The Mariners made a move this week that few saw coming as they sent Bryce Miller, Logan Evans, and Jose Ferrer to the lower midwest in exchange for Gold Glove winning third baseman Maikel Garcia and two fair-to-middling relievers. You can read all about the details and early analysis of the trade here and here. However, today’s post is meant to get y’all contemplating your orbs and looking into the future to see how this trade shakes out five years down the road or more. Let’s prognosticate!
Here
are some prompts to answer in the comments:
- Who ends their career with higher WAR: Bryce Miller or Maikel Garcia?
- Does Logan Evans become the underrated gem in this trade by having a breakout season for Kansas City in 2027 or even 2028?
- How will losing Ferrer effect the Mariners bullpen?
- Are Miller’s struggles mental, physical, both, or neither?
- Assuming full health or close to it, what is Garcia’s slash line for the Mariners in 2027? And how many stolen bases?
As much as it pains me to give up on Bryce Miller when there is still a chance he puts together the kind of season that had me picking him as my dark horse Cy Young candidate before the 2o25 season, bringing in a Real Life Third Baseman who can also hit a bit does fill me with optimism. After all, enduring the left side of the Mariners infield in 2026 was like a viewing of “Salò.” Absolutely punishing and deeply unpleasant. No one wants to see either of those things more than once, so a healthy Garcia plus a healthy Colt Emerson at shortstop all season could make for a distinctly more enjoyable viewing experience. If Miller ends up an ace in KC, I’ll be happy for Cowboy Bryce, but hopefully the revamped infield defense is enough to overlook the regret of seeing Miller put it all together for another team.
What do y’all think? Let’s hear your answers to the prompts in the comments, plus any other trade hot takes you want to share.













