Even after amassing over millions of followers on social media, Keith Lee still has imposter syndrome.
"I don't view myself how people view me,” he tells USA TODAY. “I just eat food.”
In less than five years, He's gained 17.4 million followers on TikTok with his simple yet decisive reviews of mom-and-pop restaurants. They all tend to follow a similar format: He sits in his car, turns on the camera, and holds up his takeout container as he says: "I got it, let’s try it, and rate it one through 10."
He has found that his opinion has much more power than he had anticipated. His positive reviews have been credited with helping to save dozens of struggling small businesses on the verge of closing and bringing them new crowds, a phenomenon dubbed "The
Keith Lee Effect." He was very cautious about giving interviews during his rise to fame, but now that he's become "the world's most prominent food authority," according to Eater, he's starting to come out of his shell, owning his place at the top of the influencer food chain.
"The main thing that we look for is a storyline," he says of his videos. He visits establishments recommended by his followers or those he's invited to try. But "if there's a place with only two or three customers, we try to figure out why that's the case." He tries to find out: Is it the food, or does the restaurant just lack resources to promote itself? Lee adds that he focuses on restaurants in food deserts, or ones that don't have a marketing budget, and people are trying to charge them $10,000 for a social media post, but they can't afford that, we'll go and do it for free."
Now everyone wants a piece of the Lee pie. He does his best to spread the wealth by going on food tours with his family in cities like New York City, Chicago, Los Angeles and Atlanta. He usually doesn't go into restaurants himself — he has a family member order and pick up the food for him, or even hires someone. Sometimes, when he loves the food and the service, he'll leave a hefty tip of a few thousand dollars.
The 30-year-old father of three based in Dallas has always been a foodie. He started sharing videos of himself cooking dinners for his family or picking up food for his wife to satisfy her pregnancy cravings in 2020, while he was still an MMA fighter. This got him a modest following.
But he transitioned to food reviews in 2021 and by November 2022, he had over 12 million TikTok followers. That sort of meteoric rise is virtually unheard of in today's oversaturated creator landscape. Lee says that at the beginning of his time as a content creator he had "super high social anxiety" and was "very sheltered." Success was overwhelming.
"My nervous system is shot. It's still shot to this day. But the way I look at it is: I was punched in the face for a living, so nothing is harder than that," he says. "My professional fighting background has allowed me to see the highs of the highs and the lows of the lows. I've built this mindset of 'sometimes you lose, sometimes you win, but as long as you don't get too high, you don't get too low, you're going to be fine.'"
By 2023, the places he reviewed positively saw nonstop business afterward. A pizza spot in Las Vegas called Frankesons, which was on the verge of shutting down, got a glowing review from Lee and almost immediately after, the owner said, his phones were ringing nonstop. Another shop, this time a banana pudding spot in Houston, told Eater in 2023 that Lee's ecstatic review boosted business from an average of six customers per day to 150 to 200.
His family and his faith keep him grounded as he grapples with wielding this power – he says he doesn't internalize it and gives all credit to God. "At the end of the day, I have no control over it. I can go to a place that I love, and [after his video review] it might be 40 people that show up. Or I can go to a place that I might not think a lot of people are going to show up to, and it be 1,000 people … I literally just go eat the food, and whatever happens after we leave is what happens after we leave."
He adds, "The second I start taking control and saying, 'I'm the reason why all of these people are here and I had the power to bring all these people,' I think that's when I start losing sight of what it is that we're doing."
Lee does his best to avoid controversy, but the drama seems to follow him. When he did his food tour in Atlanta in 2023, he was honest in his reviews, pointing out that the customer service he experienced was less than ideal on multiple occasions. One restaurant was closed during normal business hours, and he couldn't order online, so he started to walk away. Once they realized who Lee was, they offered to open the restaurant just for him, but he declined.
This criticism caused a backlash from viewers who accused him of wanting to "tear down Black businesses," as one commenter put it.
Since then, his brand has been focusing on positivity and uplifting small mom-and-pop shops. He hosted many of them at his inaugural Familee Day Festival in New Orleans back in May — they sold food from local vendors (all of which did not have to pay any fees to participate) amid carnival rides, an obstacle course and live performances from artists like Kirk Franklin, Big Freedia, and Andra Day.
While many food creators charge small businesses for reviews, he refuses to do so. "No matter if there's a line out the door, no matter if they open three or four locations, restaurants, that's not my money to take," he says. "The only money that I will ever take is from a corporation who has a budget set to the side specifically for marketing," but these sort of paid reviews are typically labeled as ads.
He takes the phrase, "If I eat, you eat," very literally with his family. His entourage at restaurants and while traveling for work can often include his three kids and his wife, his mother-in-law, his sister Erma and two cousins.
If his stardom were to disappear tomorrow, he knows he'd still be surrounded by them. "When we were in that two-bed, two-bath apartment, we were on the couches, and we still loved each other, and that's what matters ultimately to me."
Lee is adamant about tuning out the noise that social media stardom brings, even if he's still coming to terms with seeing himself as an internet celebrity. He says, "Keep the main thing, the main thing: We eat food."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: How Keith Lee became one of the world's most powerful food critics













