Used car prices topped $32,000 in 2026 at a time when car buyers are grappling with record high new vehicle and gas prices, according to new data released by the website iSeeCars.com.
The average list price of a three-year-old used car increased from $23,624 in 2019 to $32,461 in 2026, a bump of almost $10,000.
"Used car prices rose sharply during the pandemic and remain substantially higher than they were in 2019, leaving today’s buyers with far less purchasing power across most vehicle segments," the group said.
The findings come as the average new cars rose to $52,331 in September 2026, according to market data compiled by Cloud Theory's MotoMiner platform and USA TODAY Co.'s LocaliQ Automotive. The average new-car price in September rose 0.7%
from $51,973 in August and 5.1% from $49,775 in September 2025.
Industry analysts say consumers are being squeezed on both ends with the rising costs of new and used cars.
"Digging into pricing trends beneath the overall averages, we continue to see patterns that tell us buyers are stillprioritizing affordability and putting a premium on the most affordable vehicles that can translate into amanageable monthly payment," Mark Strand, deputy chief economist at Cox Automotive, said in a recent briefing about industry sales. "The inescapable reality of this market is that the buyer can get fundamentally less for their money than pre-pandemic, and it is only older and higher-mileage vehicles that are working financially for many buyers," Strand continued.
With that in mind, the USA TODAY Cars team took at a look at iSeeCars' list of the used non-luxury cars that have seen the biggest price increases since 2019.
1. Hyundai Elantra
Average 2019 Used Price: $12,295
Average 2026 Used Price: $19,178
Difference: 56.0%
What we said: Charles Singh of the USA TODAY Cars team said in an article identifying the best cars for commuters that the Elantra is a "good choice for budget-conscious commuters who want to save money on gas."
2. Nissan Versa
Average 2019 Used Price: $10,146
Average 2026 Used Price: $15,718
Difference: 55%
What we said: I said in an article examining why Nissan decided to end production of the Versa that the vehicle was a product of "assumptions made by Nissan and other manufacturers about a huge market for small cars that never ended up coming to pass."
3. Chevrolet Camaro
Average 2019 Used Price: $24,904
Average 2026 Used Price: $38,514
Difference: 54.6%
What we said: Charles said in an article that the Camaro is "set to return as a 2029 model year with major upgrades. It could even get the 6.7-liter V8 engine option featured in Chevy's Corvette."
4. Kia Rio
Average 2019 Used Price: $10,217
Average 2026 Used Price: $15,727
Difference: 54%
What we said: Henry Payne of the Detroit News, which is owned by USA TODAY Co., said the 2018 Kia Rio was "a nimble subcompact hatchback that is fun to drive yet offers excellent fuel economy, handsome styling, and a 100,000-mile drivetrain warranty."
5. Mini Clubman
Average 2019 Used Price: $18,876
Average 2026 Used Price: $28,945
Difference: 53.3%
What we said: Mark Phelan of the Detroit Free Press, which is also owned by USA TODAY Co., said in a review of the the 2016 Mini Cooper Clubman that it was "the sportiest, most enjoyable small station wagon on the market and the best car in Mini’s revamped model line."
6. Kia Forte
Average 2019 Used Price: $12,015
Average 2026 Used Price: $18,166
Difference: 51.2%
What we said: The Detroit News said in an article that "the third-generation Forte adopts a more aggressive version of Kia’s familiar “tiger nose” grille, framed by new, Stinger-style headlights and a more muscular front fascia.
7. Toyota Camry
ISeeCars.com. Pictured here is the Toyota Camry." id="91068360007">
Average 2019 Used Price: $16,567
Average 2026 Used Price: $24,829
Difference: 49.9%
What we said: Charles Singh said in an article that "the 2026 Camry stands out because of its incredible value proposition. Its distinct hammerhead front end design gives the midsize sedan an aggressive and sporty look, which is different than the exterior design of previous generations.'
8. Kia Rio 5-Door
Average 2019 Used Price: $10,818
Average 2026 Used Price: $16,038
Difference: 48.3%
What they said: MotorTrend said in a review that "while it comes with surprising features, especially in the SX trim, the 2016 Rio 5-Door remains at the back of the pack due to its lack of refinement and sloppy driving dynamics."
9. Chrysler 300
Average 2019 Used Price: $20,338
Average 2026 Used Price: $29,839
Difference: 46.7%
What we said: Mark Phelan of the Detroit Free Press said in an article that the Chrysler 300 is "the last great sedan created by an American automaker and the catalyst for Detroit’s greatest horsepower race."
10. Nissan Sentra
ISeeCars.com. Pictured here is the 2026 Nissan Sentra SR." id="89429916007">
Average 2019 Used Price: $12,540
Average 2026 Used Price: $18,332
Difference: 46.2%
What we said: Charles Singh said in an article that "the Nissan Sentra is an affordable sedan that is second only to the Rogue SUV in Nissan annual sales. It's efficient and even its upper trim levels don't break the bank."
Keith Laing is an automotive reporter on the National Trending Desk at USA TODAY. Contact Keith at klaing@usatodayco.com.
If you purchase through our links, the USA Today Network may earn a commission. Prices were accurate at the time of publication but may change.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Shopping for a used car? These 10 models saw the biggest price jumps
