There is a vocal part of the New York Giants fan base that believes the team should have already booted rookie plackekicker Dominic Zvada to the curb. That is understandable. When something goes wrong, fans always want someone to blame, and invariably they want someone to lose a job so they feel like they got their pound of flesh.
The Giants have not been willing to do that as Zvada, after a 9-for-9 start, has made just 8 of 14 field-goal attempts over the past four games. Zvada has a much-discussed
issue from the right hash mark.
“You can’t, as soon as a guy doesn’t make a play, start firing people left and right,” said head coach John Harbaugh.
It is always easy to say “that guy’s gotta go.” It is a lot tougher to look around and find a solution, to find someone you are certain is a better option.
Let’s look around and see what kind of options the Giants would have if they were to consider replacing Zvada.
Ben Sauls
The common refrain from Giants’ fans who want Zvada gone is, basically, “Better call Sauls.”
Left-footed Ben Sauls was an elixir for the Giants’ kicking woes at the end of the 2025 season. Sauls made all 15 of his kicks over a three-game span, eight field goals and seven extra points.
Yes, Sauls was perfect over that three-game stretch. Remember, though, his longest kick was a 45-yard extra point. Zvada has already been asked to try nine field goals of 50 yards or more, making six. Sauls has the leg for those kicks, but it’s never been tested in an NFL game.
It is also important to remember that Sauls, like Zvada is currently, went through his own technique issue in the spring and summer while competing with Zvada. He was terrible in the spring, consistently pushing kicks to the left. He was better in the summer, but wasn’t nearly as consistent kicking the ball as Zvada was.
It was easily to decide which of the two kickers should win the job.
Sauls is not currently on a 53-man roster or practice squad. To my knowledge, he may have only had one or two tryouts.
You can romanticize Sauls as the perfect solution to the placekicking issue if you want, but Sauls lost his job to Zvada because — based on the evidence at hand this summer — that is exactly what should have happened.
Zane Gonzalez
Gonzalez, 31, has had an up-and-down eight-year career. He made 19 of 22 field-goal attempts (86.4%) for the Atlanta Falcons in 2025. He got waived on Monday by the Miami Dolphins after he missed two field goals and an extra point in a 24-22 loss to the Indianapolis Colts.
Gonzalez had replaced Riley Patterson earlier this season.
It’s hard to make a case that Gonzalez would be a better option that Zvada.
Old guys
The 42-year-old Matt Prater made 18 of 20 kicks (90%) for the Buffalo Bills last season. The last time he made less than 80% of his kicks in a season was 2020. He made a 57-yard kick for the Arizona Cardinals in 2024, so there should still be something left in his leg.
Are the Giants reaally in a situation where replacing Zvada with a guy almost 20 years older than he is would be the right move?
Graham Gano is also out there. And, he misses football.
Practice squad guys
Harrison Mevis is on the Baltimore Ravens’ practice squad. He went 5 of 9 for the Los Angeles Rams earlier this year.
Justin Tucker is with the Kansas City Chiefs. Once the best kicker in the game for Harbaugh’s Baltimore Ravens, Tucker made just 22 of 30 field goals (73.3%) in 2024. He served a supension in 2025 related to sexual misconduct allegations. Tucker turns 37 in a few days.
Final thoughts
Quite honestly, I don’t see any “no-brainer” decisions guaranteed to be better than working with Zvada and trying to get through his issue from the right hash mark.













