When your fork cuts into that perfect piece of pumpkin or pecan — you know: Thanksgiving is coming to an end.
But a mighty sweet end it is.
Our USA TODAY Network food writers know it too. And while we love to follow their for recommendations for the best tacos, burgers and sandwiches — even the best bars to go out to on Thanksgiving Eve
— we're equally as curious about their thoughts on Thanksgiving desserts.From silky smooth sweet potato in Indianapolis to Kentucky Bourbon Pecan Pie in, well, Massachusetts, these pies are ones to seek out — maybe even order to be shipped. (The Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag from The Elegant Farmer in Mukwonago, Wisconsin, is available
on Goldbelly.)
Of course, these are the bakeries and regional specialties that give the pies at our USA TODAY Network sites a distinctly local flavor. But, as Bradley Hohulin at the Indianapolis Star said: We encourage everyone to do "their own, rigorous research."
Piefection Banana Cream | Mesa, Arizona
Details: 3933 E. Indian School Road, Phoenix. 602-956-7662. And 6522 N. 16th St., Suite #1, Phoenix. 602-266-0511. Also, 250 S. Arizona Ave., Suite #4, Chandler. 480-855-1019. piesnob.com.
As the door to Piefection opens, the sweet scent of baked goods greets the nose and wraps the body. It may take a while to choose a favorite or two. Once you do, you are given your prized pie in a pink box with black stripes. Back home, opening the box's lid brings about another layer of delight. The shop's owner, Cheryl Standage, opened her first store in Mesa in 2012 after leaving a 25-year corporate career. But her love of baking started long before she opened her bakery. It goes back to her childhood, to her grandmother baking pies from what grew on her farm, to her baking with her friend's mom when the other kids were playing. That one shop in Mesa has grown to four across the Valley, with other locations in Scottsdale, Chandler and Queen Creek. Her banana cream pie is a standout. The pie balances luscious banana flavor and fresh banana slices with a crunchy crust, creating an ideal bite. While pies can sometimes feel heavy, this one was wonderfully light. — Bahar Anooshahr | The Arizona Republic
Winston Pies | Palm Desert, California
Details: 73-061 El Paseo #5, Palm Desert; 760-350-4743; winstonpies.com
The Palm Desert location of this Los Angeles-based bakery is its first outside of LA County, and refers to itself as the "first all-dessert pie shop in Palm Desert." The El Paseo storefront is small — there's no seating inside its chic modern interior — but there's seating outside, and the large display case shows off various flavors of flaky creations displayed upon gold-and-marble pie stands. Customers can choose from an 11-inch whole pie, 5-inch mini pie, 4-inch slice or 2-inch mini bites, and flavors range from Mixed Berry and Carolina Classic Cherry to Fall Pumpkin and Southern Pecan. On a recent visit, I opted for the Harvest Apple, which was stuffed to the brim with perfectly seasoned apples and surrounded by a dreamy, buttery crust. Next time, I'll order Vanilla Bean ice cream à la mode, which is among the seven McConnell's Ice Cream flavors available to customers. — Niki Kottmann/Palm Springs Desert Sun
Pots and Pans Pie Co. | Indianapolis, Indiana
Details: 4915 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, 317-600-3475, potsandpansindy.com
Though I cherish basically all pie, Pots and Pans’ sweet potato belongs to a rare group of pies that I occasionally find myself thinking about throughout the year, regardless of season (I assume everyone does this). Silk-smooth and expertly spiced, with a doughy lard-laced crust underneath and an ultra-soft hotel pillow of toasted marshmallow and crackly pralines on top, this particular pie might be the best in the whole city. Of course, I encourage everyone to do their own, rigorous research. –Bradley Hohulin, Indianapolis Star
The Pie Kitchen | Louisville, Kentucky
Details: Multiple locations around Louisville, Ky.; 502-855-7437; piekitchen.com

The Pie Kitchen is a popular locally-owned shop with five locations across Louisville, each of which sells a variety of pies and other sweet treats throughout the year. The Louisville chain, founded in 1982, is best known for its old fashioned shelf stable pies served in buttery homemade crust shells with options such as double crust apple, cherry, Dutch apple, pecan, pecan chocolate chip (Kentucky bourbon), chess, and chocolate chess. A standout, though, is the caramel Dutch apple pie, which features fresh sliced applies topped with a sweet crumble, with a proprietary caramel icing spread over the crumble topping. The pie is the definition of sweet and unlike anything else you can order at a bakery around Louisville. If you make a trip to the The Pie Kitchen, don't skip its refrigerated pies either, which include flavors such as Boston cream, Key lime, chocolate meringue and many more. Plus, any slice of pie can be ordered served warm and ala mode, topped with a wide variety of ice creams. — Amanda Hancock/Louisville Courier Journal
Verrill Farm | Concord, Massachusetts
Details: 11 Wheeler Road, Concord; verrillfarm.com

Chocolate, pecans and bourbon come together in Verrill Farm’s Kentucky Bourbon Pecan Pie, a longtime local favorite in Concord. A flaky, homemade all-butter crust holds a rich filling made with chopped pecans, semi-sweet chocolate chips, dark corn syrup, brown sugar and three tablespoons of bourbon. The chocolate chips line the bottom of the crust before being covered with pecans and the bourbon-spiked filling. Baked until puffed and set, the result is a decadent variation on traditional pecan pie, with chocolate adding another layer of sweetness. The pie sells for $28. — Joanna Tzouvelis/Wicked Local
Achatz Handmade Pie Co. | Metro Detroit, Michigan
Details: achatzpies.com

For more than 30 years, Achatz Handmade Pie Co. has been serving pies made with ingredients from local farms. This season, try the Autumn Harvest, which layers a pumpkin filling on top of a pecan filling for customers who can't choose between the two, or go for the company’s signature Michigan 4-Berry – what founder Wendy Achatz calls a “happy accident.” When she blended leftover cherry, blueberry, raspberry and blackberry filling, the pie Achatz is now best known for was born. And if you’re considering a classic pie as a last-minute option, here’s a caution: Achatz sells a pumpkin pie every 90 seconds the day before Thanksgiving. — Lyndsay C. Green/Detroit Free Press
Anthony's Cheesecake, Bloomfield
Details: 71 Washington St., Bloomfield; 973-415-8885, anthonyscheesecake.com.

Anthony's Cheesecake is known for serving irresistibly indulgent desserts in as many flavor varieties as an inspired mind can imagine. Craving a cheesecake (you should be, it is the shop's namesake dessert)? Savor an apple cider donut rendition. Addicted to tres leches? Try the cannoli, cinnamon chai or red velvet. When it comes to pies, the mouthwatering selection is just as lengthy. On the pumpkin front alone, the bakers have been known to whip up Pumpkin Pecan Holiday Mashup, Pumpkin Pecan Streusel, Pumpkin Meringue and Pumpkin Salted Caramel, while plays on sweet potato, apple and more are regular bestsellers. Personally, my top slice (Thanksgiving or not) hails from the Reese's Peanut Butter Mousse Pie, but the Banana Biscoff Cream is a close second. — Kara VanDooijeweert, NorthJersey.com
Pie Lady Cafe | Moorestown, New Jersey
Details: 9 E. Main St., Moorestown; 856-778-7437; facebook.com

Owner Christine McHale’s café business, housed in a converted Victorian home along picturesque Main Street, serves omelets, avocado toast, breakfast burritos and muffins — but her pies are the big draw. In some years 1,000 pies have been made for Thanksgiving. The café typically offers 10 standard pies, plus seasonal varieties made with fresh local fruit, such as peaches. Some of the flavors include: apple, cranberry apple, mixed berry, blueberry, cherry almond, cherry, pecan, chocolate pecan, key lime, coconut custard, chocolate chip and pumpkin. The fruit pies have a crumb topping. Gluten-free, sugar-free and vegan options are available for a few dollars more. — Celeste E. Whittaker/Cherry Hill Courier-Post
Newbury Park Pastries | Henrietta, New York
Details: 205 Mushroom Blvd., Henrietta; 585-272-7864; newburyparkpastries.com

Newbury Park Pastries is tucked along a street lined with warehouses in the Genesee Valley Regional Market in suburban Rochester. Locals in the know appreciate its savory pot pies, ranging from the ubiquitous chicken potpie to flavors like Panang and woodland mushroom. During the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the small business was overwhelmed when its turkey dinner potpie went viral locally. A single butter crust is layered with real mashed potatoes, turkey and gravy and is topped with butternut squash, green beans, and stuffing. Made for only five weeks each year, it has become an annual tradition for many. Newbury Park Pastries also makes sweet goodies including pumpkin, pecan and peanut butter pies for Thanksgiving. — Tracy Schuhmacher/Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Galloway’s Bakery | Scarsdale, New York
Details: 69 Harney Road, Scarsdale; 914-725-4074; gallowaysbakery.com
Simplicity is at the heart of what makes Galloway's, a third generation bakery, so special. It's all about the classics — apple, pumpkin, pecan and chocolate cream. The recipes are exactly the same since the business first started in the late 1940s, and its that taste of childhood, coupled with the sense of nostalgia (the place remains virtually unchanged since it moved to this location in 1962) that have people lined outside the door for Thanksgiving. This third-generation bakery, run by the founder's granddaughter, Shannon Galloway, still makes everything by hand. "And," said Galloway, "Because we've never branched out, we've stuck to what we do best." That means pies — lots of them — alongside cakes, cookies, doughnuts, breads, buns and Danish rings. What makes it even more popular? The fact that its limited hours of Friday, Saturday and Sunday (and cash only) means there's only select times to get their coveted treats. — Jeanne Muchnick/Rockland/Westchester Journal News
Apple Annie's Bake Shop | Wilmington, North Carolina
Details: 837 S. Kerr Ave., Wilmington; 910-799-9023; appleanniesbakeshop.com
When it comes to Wilmington bakeries, Apple Annie's Bake Shop is a longtime favorite that has been a part of the community for more than four decades. There are 200-plus items and the long row of display cases are always filled with cookies, Swiss rolls, classic New York treats, Italian breads and (of course) pies. At Thanksgiving, they bake more than 1,500 of them for the holiday. The best-sellers are pumpkin, bourbon pecan and apple, in that order. The base is a smooth, creamy pumpkin filling infused with just enough warming spice. If you get the Whipped Cream Pumpkin Pie, though, comes with the addition of mounds of fluffy piped topping. — Allison Ballard/Wilmington StarNews
Bluebird Bakery | Glendale, Ohio
Details: 29 Village Square, Glendale, Ohio; 513-772-5633; bluebirdbakery.com.
Bluebird Bakery is located on what is about the prettiest village square you will find in Greater Cincinnati. Jenny Dennis opened Bluebird in 1996 as a take-out spot, but in 2009, took over the space next door, turning it into the kind of neighborhood cafe that would fit as nicely into Star's Hollow as Glendale, Ohio. After Jenny retired in the early 2020s, her son, Bryan Dennis and his wife, Kelly, took over. The couple has kept things pretty much the same. The pies are baked from scratch, the crusts made with shortening instead of lard or butter. I read somewhere that shortening is better for fruit pies, since the bold flavors of those other two fats can overshadow the fruit. Maybe that's why the latticed triple berry pie I tried was so good. Other pies include apple crumb top, coconut cream, pecan and key lime. For the holidays, they also offer pumpkin pie with walnut, butter, brown sugar and a coconut topping, an apple cranberry with orange zest, cinnamon and nutmeg, and a mincemeat pie, among others.

Along with pie, Bluebird serves homemade soups, a wide selection of sandwiches (they are famous for their chicken curried salad) and good, hot coffee. But it's the pies you come here for. And it's the pies you will remember. – Keith Pandolfi, The Cincinnati Enquirer
Der Dutchman | Plain City, Ohio
Details: 445 S. Jefferson Ave., Plain City, Ohio; 614-873-3414; dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-plain-city-oh
The Amish restaurant and bakery that attracts many with its authentic recipes and flavors shines when it comes to homemade pies. Some pies that stand out include pumpkin, apple, Dutch apple, blackberry, blueberry, custard, peach and lemon meringue. More flavors to try include red raspberry cream, pecan, cherry, banana cream, butterscotch cream, coconut cream, chocolate peanut butter cream, chocolate cream and peanut butter cream. There are also small pies and sugar-free pies. If pies aren't your thing, try the pumpkin rolls or cookies. –Bob Vitale, The Columbus Dispatch
Butteriffic Bakery & Cafe | Memphis, Tennessee
Details: 488 S. Second St., Memphis; 901-207-4618; butterifficbakery.com

Key lime pie is a Southern dessert classic, and you will not find a tastier slice than the one offered at Butteriffic Bakery & Cafe in Downtown Memphis. Much of the credit goes to its absolutely sublime butter cookie pie crust, the bakery's signature touch. It may be one of the tastiest pie crusts you'll ever eat. Combined with the tangy yet sweet key lime filling, it's truly irresistible. — Brian Strickland/Memphis Commercial Appeal
The Elegant Farmer | Mukwonago, Wisconsin
Details: 1545 Main St., Mukwonago, Wisconsin; 262-363-6770; elegantfarmer.com

It's not every day that a pie is so beloved it gets trademarked. But with so many devotees across the country, The Elegant Farmer's iconic Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag has earned its icon status. It's been called one of the country's best pies by The Wall Street Journal and Gourmet magazine, and even inspired a cook-off challenge on Food Network's "Throwdown with Bobby Flay." On Goldbelly, one 8-inch pie sells for $70. (Sold locally at the smiley-face barn at the flagship Mukwonago market, it's just $22.) So what's with the hype? That bulging, craggy crust, so crisp and sweet it tastes something like a fresh-baked sugar cookie. Baking it in the brown bag keeps the sugar from burning, and provides an irresistible crunch on top. Inside, piles of sliced Ida Red apples are sweet and tart, with just a hint of pie spice so the apple taste is front and center. Feeling even more decadent? Go for the caramel apple pie, coated with a sticky glaze of gooey soft caramel. – Rachel Bernhard, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: These are our food writers' favorite pie shops across the US













