This morning’s trade between the Seattle Mariners and Kansas City Royals wherein starter Bryce Miller and other pitching prospects were swapped for Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garcia got me thinking about Casey Schmitt’s trade value; and, lo and behold, this was a part of ESPN’s Jeff Passan’s big offseason rumor reporting roundup published just a few hours before said trade. So, that gets me thinking… what sort of trade value does Casey Schmitt have?
First, the reporting:
There could be some lockout
deadline-beating trades involving hitters in the meantime. Kansas City and San Francisco, both desperate to upgrade their rotations, have floated infielders Maikel Garcia and Casey Schmitt for pitching help. (Note: Garcia was traded to the Seattle Mariners on Wednesday)
Now, I’m the idiot referenced in the headline, and here was my summation of the aforementioned trade:
lol this idiot said “Bryce Milker.”
Now, to be fair, Maikel Garcia’s track record is far more established than Casey Schmitt’s:
Garcia: 531 G, 2,174 PA, .264/.322/.381 (94 wRC+), 10.9 fWAR, +36 Defensive Runs Above Avg
Schmitt: 323 G, 1,147 PA, .244/.290/.420 (96 wRC+), 2.5 fWAR, -6.1 Defensive Runs Above Avg
While both had injury-shortened 2026s (82 and 98 games, respectively), Schmitt is a year older and Garcia was an All-Star and Gold Glove winner last season.
Now, defensively, we know that Schmitt is better than the metrics show, as he’s rarely played at his best position of third base. But, taken together, it would appear my hasty morning post wasn’t fully considered and misses the mark by a bit. Garcia is probably not the 5.6-WAR position player from 2025, but 3-3.5 sounds about right. That’s about what Miller is being valued as, too, although he hasn’t really been that since 2024, when he posted a 2.94 ERA in 180.1 IP (+2.8 fWAR). Over the past two seasons, he’s 8-16 with a 4.82 ERA in 209 IP (40 G, 39 GS) and valued at just 1.0 fWAR. The arms going with him might reasonably raise the projected value in the aggregate to the 2.5-3 fWAR range.
But, I digress! This is about Casey Schmitt and his potential trade value. In that case, the best return would have to be based on his projected future value, because his track record is spotty enough that it’s unclear what sort of player he actually is and that makes it difficult to determine equivalent value. If we trust our gut that Schmitt is a better defender than he’s amassed thus far (-6.1 Defensive Runs Above Average) and we think his breakout of 2026 is sustainable (115-120 wRC+), then let’s be generous but also conservative and say he’s about a 2-2.5 fWAR player for at least the next couple of years. Not an All-Star, but valuable. Here are all the 2-2.5 fWAR/season players since 2024 (current free agents bolded):
- Randy Arozarena (2024)
- Pete Alonso (2024)
- Ryan McMahon (2024 & 2025)
- Jake Meyers (2024)
- Cole Young (2024)
- Sal Stewart (2026)
- JT Realmuto (2025)
- Brent Rooker (2025)
- Bryan Reynolds (2024)
- Alec Burleson (2025)
- Jake Cronenworth (2024)
- Cody Bellinger (2024)
- Nick Gonzlaes (2026)
- Lourdes Gurriel Jr. (2024)
- Marcus Semien (2025)
- Josh Naylor (2024)
- Jose Altuve (2025)
- Addison Barger (2025)
- Michael Busch (2024 & 2026)
- Jose Ramirez (2026)
- Logan O’Hoppe (2024)
- Matt Vierling (2024)
- Masyn Winn (2026)
- Spencer Torkelson (2025)
- Sam Antonacci (2026)
- Otto Lopez (2025)
- Chandler Simpson (2026)
- Xavier Edwards (2026)
- Heliot Ramos (2024)
- Mauricio Dubon (2026)
- Mike Yastrzemski (2025)
- Manny Machado (2026)
- Jung Hoo Lee (2025)
- Jakob Marsee (2026)
- Christian Yelich (2025)
- Ketel Marte (2026)
- Yandy Diaz (2026)
- Kody Clements (2026)
- Hunter Goodman (2026)
- Gleyber Torres (2025)
This is a fine list of solid players all of whom have been valued in trades or as free agents. Indeed, Glebyer Torres is an interesting comp. Coming out of his Yankees tenure and a 1.7 fWAR (104 wRC+) season, he signed a 1-year $15 million deal with Detroit; then, after a 2.5 fWAR season in 2025 with them (112 wRC+ and his age-28 season), accepted the Qualifying Offer to remain for his age-29 season and posted a 109 wRC+ and 1.0 fWAR in 96 games. So, imagine Casey Schmitt in the $15 million/year player value range.
Helpfully, FanGraphs does have a $/WAR ranking. In 2026, St. Louis’s Michael McGreevy pitched with the value of about $15 million. He, like Schmitt, made the MLB minimum. McGreevy also amassed 1.9 fWAR in value for 168.2 innings of 3.95 ERA ball. So, again, the 2-2.5 fWAR valuation feels correct. Here are the 2-2.5 fWAR starting pitchers from 2026 (current free agents bolded) — I am not collating 2024-2026 because above I was just trying to list as many players as possible to more strongly suggest how Casey Schmitt might be valued. He fits very well with that group, I feel. Anyway — this year’s 2-2.5 fWAR pitchers (starters and relievers):
- Hunter Brown (HOU)
- Michael McGreevy (STL)
- Josh Hader (HOU)
- David Bednar (NYY)
- Freddy Peralta (NYM/TB)
- Blake Snell (lol)
- Justin Wrobleski (LAD)
- Framber Valdez (DET)
- Garrett Whitlock (BOS)
- Janson Junk (MIA)
- Shane Drohan (MIL)
- Spencer Miles (TOR)
- Connor Prielipp (MIN)
- Bubba Chandler (PTI)
- Ben Brown (CHC)
- Grant Taylor (CHW)
- Joey Cantillo (CLE)
- Didier Fuentes (ATL)
- Tyler Mahle (lol)
- Dylan Lee (ATL)
- Brent Headrick (NYY)
- Christian Scott (NYM)
- Gerrit Cole (NYY)
- Mason Montgomery (PIT)
- Brandon Pfaadt (ARI)
- Jacob Latz (TEX)
- Will Warren (NYY)
- Casey Mize (DET/SD)
- Max Meyer (MIA)
- Jake Bennett (BOS)
- Tyler Glasnow (LAD)
- Logan Henderson (MIL)
- Shane McClanahan (TB)
- Peter Lambert (HOU)
- Tanner Scott (LAD)
- Eury Perez (MIA)
- Michael Wacha (KC)
- Andrew Alvarez (WSN)
- Landen Roupp (lol)
- Keider Montero (DET)
- Trevor Megill (MIL)
- George Kirby (SEA)
- Joe Ryan (MIN)
- Ryan Weathers (NYY)
You could probably expand this list by going back to 2025 and looking at guys who performed worse in 2026 to see if there’s a fixable problem or a scouted defect that can’t be fixed (one example: Boston’s Brayan Bello — what’s up with him?) or looking at the sub-2 win guys and see which one of them is due for a breakout or could be projected to perform better with more playing time. Those are still iffy because we have to assume it would be a situation where the trading team would undervalue both players; but otherwise, my Bryce Miller is, basically, Landen Roupp comp that I pitched after dumbly discussing Casey Schmitt’s value seems to hold up a bit.
We can assume that the Mariners aren’t a trade partner at this point. Even if Jerry Dipoto is negotiating through the press by saying there’s zero chance he moves another starting pitcher this offseason, it’s hard to see how the Giants matchup with them on a Casey Schmitt deal anyway.
That list of pitchers is a group of guys their team might not want to give up anyway. Those are, at minimum, league average players, which is quite a bit different from replacement-level. And that’s sort of the miracle of Casey Schmitt. He’s actually chapter one in the story of the Giants turning it around when it comes to player development. Ordinarily, that’s not the sort of player you look to move… unless the Giants don’t think his 2026 is sustainable. Which might be the case! That’s a comically low walk rate (2.7%).













