Sunderland kept their European qualification dream alive and dealt a major blow to Everton, overturning a deficit to win 3-1 at Hill Dickinson Stadium. The result lifted Sunderland into ninth place before their final-day trip to Chelsea, while Everton slipped to 11th and saw continental hopes fade badly.
Manchester City’s FA Cup win means eighth spot now secures European qualification, but Everton failed to seize that opening in their last home match of the season. An early lead, created by a heavily deflected Merlin Rohl strike, could not mask a flat team display that unraveled after half-time.
The damage to Everton’s ambitions runs deeper than one defeat. David Moyes’ team are winless in six league games, at precisely the stage when consistency
is vital for European qualification pushes. The 3-1 reverse was also Moyes’ heaviest home league loss to a former club since West Ham’s defeat by Manchester United in December 2020.
Everton’s first campaign at the Hill Dickinson Stadium has delivered only 23 Premier League points so far, two fewer than they collected in their final season at Goodison Park. That return underlines why European qualification has slipped away, despite the league extending continental places as far as eighth.
The match itself turned on individual mistakes and Sunderland’s persistence. Rohl’s 43rd-minute shot took a deflection to beat Robin Roefs and put Everton ahead, but Jake O’Brien’s error after the break gifted Sunderland a lifeline. Brian Brobbey shrugged off James Tarkowski and fired in the equaliser, shifting the momentum completely.
Everton then lost control in the closing stages. Enzo Le Fee struck in the 81st minute, beating Jordan Pickford to complete Sunderland’s comeback. Roefs preserved that advantage with a key save from O’Brien, and the punishment grew when Seamus Coleman, in a final home appearance for Everton, misjudged a situation that allowed Wilson Isidor to sweep in a third goal.
THREE POINTS ON THE ROAD #EVESUN pic.twitter.com/h6m6r8W5gaSunderland AFC (@SunderlandAFC) May 17, 2026
Everton vs Sunderland Premier League European qualification data
Regis Le Bris’ Sunderland have built a reputation for resilience in their first Premier League season since 2017. Sunderland have taken 22 points from losing positions, more than any other side this campaign and their highest tally from behind in a single Premier League season, highlighting their consistent ability to respond under pressure.
Underlying numbers also framed the contest. Everton posted the higher expected goals figure, 1.07 compared with Sunderland’s 0.73, yet Sunderland converted all three efforts on target into goals. Everton, by contrast, could not turn territorial control into results, a pattern that has harmed European qualification aims throughout this run.
| Team / Metric | Detail | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Everton | Home league points 2025-26 (Hill Dickinson Stadium) | 23 |
| Everton | Home league points previous season (Goodison Park) | 25 |
| Everton | Current winless league run | 6 matches |
| Sunderland | Points from losing positions in 2025-26 | 22 |
| Everton | Expected goals (xG) vs Sunderland | 1.07 |
| Sunderland | Expected goals (xG) vs Everton | 0.73 |
The result left Sunderland targeting a high finish and possible European qualification as they head to Chelsea, while Everton face the final day reflecting on a damaging slide. Missed chances, defensive errors and weaker home form at Hill Dickinson Stadium have combined to leave European ambitions almost out of reach.
