It started with a parade.
Literally.
Before Lane Kiffin had ever coached an LSU game, he served as a grand marshal for the Mardi Gras parade in February in New Orleans.
The hoopla continued through the season opener, and Kiffin made his much-antipated entrance into Tiger Stadium wearing a pin-striped suit and walking alongside bikini models. The hype reached a fever pitch when LSU destroyed Clemson.
And then ... pffffttt.
The air went out of the balloon.
With two games left in the season, LSU is already out of the playoff hunt after a 22-21 loss to Texas, the Tigers' second home loss in as many weeks.
Already, it's time to put Kiffin's first season into perspective.
On this edition of “College Football Unfiltered,” a USA TODAY Sports podcast presented
by Sports Seriously, host Blake Toppmeyer and his colleagues Paul Myerberg and Matt Hayes dissect Kiffin's debut season at LSU and what Year 1 portends for the rest of his tenure.
Later in the episode, the crew debates Lincoln Riley's future at Southern Cal. They lay out the case for firing Riley, and the case for bringing him back for 2027, and they explain why the decision could turn on a dime.
On the subject of Kiffin's debut season on the bayou:
How would you describe Lane Kiffin's first LSU season?
∎ Boring. That's how I'd describe the Tigers. They're boring. They haven't been exciting since halftime against Clemson, when Kiffin was college football's dominant storyline and maybe the biggest celebrity coach in all of sports, at that moment. Since then, boredom followed. It's boring to watch a team lose to every good team and beat every bad team. It's boring to see everyone build up LSU, and then it repeatedly comes up short of expectations. And it's boring to expect Kiffin to have gotten to the playoff and then be 6-4. Boring. That's not something you would have expected to say about this team two months ago. — Myerberg
∎ Fantasyland. It's just been nothing but this crazy fantasyland since the moment he left Ole Miss and then a series of offseason machinations. We watched everyone in the state of Louisiana, including the politicians, get sucked into Lane World, but then the clock strikes midnight, and LSU turned into a pumpkin. The Tigers are just not what you expect them to be, not what you want them to be, because it's fantasyland. Kiffin got everybody on board — and I do mean everybody — from the big-money boosters to the governor, to the attorneys, to the local judges. They were all rallying around Kiffin. And, what happened? A colossal failure. — Hayes
∎ Bust. Think of it in blackjack terms. LSU put so many chips on the table for this season, between Brian Kelly's buyout, the roster investment, the salaries for Kiffin and his staff. Lane can talk all he wants about Kelly not leaving him a good hand, and Kelly not recruiting well, and the roster not being in good shape, but LSU spent to give Kiffin a roster that could win in Year 1, and he went out and lost to another first-year coach, Will Stein at Kentucky. Out at UCLA, Bob Chesney is undefeated. Did he inherit a good hand? All that money invested into Year 1, and what did LSU get for it? Four losses, with more potentially on the way. Kiffin so badly wanted this LSU team to be a big, bad villain. Instead, it's just a bust. — Toppmeyer
How concerned should LSU be that Lane Kiffin's Year 1 went splat?
Myerberg: This season doesn't shake my confidence that Lane will win at LSU. All the pieces are in place for him to succeed, so I can separate this season from the outlook of his tenure. This year has been a crap show, but that doesn't mean he won't ultimately be successful. LSU needs a new quarterback, for starters, and it needs more depth, and it needs a run of good recruiting classes. That can all happen. I'm still on board with LSU being successful in the long run.
Hayes: I would lean toward that, as well. However, I will say, Kiffin has never won a power-conference championship. He's never coached in a College Football Playoff game. So, I do consider the track record. I also consider LSU's history. Look, Ed Orgeron and Les Miles won it all there, so you would think Kiffin could do it, too, considering all of the inherent advantages at LSU.
Toppmeyer: I'm not bailing on the idea of Kiffin succeeding at LSU, but I am concerned. This season didn't ease those concerns. Throughout his career, Lane has not been at his best when he's in the high-pressure job, when his every single move is under the microscope. Think about what happened at USC. Yes, he stepped into some tough circumstances, and he wound up getting fired. As the young coach of the Raiders, he was a disaster.
Lane is at his best when he's the underdog, like at Ole Miss. I was interested in how he'd handle the pressure of LSU. He and his team buckled this season. The pressure is only going to increase in Year 2. I'm not folding on Kiffin. He might still pull this off in the long run, but this season didn't increase my confidence.
College Football Unfiltered to go live for CFP rankings
The third CFP rankings will be released around 9 p.m. ET on Tuesday, Nov. 17. As soon as the rankings are released, Toppmeyer and John Brice will go live with a special edition of College Football Unfiltered. You can watch that show on the USA TODAY Sports YouTube page.
Where to listen to College Football Unfiltered
Be sure to check out USA TODAY Sports' "College Football Unfiltered" podcast, hosted by columnist Blake Toppmeyer. You can stream episodes on YouTube or download via Apple podcasts, Spotify or iHeart. Cohosts Matt Hayes, Paul Myerberg and John Brice cover college football for USA TODAY Sports.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: LSU went all-in on Lane Kiffin. What it got was an expensive bust













