The Minnesota Golden Gophers (5-5) lost to the Penn State Nittany Lions (6-4) by a score of 42-14.
The Ugly
4-6, 3-7, and 6-4. Those are the respective records of Mississippi State, Purdue, and Penn State — the three opponents that have beaten Minnesota by 25 points or more this season. Context is needed for Mississippi State, as the Bulldogs were 4-0 and ranked in the Top 25 when their Heisman quarterback got banged up and eventually saw his season end due to injury. But the same Boilermakers that walloped
the Gophers have lost four straight since, and the Nittany Lions hadn’t scored more than 31 points in a game this season since putting up 55 on Buffalo in Week 3. These are not the types of opponents that should be running Minnesota out of the stadium, yet all three games were effectively over by halftime.
The Greg Harbaugh era. Thankfully, it’s finally over. Ten games into a season that started with head coach P.J. Fleck touting Minnesota as the only team in the Big Ten that returned its offensive coordinator, starting quarterback, and defensive coordinator from last season, the offensive coordinator has been fired, the starting quarterback is a shadow of his former self, and the defensive coordinator’s future is uncertain. The deficiencies across all three of them were on display in Saturday’s loss to Penn State, but for now Harbaugh is the sacrificial lamb and rightfully so after only mustering 60 yards of offense and no points in the first half in State College. We’ll see what impact (if any) this change has on the offense in the next two games, but I believe the roots of the problems run much deeper than the coordinator, unfortunately.
Drake Lindsey. I’m not ready to give up on him yet, but the Gophers’ next quarterbacks coach has his work cut out for him. Not only is Lindsey frequently gun shy when throwing down field, but the accuracy on his short passes is abysmal, often throwing behind his intended target. To his credit, he looked improved in the second half as he threw for two touchdowns, but Lindsey desperately needs to hit the reset button this offseason.
All the dropped passes. I understand that Lindsey’s accuracy fluctuates from one play to the next, but if the ball hits you in the hands, I expect you to catch it. I don’t think that’s being unreasonable.
The uncertain future of Danny Collins. The case for firing Greg Harbaugh was clear and obvious. The cases for and against the defensive coordinator are more complicated. The Gophers had trouble stopping the run on Saturday, as the Nittany Lions rolled up 229 rushing yards. But Minnesota was also without three of their top five defensive tackles, which undoubtedly contributed to the struggles. The frequent breakdowns in pass coverage are less excusable. Communication and execution are severely lacking at times on defense, and that falls on Collins. The defense has put together some impressive performances this season, but they’ve also given up 38 points to Mississippi State, 41 points to Purdue, and 42 points to Penn State. Someone has to answer for that.
Penalties. This has to be one of the least disciplined teams of the P.J. Fleck era. They’ve consistently ranked in the Top 25 in fewest penalties per game year in and year out. This year, they rank 46th. That’s not terrible, but it’s a step down from what has become the standard at this program. Six penalties in the Penn State game is reflective of that ranking, as the Gophers currently average 5.8 penalties per game.
The Governor’s Victory Bell. To be honest, I completely forget about it until I saw a photo of Penn State players carrying it on the field after the game.
The Meh
Special teams. The blocked punt was bad, but I thought punter Tom Weston was fine outside of that. But procedure penalties on punt formations, the kick-catch interference penalty on a punt return, and some ill-advised decisions by punt return Javon Tracy made this a game to forget for the special teams units.
The Elite
Darius Taylor. Even though he only rushed for 32 yards on 13 carries, Taylor is starting to look more and more like his old self each week. His 58-yard catch down the sideline gave his team a much-needed spark. I just wish we were seeing this in Week 4 and not Week 11 of the season.
Maverick Baranowski. He’s a dude. He looked like a missile on that sack of Rocco Becht.













