It’s hard to make your mark on a franchise in a single season. Juan Soto is one of the Yankees’ most prominent one-and-done players, finishing third in 2024 AL MVP voting and helping lead his team to the pennant in his sole year in pinstripes, but he’s a notable exception. Jon Lieber spent 14 years in the big leagues, quietly establishing himself as one of the game’s most reliable right-handed starters. And, in an era that saw the Yankees take fliers on many flashier veteran hurlers, his single year in the Bronx
was an unqualified success.
Jonathan Ray Lieber
Born: April 2, 1970 (Council Bluffs, IA)
Yankees Tenure: 2004
An Iowa native, Lieber was taken by the Royals out of the University of South Alabama as a second-rounder in 1992. He only spent a year and a half in Kansas City’s system, showing enough to make himself a trade chip that brought back Pirates closer Stan Belinda. Lieber reached the Show at the age of 24 in ’94, spending three seasons as a swingman before settling into a full-time starting role for his final two years in Pittsburgh, even earning an Opening Day nod in ’97.
Before the 1999 season, the right-hander was shipped off again, this time to Chicago for outfielder Brant Brown (fresh off an error that nearly cost them a Wild Card berth in ’98). Lieber would find his greatest success on the North Side, making his sole All-Star team in 2001 while winning 20 games and finishing fourth in NL Cy Young Award voting for a Cubs team that fell just a few games shy of the playoffs.
Lieber’s next season was derailed by a UCL injury that required Tommy John surgery in August and would keep him out for all of 2003 as well. “He was hurt from Day 1,” Joe Girardi, his catcher with the Cubs, later said of that fateful season. “But he tried to suck it up and pitch, because the thing about Jon is he really thinks about the team first. He kept telling me he didn’t want to let the team down. I kept telling him: ‘Liebs, if you’re hurt, you’re hurt. You’ve got to get it taken care of.’”
With an aging 2003 rotation that featured a 41-year-old Roger Clemens and 40-year-old David Wells, the Yankees were a logical fit to sign the relatively youthful 33-year-old Lieber to a two-year, $3.5 million deal, content with the knowledge that he would not be able to contribute until ’04. “I could have cussed the world out, but I totally believe everything happens for a reason,” Lieber said, looking back on his career-altering injury. “That’s why I’m here in New York.”
With Clemens, Wells, and Andy Pettitte all departing to free agency after the 2003 campaign, Lieber had a spot in the rotation waiting for him upon his return. The Yankees’ brain trust said everything you would expect them to about their on-the-mend starter. “From everybody I’ve talked to, he has absolutely no ifs on his résumé at this point,” said manager Joe Torre said. “He’s 100 percent,” added GM Brian Cashman. Still, given his age and long layoff from pitching, Lieber had to be considered something of a question mark entering the ’04 season.
Waylaid by a groin injury suffered during spring training, the veteran did not make his Yankees debut until May, when he went eight innings and earned the victory against the team that drafted him, Kansas City. He would go on to have the kind of sturdy season the Yankees would have hoped for, tossing 16 quality starts in 27 outings and pitching to a slightly-above-average 104 ERA+ in 176.2 innings. He wasn’t blowing anyone anyway, but he didn’t waste anyone’s time with walks, leading the majors with a 0.9 BB/9.
Despite slotting near the middle or back end of a star-studded staff for most of the season, Lieber cracked the playoff rotation after the Yankees won nine of his final 10 starts. He was a workhorse too, pitching into the eighth on five different occasions — most impressively firing eight innings of two-hit, one-run ball on 93 pitches in a win against the future playoff opponent Red Sox on September 18th before faltering in the ninth. Lieber even held that formidable lineup hitless until David Ortiz broke it up two outs into the seventh.
Lieber’s rock-solid reliability stood in contrast to the likes of Kevin Brown, who broke his hand punching a clubhouse wall; Javier Vázquez, who collapsed after an All-Star first half; and Esteban Loaiza, whose 8.50 ERA made him one of the worst Trade Deadline acquisitions in franchise history. Although skipper Joe Torre would have to dabble in postseason starts for Brown and Vázquez, but he felt much more confortable deploying the likes of Lieber and Mike Mussina in the opening contests. Remarkably, after toiling for a decade on subpar teams, 2004 would be the first—and, ultimately, only—playoff action of the 34-year-old’s career.
Lieber’s first postseason start came with the Yankees down 1-0 to the Twins in the ALDS following a Johan Santana gem in the opener. He staked Minnesota to a 3-1 lead by the second inning, but he settled in with the Yankees’ season beginning to approach the brink, holding the Twins there until the seventh inning, when he departed with two outs and a 4-3 lead. After Mariano Rivera uncharacteristically blew the lead in the eighth, Lieber would not factor into the decision, though his gutty performance played a key role in an eventual 12-inning victory. New York won the next two games at the Metrodome to advance to the ALCS for the sixth time in seven years.
But it was in Game 2 of the ALCS when the veteran would turn in the performance of a career. With his team up 1-0 in the series, Lieber was tasked with opposing Pedro Martínez, the longtime Yankee foil who had just earned his seventh top-five Cy Young finish in eight seasons. The journeyman would outduel the future Hall of Famer, holding Boston to two hits and no runs through seven innings.
Lieber allowed a single to lead off the eighth who would eventually come around to score, ending his night. For his part, Pedro allowed a pedestrian three runs in six innings as the Yankees squeaked out a 3-1 victory with the help of a long ball from fellow 2004 newcomer John Olerud.
By the time Lieber came back around to pitch in Game 6, of course, the series had taken a turn for the worse. He kept the Yankees in the game, allowing four runs in 7.1 innings, but Curt Schilling and his bloody sock would carry the day. The ignominy of the Yankees’ historic collapse in that series effectively wiped the first three games from the collective memory of the Yankees faithful, an unfortunate fate for Lieber, whose dethroning of Martínez would likely occupy a place in the team’s lore had they gone on to win the pennant. There were multiple reasons why that series went awry; Lieber wasn’t really one of them.
On the strength of his comeback campaign, Lieber signed a three-year, $21 million deal with the Phillies that offseason. While there was some interest in a Yankees reunion, New York opted to let him walk as part of another rotation remodel that saw them trade for Randy Johnson and bring aboard free agents Carl Pavano and Jaret Wright. The results were decidedly mixed (to be kind), and there’s a fair argument that—even putting Pavano aside since his reputation was better at the time—the Yanks should have at least re-signed Lieber over adding the inconsistent Wright on an identical deal. The latter’s 2004 in Atlanta was better than Lieber’s by some numbers, but it was also such an outlier compared to his ineffective and injury-ravaged 1999–2003. Alas.
Lieber joined a Phillies team that was gradually building an impressive young core under manager Charlie Manuel with Jimmy Rollins, Chase Utley, Ryan Howard, and Cole Hamels. He pitched to a league-average level in his three seasons in Philly, but he missed out on their incredible 2007 NL East comeback to dethrone the Mets because he ruptured a tendon in his ankle during a start in late June. Lieber’s season was over and he could only cheer from the sidelines during the thrilling September comeback. One year later, those Phillies won it all for just the team’s second World Series title in franchise history — though Lieber had officially moved on.
At age-38 in 2008, Lieber elected to return home with the Cubs for his 14th and final season. He mostly pitched out of the bullpen for Lou Piniella’s NL Central winners, but for the second-straight year, October eluded him anyway. Lieber went to the shelf with a right foot strain in mid-July and made just one more appearance in September before leaving the field for good. The Cubs were swept by the Dodgers in the NLDS, and Lieber officially hung up his spikes.
Lieber finished his big-league tenure with 131 wins and 2,198 innings pitched, markers of his long, consistent career. He spent more time with each of his four other franchises and is only somewhat remembered for donning the pinstripes. Still, his steady hand and reliability were a godsend for the 2004 Yankees, who nearly won the pennant in no small part due to his efforts. Join us in wishing a very happy birthday to one of the great one-year Yankees, Jon Lieber.
See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.
