The National Baseball Hall of Fame released the 2027 ballot on Monday, kicking off a treasured offseason pastime: having somewhat contentious discussions with friends and strangers about who belongs in Cooperstown. This year, four former Yankees join the ballot as new additions, with three former Bombers remaining aboard from last year for a total of seven. The Baseball Writers Association of America will submit their ballots over the course of the next few months before the results are revealed
on January 19th.
Fourteen retired players are debuting on the ballot this year: Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce, Asdrúbal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Brett Gardner, Jon Lester, Andrew Miller, Buster Posey, Pablo Sandoval, Ervin Santana, Kyle Seager, Joakim Soria and Ryan Zimmerman. Gardner spent his entire career with the Yankees, while Castro, Miller, and Bruce spent shorter stints in the Bronx.
The returning Yankees on the ballot have all been under consideration by the BBWAA for over half a decade now, garnering enough votes to remain on the ticket. Andy Petttite, who received a checked box from 48.5 percent of voters last year, is in his ninth year of eligibility. Bobby Abreu will be on the ballot for the eighth straight year after earning a little over 30 percent of the vote, and Álex Rodríguez is in year six after a 40 percent showing this past season.
Pettitte’s voter share leapt from 110 in 2025 to 206 in 2026, for an increase of 20 percentage points. He’ll need a similarly giant step forward this year to have a good chance of eventually entering the Hall. Despite commanding universal respect from the baseball community, Pettitte’s relative lack of individual accolades or dominant individual seasons (as well as PED connections from the Mitchell Report) has prevented his case from truly taking off.
Similarly, Abreu’s case is similarly reliant on how voters view a long, consistent career without any periods of transcendent play. His voter share also saw a jump in 2026, but with only two inductees that year, some of that can likely be chalked up to a lack of stronger candidates for those who filled out a full ballot. He does not appear to be on track to earn induction.
A-Rod remains, as ever, a lightning rod. His links to steroids have probably permanently thwarted a statistical body of work which is just about as Cooperstown-worthy as anybody to have played in the past 50 years. He has garnered a slightly better showing than Manny Ramírez, whose similarly-tarnished case finally fell off the ballot with a 38.8 percent showing in his 10th and final year.
If Yankee fans had exclusive power over who made the Hall of Fame, Brett Gardner would probably be a first-year inductee. The fan-favorite outfielder played all 14 of his Major League seasons with the Yankees, filling the role of top-of-the-order spark plug with outstanding defense. Over the latter half of his career, he perfected his swing for Yankee Stadium, adding a steady diet of homers to his diet of singles, doubles, and oodles of walks. Gardner’s tendency for amusing antics (such as banging the dugout roof with a bat when he disagreed with an umpire’s call) endeared him to Yankees fans in a way few other players have in recent years. Brett doesn’t have a realistic shot at the Hall, but it’s still great to see his name appear on the ballot.
The other three former Yankees had far more ephemeral Yankee careers. Castro and Miller are probably better known for their roles in major trades which sent them out of town than for their accomplishments in pinstripes. Miller was traded to Cleveland in 2016 for a prospect package which included Clint Frazier, while Castro was sent to Miami in 2017 as part of the Giancarlo Stanton trade. Jay Bruce only played 10 games with the Yankees in 2021—his final MLB stint.
In addition to the annual BBWAA ballot, the Hall of Fame also assembles the Era Committee every year to evaluate other cases which fall outside the standard ballot’s purview. This year’s Era Committee ballot focuses on managers, executives, and other non-players, and includes former Yankee player and fiery manager Lou Piniella, erstwhile Yankee executive Brian Sabean, and Cardinals slugger/AL president Bill White, who broadcasted Yankee games along Phil Rizzuto for almost two decades. The results of the Era Committee election will be announced next month.













