When Republicans gathered in Tallahassee, Florida, after the election to swear in new leadership, Gov.-elect Byron Donalds joined the party.
“It was definitely refreshing to see a governor stay for the entire ceremony and participate openly with members on the floor,” said state Rep. Juan Carlos Porras, R-Miami. “He will have a very open-door policy from the looks of it.”
Donalds promised voters he would be DeSantis 2.0, embracing and promoting the previous administration's policies. But lawmakers and pundits expect that the new governor won’t be like the pugilistic Gov. Ron DeSantis and will be more collaborative with state lawmakers, having been one himself not so long ago.
One area to watch, political analysts say, is whether Donalds moves on from
controversial Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, who has tried to eliminate vaccine mandates in a state that has seen a rise in measles cases. On Nov. 17, the United States lost its measles elimination status after 26 years.
There is also an expectation that school vouchers could be supercharged under Donalds. His wife, Erika Donalds, has a financial stake in charter schools and has promoted the use of artificial intelligence in the classroom.
The new governor will have challenges that DeSantis did not.
First up is how to implement the Amendment 3 property tax cut voters approved on Nov. 3. Cities are already cutting transportation (St. Petersburg cut its trolley services) and celebrations (Delray Beach axed its St. Patrick’s Day parade).
DeSantis and state Attorney General James Uthmeier have not stopped waging their culture war since the election. It remains to be seen how much influence Donalds will have over Uthmeier’s use of taxpayer money to file lawsuits and investigate perceived enemies of the far right.
Porras said he expects Donalds to work more closely with the Florida Legislature than DeSantis, citing the governor-elect’s experience in the Florida House and the U.S. House, which means he knows “the legislative process probably unlike any other governor before him.”
“The number one difference between the two governors will be collaboration,” Porras said. “He understands that it’s going to take long hours and conversations into late night to possibly get through some of these issues.”
Jeff Brandes, a former Republican state legislator and president of the Florida Policy Project, agreed, saying: “Donalds wants to be more collaborative. DeSantis was more prescriptive.”
“You want to keep the best of DeSantis, and you want to move forward on the areas where he did not have much interest,” Brandes said.
What was Gov. Ron DeSantis' relationship with GOP state lawmakers?
DeSantis had a fractured relationship with state lawmakers in his own party that culminated in rare veto overrides, public snubs and open institutional war with GOP legislative leaders, particularly House Speaker Daniel Perez.
DeSantis, believed to be preparing for a second presidential run, clashed with the legislature over state immigration authority and funding for government accountability. Florida House investigators also looked into the Hope Florida scandal, where $10 million was funneled from a Medicaid settlement to political action committees.
“First and foremost, I think with Donalds there will be a lot more communication and a better relationship with the legislature , both Republicans and Democrats,” political analyst Susan MacManus said. “The legislature was one of the problems with things not getting done, and that kept some Republicans from staying home and not voting.”
Former Republican state Rep. Alex Andrade of Pensacola served in the legislature when Donalds represented Naples and said he was “smart, prepared and collegial.”
“Donalds was an amazing colleague,” he said. “I really enjoyed working with him because his personality is one where people just gravitate to him.”
Democratic lawmaker: 'It can only go up from DeSantis'
The Democrats are buoyed by midterm wins, flipping 18 legislative seats. They hope to also have Donalds’ ear.
“It can only go up from DeSantis. It certainly couldn’t be any worse,” said Rep. Rob Long, D-Boynton Beach. “I’d like to give Byron Donalds the benefit of the doubt that he will do things differently than DeSantis and work with all of us.”
Long is hopeful that the era of preemption and demonizing cities under DeSantis is over and that Donalds would focus on helping municipalities rather than “picking fights with our cities and leaning into these culture wars.”
Donalds beat Democrat David Jolly by just 1.3 percentage points.
Boca Raton Mayor Andy Thompson said DeSantis was not always a hard-right politician. He won his first term in 2018 by 32,463 votes and governed initially as a moderate before embracing President Donald Trump’s MAGA agenda.
“It was something you’d expect from somebody who had just won a very tight race. It was kind of down the middle, and then things changed, and it gave him a platform and he took advantage of it,” he said.
Thompson said he hopes Donalds will take the “I represent everybody, not just my side of the aisle” approach and move away from DeSantis’ strident partisanship. “That’s not, unfortunately, what gets rewarded,” he said.
Expect more charter schools, fewer culture wars and a renewed focus on affordability, a former lawmaker says.
Though he just got his transition team in place, Donalds appears to be signaling his priorities, albeit slowly. Here are the areas where things could differ:
Education: Where will funding go under Byron Donalds?
Donalds' first post-election speech came during a State University System Board of Governors meeting in Miami, where he said, “We serve all 23 million Floridians, regardless of how they cast their ballot.”
Expect education to be a top priority, and Donalds said he wants to tie funding that “rightfully ties resources to tangible student outcomes.” If that means less money for arts and humanities at Florida colleges, it remains to be seen, but DeSantis has long targeted that curriculum.
What role his wife will play on the education front will be closely watched. Her businesses have received $30 million from charter schools, and she advised DeSantis on education and expanding charter schools.
“My husband sees me as an adviser just like most spouses do,” she said Nov. 12 at the Education Freedom Foundation Event in Tampa. “I’m willing to offer my expertise in that area and to the people who work on education policy.”
Space race: Donalds wants space and tech at the forefront
On job creation, Donalds wants NASA to move its headquarters from Washington, D.C., back to Brevard County. As a congressman, he co-sponsored bipartisan legislation to make it happen.
“The long and storied legacy of human space flight is inextricably linked with Cape Canaveral, Florida. Home to the Kennedy Space Center,” he said in a statement in April 2025.
During the campaign, he proposed convening a Florida Space Race Summit and pledged to streamline state environmental and infrastructure permitting to expand launchpad capacity on the Space Coast.
Florida has also submitted its official bid to host the U.S. Space Academy.
“The U.S. Space Academy will train the workforce that keeps our nation in the lead and create good-paying jobs for the Floridians who build our path to the stars.”
Health: Will Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo be reappointed?
With the U.S. rise in measles cases, the era of anti-vaccine policies in Florida could be coming to a standstill – at least doctors and health officials hope so.
Donalds, though, has praised Ladapo’s tenure and said he's open to reappointing him. He has also voiced support for Ladapo's efforts to scale back school vaccine requirements.
The Florida Legislature has shown little interest in eliminating vaccine mandates, ignoring DeSantis and Ladapo's efforts to roll back core childhood immunization laws for polio and whooping cough, among others.
“Ladapo moves on,” Brandes predicted. “Ladapo has been here three or four years now. That’s a long time for a surgeon general. I don’t think Ladapo adds anything to a Donalds administration.”
Immigration: Will Byron Donalds maintain a hardline stance?
One area where DeSantis and Donalds seem to be on the same page is immigration. Donalds has said that he agrees with DeSantis that local municipalities have no choice but to allow their officers to be de facto agents of ICE. And on Nov. 19, he posted on the social media site X: "Florida is not a sanctuary state, and as Governor, I will never let it become one. Florida cities must comply with federal and state laws – full stop."
How a hardline immigration stance (something voters – especially Hispanics – rejected in the midterms) plays out in a state that heavily relies on migrant workers could be one of Donalds' challenges. Certainly, DeSantis' now-closed Alligator Alcatraz immigration facility backfired, considering the $1.5 billion price tag.
Affordability: More focus on insurance and housing costs?
Culture war issues were notably absent from the Republican caucus meeting, with lawmakers promising to deliver for Floridians on kitchen-table issues.
“It's time that we get back to a focus on issues that matter," said Rep. Dan Daley, D-Sunrise.
Yet, Uthmeier has said he is investigating the Democratic Socialists of America, and DeSantis has gone on Fox News, championing an investigation into the leftist organization’s fundraising. It adds to a long list of targets that include the NFL, Major League Baseball and Target.
Donalds and Uthmeier share a lot of conservative positions on gun control and immigration. Both were endorsed by Trump.
But Brandes expects Donalds to be less concerned about divisions and focus more on insurance costs and housing affordability.
“Whereas DeSantis largely waited until things went really south in Florida, I think Donalds is going to be much more proactive on the insurance side to bring down costs,” Brandes said.
Donalds will have to deal with the headaches of unpaid contractors of Alligator Alcatraz and a growing crisis with Florida’s Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), Brandes said.
“The state is going to be dealing with the Dumpster fires of the DeSantis administration on the back end,” Brandes said.
John Pacenti is the Government Impact Reporter for The USA TODAY NETWORK-FLORIDA.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: A new tone for Florida? How Donalds' policies could differ from DeSantis













