Now that the dust has settled on the Luis Garcia Jr. trade, I wanted to highlight my two favorite pieces. Yovanny Cruz and Ben Grable are two relief prospects who project to be weapons in the Nats bullpen for years to come. If Paul Toboni wanted to, he likely could have gotten prospects that were higher ranked on public sites, but instead he centered the package around dynamic bullpen arms that can help the team soon.
In Cruz and Grable, the Nats got two arms who should factor into the 2027 bullpen
plans, with Cruz being a plug and play option. Despite giving away Garcia, who leads the NL in slugging, this move was largely made with 2027 and 2028 in mind. It is no secret that the Nats have issues in the bullpen, and these two arms should help fix that.
First, I want to talk about Cruz, who will immediately slide into the Nats bullpen. Cruz has some of the most effortless velocity you will ever see. He can throw 100 MPH fastballs and look like he is just playing catch. That type of electricity is badly needed in the Nats bullpen.
Before this season, Cruz had a winding path through the minor leagues. He was in the Cubs organization from 2017 to 2023, not getting above High-A. After the Cubs gave up on him, he had single season stints with the Padres and Red Sox organizations before signing with the Yankees as a minor league free agent this offseason. This season Cruz suddenly started throwing way more strikes in the Yankees system.
As a result, he started dominating in AAA. Cruz posted a 3.53 ERA and 3.39 FIP in the minors this year. He struck out 33.1% of hitters while walking just 8.9% of them, which is very manageable for a reliever. In 5.1 big league innings, he walked just one batter and struck out six, posting a 1.69 ERA.
When you look at Cruz’s stuff, it is easy to see why he gets all these strikeouts. His fastball sits around 100 MPH, which is rare even in the modern game. The shape of the pitch is not great, which means the heater plays down slightly. However, it is still premium velocity which makes it an effective offering. I would argue his slider is his best pitch though. He throws it more than his fastball and hitters just can’t seem to touch the offering.
It is a 91 MPH bullet that just drops off the table. He has commanded the pitch well this season too. The final pitch of his arsenal is a splitter he throws about 5% of the time. It is a really intriguing pitch that the Nats could look to unlock further.
The fact Cruz is almost 27 and did not throw strikes before this year is somewhat concerning. However, we see pop up relievers fairly often. A lot of great bullpen arms take a while to figure things out. If this strike-throwing sticks, the Nats have a potential closer as soon as right now.
The stuff is nasty and there are some tweaks to be made as well. With his poor fastball shape, I wonder if adding a sinker would help him out. A 100 MPH power sinker would make him even more devastating. That splitter also has a chance to be featured more, especially against lefties. Cruz should immediately slide into a high leverage role, and if he keeps throwing strikes like he has this season, he could be in that role for many years.
Unlike Cruz, Ben Grable is not quite big league ready yet, but his upside might be even higher. Grable may not throw 100, but his fastball is better than Cruz’s. He sits around 96, but gets over 20 inches of induced vertical break. That makes his fastball look like it is rising, making hitters swing under the pitch.
It is a true unicorn of a heater and that pitch alone should carry him to the big leagues. What makes it even more special is Grable’s ability to command the pitch. Between High-A and AA, Grable is striking out 38.4% of hitters while walking just 6.8%. He has a 2.45 ERA and an even lower 1.86 FIP this season. The 24 year old is one of the best pure relief prospects in all of baseball.
There is some risk, most of it being health related. He had a couple elbow surgeries in college, including Tommy John and has an unusual arm action. However, he has been healthy lately and has a chance to be a big league closer.
To go with the plus-plus heater, Grable has a solid slider that is nothing special, but does enough to fool hitters sitting dead red. He will also mix in a curveball and splitter on very rare occasions. Grable throws the fastball 75% of the time though, and for good reason. Even though hitters know what is coming, they still can’t hit it.
As he gets to AAA and eventually the big leagues, he may need to mix in his other pitches slightly more. However, the fastball is good enough where he can throw it 65 to 70% of the time and have success. Ironically, his approach is similar to Nats assistant pitching coach Sean Doolittle, who also leaned heavily on his rising heater.
Grable could have a similar career to Doolittle as a fastball heavy closer with good command. As long as he stays healthy, I think he can be an elite reliever. He should be big league ready sometime next season. It is clear what Paul Toboni was looking for in this package, and if you wanted potential high leverage arms for Garcia, he did very well here.
There is only so much value in relief pitchers, so I am not sure this is the most upside rich package here. However, it matches the Nats needs very well and sets up the bullpen for the present and future. This organization was not going to let the bullpen be this bad again, and they showed that by getting two potential controllable relief weapons. Get used to Yovanny Cruz and Ben Grable because they should be in the Nats bullpen for a long time.
