Democrats’ landslide in the midterm elections has set off all sorts of wild speculation. But one consequence is easy to see coming: The filibuster, the Senate rule that requires 60 votes to advance most legislation, is in serious danger.
Progressive commentators, advocates and some members of Congress have already started the drumbeat to kill the filibuster. With President Donald Trump still holding the veto pen, doing so makes little sense for now. But the prospect of a Democratic president in 2028 opens a window.
The filibuster is now a hostage: Either Americans hand Democrats a 60-vote majority in 2028, or the procedural hurdle is likely done for. That's the wrong way to make your case to the American people, and Republicans should fight Democrats on it to the end.
The filibuster's fate doesn't look good
Democrats have tried this before. With a slim majority under former President Joe Biden, they moved to change the filibuster to pass “voting rights” legislation. The effort failed 52-48, thanks to the courage of then-Democratic Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema.
Most of the senators who backed eliminating or reforming the filibuster in the Biden years are still in office. And many in the new crop of Democratic senators favor reform or elimination, or have stayed strategically ambiguous.
But if Democrats win the required 60 votes in 2028 – a prospect that has gone from unthinkable to plausible in a matter of weeks – their need to kill the Senate filibuster likely vanishes. Scrapping it would even work against them.
With 60 Senate seats, the House and the White House, Democrats could ram through an aggressive agenda – codifying Roe v. Wade, expanding health care in some form, reforming the Supreme Court, raising the federal minimum wage and much more – so long as they keep a united front.
In that scenario, Democrats are better off passing their agenda with the filibuster intact and sparing themselves the political damage that killing it would likely bring. A Republican 60-vote majority is several election cycles away at best, so Democrats would be better off leaving the filibuster in their back pocket for when they inevitably lose power.
The real danger to the filibuster comes if Democrats fall short of 60 in 2028. Their incoming majority is likely to reach 56 seats once Alaska finishes counting. Anything short of 60, though, and Republicans could still block most of the Democrats’ wish list. Only nominations and budget reconciliation bills can pass with a simple majority. That covers a lot of ground, but it leaves out most of the big proposals I outlined above.
Prediction markets give Democrats roughly a 30% chance of reaching 60 seats in 2028 but an 87% chance of holding the Senate. That zone between 50 and 59 seats is where the filibuster is in the most danger.
Democrats' filibuster radicalism is no way to govern
The Democrats' threat is clear by now: Give us unilateral power, or we'll change the rules to get our way. Never mind compromise or working across the aisle. Democrats want to enact sweeping change over the objections of large portions of the country.
Democrats will claim the filibuster is thwarting the mandate for change voters handed them. They’re wrong. A mandate is the power voters trust you with inside the existing system. Changing the rules once you’re in power is overreach. If voters want Democrats to remake the country, they’ll give them 60 seats to do it. If they don’t, Americans want some form of compromise.
Reaching for more power the moment voters trust you with a majority again is a surefire way to overextend. It’s a big reason Democrats were let back into power last time, and it’s part of why voters overwhelmingly rejected Republicans this time around.
Republicans have lost some credibility here by toying with killing the filibuster to pass Trump's priorities, namely on election security. But Democrats have grown far more open to eliminating it. Republicans would be wise to make the stakes clear: Put Democrats in power, and the filibuster is likely gone, with a radical agenda sure to follow.
Democrats have an opportunity in front of them. But if they kill the filibuster, they'll prove once again that they can't be trusted with power. Holding the filibuster hostage is no way to govern, and Republicans should be ready to fight them on it.
Dace Potas, a law student, is an opinion columnist for USA TODAY. Follow him on X: @DacePotas
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Killing the filibuster is shortsighted, even for Democrats | Opinion













