We are approaching the non-tender deadline which may or may not be the end of David Fry’s time on the Guardians. How should Fry’s 2026 season inform that decision?
David Fry’s role on the 2026 Guardians was to fill in at first base, corner outfield, and DH against left-handed pitching. Fry put up a 104 wRC+ against LHP and an 89 wRC+ against RHP. Since June 1st of 2024, Fry has had 365 plate appearances and put up an 86 wRC+ against LHP. When it comes down to it, I think that’s why Fry will be non-tendered
on Friday. Even though he has dealt with elbow surgery during that time, you simply can’t be 14% below average as a lefty-masher when that is your only calling card.
In Fry’s defense, he has been average to slightly above average in corner outfield defensive chances and at first base. The Guardians pretty quickly abandoned him as a catcher in 2026, which may have partially been because Austin Hedges was surprisingly competent as a hitter, so Fry subbing into games late to replace Hedges at the plate was no longer a pressing need. Fry is not a defensive PLUS, obviously, so he isn’t someone who adds value in that way.
What is the case for retaining Fry? He has a .232 BABIP against LHP over the past three years, so he’s likely been unlucky in what still amounts to about half-a-season’s worth of plate appearances against them. He was finally above average against southpaws last season. He’s still not going to be expensive and has two minor-league options. That’s about it. If the team is serious about adding “a complementary piece”, as Chris Antonetti said, they would be better served to non-tender David Fry and roll the dice on another Rhys Hoskins-type in free agency, particularly in the frenzy likely to place after the lockout. Or, if they prefer to add a left-handed stick, they can give Fry’s plate appearances to a promising young bat in Kody Huff and to Jo Adell.
Aside from Fry’s incredible run in April-May of 2024, we will always have the memories of him hitting two HUGE home runs in the 2024 playoffs. He seems like an incredible dude and I imagine some other team will give him another shot to mash lefties before he’ll have to consider continuing his playing career in Japan.













