UNC, now 5-5 on the season, will finish the season with something of a QB controversy.
UNC fans got to see Travis Burgess for the first time Saturday night. Travis Burgess made some nice plays against Louisville, free-lancing some runs that showcased his athletic ability and field vision as a runner. He threw both darts and touch passes, none of them egregious misses, although too many were slightly off-target. Burgess oozes potential, which makes him a tantalizing thing for fans to imagine about.
From this point forward, every errant pass Billy Edwards throws, some fans will imagine that Burgess would have nailed it. Every sack Edwards takes, Burgess would have eluded the rush and turned it into a 15 yard gain. Travis appears to be the future, and everyone wants the future right now.
Reminder: Edwards went 28-34 and four touchdowns against Miami. That’s a heck of a ceiling. As for a floor, Burgess went 6-11 against Louisville and also took three sacks. It’s hard to argue that Burgess right now has either a higher ceiling or a better floor.
It’s not hard to argue that watching Burgess is new, and given his athleticism, also fun. Part of fan imagination will be taking every positive Burgess play this season and then multiply by two what it means for next season. That’s the basic formula by which the young guy with potential becomes the prohibitive fan favorite over the sixth year QB on a 5-5 football team.
There’s the argument that Travis needs the reps against Virginia and NC State to be an effective starter next season. There’s the argument that a 5-5 team needs to turn its attention to 2027, since nothing too significant remains at stake for 2026. Both of those arguments seem to assume that the one win necessary for bowl eligibility is a given, since “Virginia stinks” and “NC State fired its coach, they’re done”. Counterpoint: in the ACC, wins are never assured.
Would you trade a possible bowl spot and winning season for two games of Travis Burgess right now? That’s not necessarily the trade-off, but QBs in their first start on the road don’t have a tremendous track record. QBs in their second start against a hated rival with nothing to lose don’t have a tremendous track record. If the opponents were Boston College and Georgia Tech, things might look different. Bowl eligibility activates a sizable additional practice window that most teams use to get an early start on the next season.
Find the two UNC QBs in this graphic charting last Saturday’s QB passing efficacy:
Bill Belichick has made clear he values risk management over all else when it comes to QB play. In that regard, the sixth year Billy Edwards Jr. has a huge advantage over a true freshman with tons of potential. If he’s healthy, expect Edwards to start both of UNC’s final games. Don’t be surprised if Burgess gets some drives to change things up if and when UNC’s offense stalls mid-game, which it’s been prone to do this season. In all likelihood, both QBs will get snaps the next two Saturdays.
What’s your preference?













