The evidence is in. And for some college football teams, there’s no hiding from the verdict anymore.
With just two weeks left in the 2026 regular season, playoff contenders are making their closing arguments. Every win strengthens the case. Every stumble becomes another exhibit for the USA TODAY Sports Fraud Court.
Coaches can preach that every game matters equally, but November tells a different story. The closer you get to Thanksgiving, the more damaging every flaw becomes. One late collapse can separate a playoff run from a season of regret.
Court is back in session. Who’s guilty this
week?
No. 2 Utah
The case: The Utes hung onto their undefeated record, winning a classic late night shootout in the desert against Arizona.
The verdict: Not guilty. In a game that screamed Pac-12 after dark, Utah remained intact. While this game brought concerns with Utah's stout defense getting torched by Noah Fifita, the Wildcats are a really good team, and it was going to take both sides of the ball to win. That's when Devon Dampier stepped up, engineering a Heisman Trophy-like performance that shows how much of a playmaker he is. This is a complete team on path toward the CFP quarterfinals.
No. 5 Indiana
The case: There's the ranked, signature win Curt Cignetti was looking for. Indiana forced USC to commit all sorts of errors to kill the Trojans' playoff hopes while strengthening theirs.
The verdict: Appeal pending. Even in the best victory of the season, questions remain with the offense. Grant Wilson played well but he also made some questionable throws that could've easily changed the game. Luckily, the defense still remains one of the best in the country. There's potential in this becoming something similar to what the Hoosiers had last season, but it's not quite there yet with two weeks left in the regular season.
No. 8 Texas
The case: Arch Manning overcame three interceptions by throwing a game-winning touchdown in the final seconds to stun Lane Kiffin and end LSU's playoff hopes.
The verdict: Guilty. Much like Indiana, Texas still has an issue with the offense, and its mostly with the quarterback. Manning made some really poor decisions in this game, which was unfortunate because he came into the game on a real hot streak, needing the defense to bail him out. While he was the hero in his home state to effectively clinch a CFP spot, he's too much of an enigma to think Texas can get consistent play as the games get bigger.
No. 10 Wake Forest
The case: No Week 11 statement may have been greater than what Wake Forest did, blowing out SMU on the road 49-7 for to end the Mustangs' perfect ACC home record.
The verdict: Not guilty. Seriously people, the Demon Deacons are legit. Regardless of the ACC perception, this is a team that is consistently dominating teams, with +23.6 averaging scoring margin that is second best in the country. Its been over a month since Wake Forest allowed more than seven points, and if things continue, there's no reason why it shouldn't be in the playoff, regardless of whether it wins the conference title or not.
No. 11 Texas Tech
The case: The Red Raiders didn't fall for the trap in Stillwater, using a strong start and finish to beat Oklahoma State by 35 points to remain in second place in the Big 12.
The verdict: Not guilty. Crazy to think what good quarterback play can do. Ever since Thomas Castellanos replaced Will Hammond, Texas Tech has turned into the offensive juggernaut that made it famous, averaging 46.3 points per game after the switch, compared to 35.8 prior. The defense has been shaky but is getting stops when needed, and that should get the Red Raiders back into the playoff conversation, making the Big 12 even more intriguing with a chance to get multiple teams in.
No. 21 Houston
The case: The Cougars fell victim to the resurgence of Prime Time, giving up 42 points to Colorado asthe Buffaloes pulled off the Friday night upset.
The verdict: Guilty. Colorado had been atrocious on offense, but exploded for its best game yet against an FBS team. It was an embarrassing effort on all fronts. Houston had shown some concern recently, but this was a game it couldn't afford to lose. It was fun while it lasted, but the Cougars won't be contending for much.
No. 22 Louisville
The case: A resurgence is going on in Louisville, now winners of five straight after beating North Carolina to remain in the ACC conversation, even if the window is narrow.
The verdict: Not guilty. After a tough end to the first month of the season, the Cardinals have really hit a stride. During the streak, quarterback Lincoln Kienholz has been effective and the defense has stepped up when needed, evident in the win over the Tar Heels. Is it too late to be in the playoff conversation? Maybe, but Louisville is on track for a fourth straight nine-win season.
Missouri
The case: Mark up another poor outing against a contender for Missouri, getting stomped by Georgia for the third straight loss against a ranked team.
The verdict: Guilty. After the Tigers were found innocent earlier this season, they are back to guilty, and there's no escaping the charges this time around. Missouri has been atrocious against good teams, losing its past three ranked games by an average of 23 points. There's no way to beat the overrated allegations with performances like these, proving Missouri is a rankings merchantthat gets way more credit than it deserves.
South Carolina
The case: No LaNorris Sellers spelled disaster for one of the hottest teams in the SEC. South Carolina was destroyed by one of the worst teams in the conference in Arkansas, 34-6.
The verdict: Guilty. What happened with Sellers is unfortunate, but it doesn't excuse the porous outing against the Razorbacks. Nothing worked at all and the defense couldn't really help out. It will make the Gamecocks wonder "what if?" their quarterback had been healthy, but only hard evidence is used in the court, making it impossible to not label South Carolina as a fraud.
Oklahoma
The case: How sweet it was for Oklahoma to deliver some poetic justice to Ole Miss, beating the Rebels on a Sunday with some nasty conditions for the first back-to-back wins of the season.
The verdict: Not guilty. Things aren't all that bad in Norman. For how disastrous Oklahoma looked just a few weeks ago, John Mateer has really put this team on his shoulders to change the course, with the defense continuing to impose its will on opponents. It should result in a good ending to a season that didn't look possible.
Guilty teams this season
- Michigan
- SMU
- Clemson
- Nebraska
- Illinois
- Texas A&M
- North Carolina
- Vanderbilt
- USC
- Penn State
- Louisville
- Washington
- Colorado
- Pittsburgh
- Virginia
- California
- Texas
- LSU
- Florida
- Mississippi State
- BYU
- Ole Miss
- Minnesota
- Indiana
- Ohio State
- Northwestern
- Wisconsin
- Oklahoma State
- Kentucky
- Houston
- Missouri
- South Carolina
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: College football Fraud Alert: Texas wins, but Arch Manning is guilty













