Celtic Boss Wilfried Nancy Defends Scottish Football Knowledge Amid Poor Run

Wilfried Nancy is already under heavy scrutiny at Celtic, with four straight defeats leaving the 48-year-old facing serious questions about results, style and adaptation to Scottish football after a 2-1

Premiership loss at Dundee United deepened concerns among the travelling support.

This sequence covers every competition. Celtic have lost in the league to Hearts, who now sit six points ahead at the top, fallen to Roma in the Europa League, and been beaten 3-1 by St. Mirren in the Scottish League Cup final, creating unwanted historical comparisons.

The current slump means Celtic have suffered four defeats in a row for the first time since 1978, when Jock Stein was in charge, and history also shows that only twice, in October 1947 and April 1953, have the club ever lost five successive matches in any competition.

The latest setback came against Dundee United on Wednesday, when Daizen Maeda gave Celtic the lead before the team conceded twice, and the 2-1 reverse marked the first time since December 10, 2023, against Kilmarnock, that Celtic had lost a Premiership game after scoring the opening goal, ending a 55-match sequence.

Anger from the away end at Tannadice Park grew through the second half, with loud jeers greeting the final whistle, as some supporters questioned whether Nancy, who replaced Martin O'Neill at Celtic Park earlier this month after coaching Columbus Crew in MLS, truly understood the specific demands of Scottish football.

Post-match discussion quickly turned to whether Nancy had misread the intensity of the league, especially given the contrast between MLS and the Premiership, and the French coach responded with a lengthy answer that included a surprising reference to a move that almost took place during Nancy's playing career.

"No, no," Nancy responded when asked if he'd underestimated the game in Scotland. "No, I know Scottish football. I know the way it is. I come from France. I come from Europe. I was close when I was a player to signing with Carlisle. So, I know exactly where I am. I know that Scottish football is physical. I know that there is a lot of intensity. I know that there is a lot of fight. And the referees don't whistle a lot. I know that. I think that, again, today, since I came here, it is not like we went off the record. But, again, in terms of results, because I'm judged on that, you are talking like this, and I take it. But at the end of the day, I think that we, again, I'm going to repeat myself, we are improving. But, tonight, it's a perfect situation regarding what we should have done or could have done to win this game. But we have to do better in this situation. "

Nancy’s mention of Carlisle United, a club based in England rather than Scotland, drew attention because it was used as evidence of understanding Scottish football, yet Nancy stressed physicality, intensity, frequent duels and fewer fouls being given as elements that the squad must handle better while results remain the key measure.

The defeat at Dundee United added to a damaging run that spans league, Europe and domestic cup finals, and the sequence of opponents and competitions during Nancy's first weeks in charge can be set out clearly below.

Match	Competition	Result
Hearts vs Celtic	Scottish Premiership	League defeat; Hearts now six points clear
Roma vs Celtic	Europa League	Celtic loss
Celtic vs St. Mirren	Scottish League Cup final	3-1 defeat
Dundee United vs Celtic	Scottish Premiership	2-1 defeat after leading

The club’s social media account reflected the frustration after the match at Tannadice Park, sharing the final score and imagery from the night as criticism of performance and management continued among supporters and commentators.

Full-time in Dundee.#DUTDCEL | #CelticFCpic.twitter.com/rqWWjnKC3cCeltic Football Club (@CelticFC) December 17, 2025

With Aberdeen visiting Celtic Park this Sunday, Nancy faces the possibility of matching the club record of five consecutive defeats from October 1947 and April 1953, and the response in that fixture is likely to shape early opinions on whether the coach can halt the slide in Scottish football.