As we enter a new month, I want to make a point of posing questions to the audience. The first question I wanted to ask you guys is what has been your favorite move Paul Toboni has made this offseason? In his first winter as President of Baseball Operations, Toboni has made a few moves, which we will review. Towards the end, I will decide on my favorite.
Ford for Ferrer Swap
The first major move he made was an attempt to fix the Nats catching position. He traded reliever Jose A. Ferrer to the Mariners
for Harry Ford and Isaac Lyon. Ford is the real prize here and could be the Nats starting catcher on Opening Day.
Toboni took advantage of a unique situation in Seattle. While Ford is a top catching prospect, he had no chance of being anything more than a backup catcher due to Cal Raleigh. Ford was completely blocked, and the longer he stayed in Seattle as a backup, the more his value would go down. This meant that the Mariners were looking to get rid of him.
The Nats, who have had abysmal catcher play the past couple of years, jumped on this opportunity. While I like Jose A. Ferrer, and think he will be a key piece in the Mariners bullpen, getting a starting catcher for him would be a win. Relievers, especially good, but not elite ones like Ferrer are not that hard to find. It is much harder to find a quality starting catcher.
Harry Ford is unlikely to ever be a top five catcher in baseball, but he projects as a solid starter. He has a great eye at the plate to go with solid contact and power. His defense is a work in progress, but has gotten better over the years. Ford also has the natural athleticism that makes further improvement possible. Considering where the Nats are in their build, this is a very smart swap.
The Prospect for Prospect Trade
Paul Toboni’s next move was with his former club, the Boston Red Sox. The two teams pulled off the rare prospect for prospect swap. Toboni acquired flame thrower Luis Perales from the Red Sox in exchange for Jake Bennett, a high floor left handed pitcher.
You do not see this kind of trade very often, but given Toboni’s knowledge of the Red Sox farm system, this move is not overly surprising. The Nats are shooting for the stars with Perales, while the Red Sox valued the safety of Bennett.
Back in 2024, Perales was breaking into the top 100 prospect lists before blowing out his elbow midseason. He was forced to undergo Tommy John Surgery, missing the rest of 2024 and most of 2025. When Perales came back, his stuff was as good as ever, but his command was shaky.
It is pretty common to see pitchers struggle with command when they first come back from Tommy John. Control tends to be the last thing to come back after these major injuries. The stuff was absolutely filthy though. In the Arizona Fall League, his fastball averaged 99 MPH and he had a few nasty secondary pitches to go with it.
Getting that control back will be key for Perales. He was making strides with his command before going down with that injury. If he is in the zone, the stuff will play. I think Perales will end up being a nasty reliever, but he still has a chance to start. This is an upside play from Toboni, and one that intrigues me.
The Blockbuster Trade
The biggest move Paul Toboni made this offseason was trading Nats ace MacKenzie Gore to the Rangers for a five prospect package. Toboni decided to go with a quantity over quality package, but all five prospects have promise, even if none is a sure thing.
Gavin Fien is the biggest name in the deal. He was the 12th pick in the 2025 draft out of high school. Fien has a rare blend of hitting ability and power. While he was a shortstop in high school, third base should be his home in pro ball. Fien is years away from the big leagues, but he has the chance to quickly establish himself as a top 100 prospect.
The Nats grabbed another young infielder in the deal, with Toboni targeting Devin Fitz-Gerald. He is a switch hitting infielder with a real feel for hitting. Fitz-Gerald is likely to be a second baseman, but his bat has major potential.
In his pro debut, Fitz-Gerald walked more than he struck out and showed surprising power. His season was cut short due to a shoulder injury, but he should be good to go this season. Fitz-Gerald is another prospect with major helium entering this season.
Alejandro Rosario might have the most upside of anyone in the deal, but also has so many questions. He blew out his elbow last February, but did not undergo Tommy John Surgery for whatever reason. Rosario should have the surgery any day now. This means he will have missed two seasons.
When he was on the mound, Rosario was dominant. His fastball was in the upper 90’s and he paired it with two plus secondaries. He also had elite control to go with it in 2024. After the multi-year layoff, there is no telling if he will be the same guy. If he does return to form, the Nats got a steal.
Abimelec Ortiz and Yeremy Cabrera are also two solid pieces, but do not have the upside of the other three. Overall, I thought the package was solid, but not mind blowing. The Nats did not get a top 100 prospect in this deal, which makes things risky. There is no true headliner, but a few of these guys have breakout potential. Toboni is betting on his ability to develop these prospects.
The Lone Free Agent Signing
The Nats have not been active in free agency, but they did make one signing. They gave LHP Foster Griffin a 1-year $5.5 million deal back in December. Griffin is coming off a highly successful three year run in Japan, where he was one of the best pitchers in the NPB.
The Nats are going to give Griffin an opportunity to be in the rotation. While Griffin does not throw very hard, he does a lot of things well. He is a crafty lefty with a deep arsenal. His ability to throw strikes and keep hitters off balance really worked in Japan.
Griffin added a number of different pitches to his arsenal over the past few years. It is not a flashy pickup by any means, but Griffin is an interesting flier. He posted a 1.52 ERA in Japan last season.
It remains to be seen if Griffin’s low 90’s heater will work in the MLB, but it is only a one year deal. Hopefully the Nats sign another free agent starter to pair with Griffin. The Nats have a real lack of proven commodities on the pitching staff, which is concerning even in a rebuilding year.
My Favorite Move
I am a fan of most of these moves, but my favorite is the Harry Ford trade. It is just a very smart deal to make. Toboni took advantage of a unique situation in Seattle and got his hands on a potential starting catcher. The Nats catching situation was so bad last season, and they needed to find a new option.
While Ferrer is a good reliever, he is not elite. It is much harder to find a solid starting catcher than it is to find a solid reliever. Ford has hit every step of the way in the Minor Leagues and I have faith in him. He will never be a star, but the Nats have been starving for a decent starting catcher for years.
The Ford move is my favorite, but you can make a case for a number of these deals. Let me know what your favorite move is in the comments down below. Also, if you think the Nats will regret any of these moves, you should talk about that as well. It has been an interesting first offseason for Paul Toboni, and we are not done yet.
