The Buffalo Bills outlasted the Miami Dolphins this week, winning 26-9 in what was an ugly, hard-fought game. Divisional contests are never easy, so I was instantly wary of the 16.5-point spread given Buffalo’s 8-1 record and Miami’s 1-8 record entering play. While the Bills never seemed to be in jeopardy of losing this afternoon, they definitely did not play as well as they could have.
Miami’s scrappy defense fought hard, giving Buffalo’s high-powered offense trouble throughout the afternoon. At
the end of the day, a win is a win whether it’s pretty or ugly, and an ugly win is far preferable to a pretty loss.
There were plenty of positives to glean from today’s contest, but there were definitely some negatives, as well. Here are our horns up and horns down for Buffalo’s victory over Miami.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Horns Up: Greg Rousseau
In what has already been a career year, Rousseau just added to his growing stat line today. In the first half, he was an absolute menace, totaling two sacks and pressuring quarterback Kyle McCord consistently. The two sacks brought Rousseau into double-digits for the first time in his career, as he entered the day with eight. The switch to Jim Leonhard’s 3-4 front has maximized Rousseau’s ability, and he continues to shine in what is likely to be his first Pro Bowl season, and potentially his first All Pro season. Rousseau finished the game with three tackles in addition to those two sacks.
Horns Up: DJ Moore
Buffalo’s top wideout was the brightest spot in the passing game, especially in the first half. Moore saw seven targets in the first half, catching all of them for 79 yards and a score. Moore also had an injury scare late in the second half, as he seemed to hyperextend his knee while trying to play defense on a batted pass that was ultimately intercepted by linebacker Jacob Rodriguez. Moore was quarterback Josh Allen’s go-to guy on third downs, making plays to extend drives when Buffalo needed him most. He ultimately finished the game with 8 catches for 91 yards and a score on 10 targets.
Horns Down: Josh Allen
Sometimes, I really don’t know what Allen is looking at during games. Sure, Allen’s first interception came on a batted ball where right tackle Spencer Brown was beaten by Chop Robinson. The second one, though, was a pure force where he tried to hit Khalil Shakir over the middle. He didn’t see safety Zayne Anderson, who made the interception. Allen had a third interception negated by a penalty on a similarly boneheaded throw, as he hurled the ball down field into a sea of teal. For much of the first half, it looked like Allen was trying to hit on big plays repeatedly rather than progressing through his reads. There were far too many unnecessary forces and unforced errors from Allen today. He’s going to need to be much, much better on Thursday if Buffalo wants a shot at beating the Kansas City Chiefs. Allen surpassed 300 yards on the day, completing 27-of-45 passes for 304 yards, 1 touchdown, and 2 interceptions on the day.
Horns Up: Tyler Bass
Bass nailed his first two kicks, staying perfect in field goals on the season. He made a 43-yard field goal to cap Buffalo’s first drive, and he hit a 54-yard kick to end Buffalo’s second drive. He made his lone extra point attempt in the first half, as well. He missed his first kick of the season to kick off the third quarter, as he hooked another 54-yard attempt wide to the left. I didn’t expect him to be perfect all season, so I won’t dog him about finally missing one. After Bass missed the entire 2025 season due to a core muscle injury, it’s been great to watch Bass be nearly automatic this season. He made two more field goals in the second half, so he was 4-of-5 on the day, adding two PATs to his ledger.
Horns Up: Tommy Doman Jr.
Let’s go beyond the great kickoffs here. In the first quarter, Doman threw a beautiful pass to tight end Keleki Latu on a fake punt, extending Buffalo’s second drive and allowing them to kick a field goal. I joked to my dad that it was the best pass of the game, and while it definitely was at that point, it really may have been one of the better throws that happened in the game. It was a 30-yard completion for Doman, who just added another positive to what has been a strong rookie season.
Horns Up: Maxwell Hairston
Hairston came in from Cheektowaga to break up a third-down pass on Miami’s first drive of the second half, keeping Miami out of the end zone and forcing a field goal attempt. Hairston started on the far side of the field, trailed his man all across the grass, and broke up the throw on the near side. It was a really nice play overall, and while it might have gone as a footnote for other players, it was great to see the second-year man have a positive impact on today’s game. His counterpart, rookie Davison Igbinosun, was solid again, as well. Buffalo’s cornerback depth was tested today, and with the caveat that it came against backups quarterback Kyle McCord, the cornerback depth passed that test. Hairston finished with one tackle and that pass breakup.
Horns Down: O’Cyrus Torrence
On Buffalo’s first drive, Torrence slid outside and let Jordyn Brooks burst through the middle untouched for a sack on Josh Allen. In the third quarter, Torrence jumped for a false start penalty one play after left tackle Dion Dawkins committed a holding penalty, pushing Buffalo even farther away from the end zone and a potential first down. On the whole, Buffalo’s offensive line struggled against a feisty Dolphins front. Torrence, in particular, seemed to struggle.
Horns Up: Khalil Shakir
It’s a constant refrain in my house that Shakir needs the football more. My wife, in particular, calls him the team’s most underutilized offensive piece. Today, Shakir went over 100 yards receiving for the sixth time in his career including playoff games. It could have been an even better day, but he dropped a pass early in the first quarter where he was covered tightly, but the ball hit him right in the chest. Making sure that Shakir stays involved should be an essential action for the offense moving forward, as he is one of the league’s best after the catch, and he can do plenty of damage down field, as well. Shakir finished with 5 catches for 101 yards; he also had two rushing attempts for two yards on lateral swing-passes.
Horns Down: Overall Entertainment
What an ugly football game this was. The Bills were sloppy, and while Miami was gritty, they don’t have the offensive firepower to have threatened too seriously throughout.
Horns Up: Greg Dortch
Not only was he excellent on kickoff returns again, returning one try for 36 yards and another for 37, but he executed the fake punt catch to perfection once again. Instead of giving the Dolphins a chance at downing a punt inside Buffalo’s 10-yard line, Dortch settled in, made it look like he was going to make a catch, and then he watched the ball fly harmlessly over his head. It bounced at the two and went right into the end zone, giving the Bills the ball at the 20 instead of in a terrible spot. Buffalo’s special teams has been good in general, but Dortch in particular has been excellent.
Horns Up: Damar Hamlin
Buffalo’s veteran safety made a big play late in the first half, intercepting a Kyle McCord pass to keep the Dolphins from scoring before halftime. On the play, Hamlin laid a big hit on Chris Bell, who got JACKED UP and was examined for a chest injury. Hamlin was correctly ruled down by contact, but it was a great play to hang onto the ball after a big collision with Chris Bell, from? Louisville! Bell, fortunately, was okay after the big hit. Hamlin finished with just that interception on the stat sheet.
Horns Up: James Cook III
It was slow going in the first half, as Cook gained just 36 yards on 13 carries early. However, he did score a touchdown in the first half. That score gave him nine straight games with a touchdown. His second half was much better than his first half, and Cook ended up pushing past the 75-yard mark for the ninth straight games, as well. Today’s performance gives Cook the NFL record for consecutive games hitting both of those milestones in the same game. It was another great afternoon for one of the NFL’s best running backs, who finished with 22 carries for 89 yards and a touchdown. He added two catches for three yards.
Horns Undecided: You Make the Call
Alright folks: Who did we miss? Who deserves praise? Who needs some scorn? Let us know in the comments below!













