A legal organization is turning to the Supreme Court of California to challenge Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute all death sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole in the state, asking the court to stop Newsom from what they say is him disregarding the law.
“Our lawsuit is not about debating the merits of the death penalty,” Anne Marie Schubert, president and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, said in a statement to the USA TODAY Network. “It is about ensuring that the governor follows the law, respects the constitutional limits on his authority, and protects the rights of crime victims.”
Newsom announced in early November that he was using his constitutional clemency authority to change all California death
sentences to life without the possibility of parole in a move that was both celebrated and condemned. It’ll be among Newsom’s final sweeping actions as a termed-out governor.
The California Supreme Court is required to review clemency grants to twice-convicted felons, which makes up a portion of the 548 people currently sentenced to death in the state, according to Newsom’s office.
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation said it filed the lawsuit on behalf of district attorneys, victims’ right organizations, family members of victims and others.
“We believe the governor has failed to comply with important statutory and constitutional requirements, including providing notice to prosecutors and victims and conducting an appropriate individualized review of these cases,” Schubert said.
A petition for a writ of mandate was filed on Nov. 15. It's an action that asks the "court to compel a government official to comply with the law,” she said.
“We are also concerned about his reliance on criminal history summaries that may contain errors or fail to accurately establish the legal status of prior convictions,” Schubert said.
The court filing points out several instances they argue are errors involving individuals who are twice convicted of felonies. These errors speak to the importance of statutory notice procedures, as such discrepancies could’ve been looked into and resolved had Newsom notified district attorneys before his decision and before he determined which cases required review from the California Supreme Court, according to the court filing.
The court filing says that thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges have set aside their personal views on the death penalty to give judgements based on evidence and the law. However, Newsom “decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process, followed and applied the law.”
"He did none of that, as he freely admits," according to the court filing. "That alone is an abuse of power that must not stand."
What did Newsom say in response?
Newsom’s press office referred the USA TODAY Network to previous remarks made by the governor regarding his decision to commute every death sentence in California.
Newsom, in an open letter to Californians about his decision, said he “deeply” respects “the views of those who will strongly disagree with my decision, including some families of victims who have suffered the worst possible loss.” The governor said he’s listened to crime victims and survivors, public safety experts and other community leaders and that they “do not speak with one voice.”
“While I am confident this act of categorical clemency in consistent with California law, I acknowledge that my decision to exercise my constitutional clemency authority requires the Justices to participate in a weighty decision they did not choose to take up and with which they may personally disagree,” he said.
Newsom’s decision to commute death sentences to life without the possibility of parole has quickly garnered backlash. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman said he supported the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation’s challenge, saying Newsom’s decision sidelines victims’ families and disregards the will of California voters, juries and judges. Over in Orange County, District Attorney Todd Spitzer invited the public to a press conference to denounce the governor’s decision days after his announcement.
Opponents of Newsom’s decision turn to the California Supreme Court in part to order the governor and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to take no further action on clemency for the persons listed in Newsom’s announcement until the court makes a decision about their petition.
Paris Barraza covers Los Angeles and Southern California for the USA TODAY Network. Reach her at pbarraza@usatodayco.com.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Group sues to block Newsom's death sentence commutations













