning former manager David Bell after a disappointing 2024 season, “our defense needs to get better across the board.”
That was a fair assessment at the time. It’s probably still a fair one. Still, the concept of going out and getting an elite defender at a niche position has enough nuance to it that simply stating that he’s elite and plugging him onto a roster does not an improved product automatically make.
Football teams don’t go get elite wide receivers if they don’t have a quarterback who can throw them the ball. They don’t go overpay for elite running backs only to throw the ball each and every play. If a sports team is going to go out of its way to track down an elite player with one specific skill at one specific type of action – especially when that team has very limited resources – you’d instead fully expect them to use that player as much as possible.
This isn’t even a critique of the debilitating back injuries that Hayes has dealt with over time, the now 30 year old having missed more time than he’s provided for the Reds. This, folks, is a critique of the entire concept of kneecapping your team’s offense to put an elite defender on a part of the diamond that simply never sees the light of day defensively in the first place.
For ground balls to be a thing that 3B defense eats up, said balls have to be hit on the ground so the 3B can eat them up. During the 2026 regular season, only three pitching staffs produced grounders at a less frequent rate than Cincinnati’s 39.2%. That’s the kind of number that would at least be mitigated slightly a) if Cincinnati’s stadium was large enough that fly balls to the outfield became routine fly-outs or b) if Cincinnati’s outfielders were plus defenders who could go get ‘em with the best of them, but we know that neither is, in fact, the case.
What’s even more troubling is that no team in the sport produced pull contact off right-handed hitters than the Cincinnati Reds in 2026. Right-handed hitters, for whom pulling the ball means literally hitting it down the 3B line, pulled the ball just 38.0% of the time against Reds pitching, meaning no pitching staff induced strong-side platoon bats to hit the ball in the general side of the field as their 3B at a worse rate than the Cincinnati Reds.
The Reds literally went out and bought a beautiful skylight from the Pittsburgh Pirates and then immediately installed it on the north side of their house under a grove of pine trees that never drop their needles. It’s the scene from Raiders of the Lost Arc where they box up the Arc of the Covenant and store it deep in the recesses of a warehouse never to be seen again.
Even if Hayes had been healthy – or ever will be again – the Reds haven’t built-in the proper mechanisms to get the most out of the one way he can truly benefit them. They simply don’t have a staff who produces rollover contact to right-handed hitters despite having a pair of lefties forming 40% of their expected rotation. And while the quick hope at the end of this article would be that the new pitching coach may help them induce more contact that Hayes can gobble up at 3B, the more easy thing to point out is that the Reds should probably focus more on getting better defensively at the positions where hitters do hit the ball off the pitching staff.
Maybe that’s what the front office should have done in lieu of acquiring a player they can’t even use in the first place.













