For all that separates them — from their opposing ends of maybe the most intense rivalry in men’s college basketball to their 13-inch height difference — Mark Pope and Pat Kelsey will be forever linked.
The two were hired in 2024 in the same offseason by two of the 10 most historically decorated programs in the sport, with Pope returning to his alma mater, Kentucky, and Kelsey inheriting a rebuild at Louisville. Because of that timing, and because of the schools where they landed, they’ll always be compared to one another, at least in their current roles.
Now, two weeks into their third seasons at their respective schools, the two are bonded ... just not in the way either of them would have anticipated or hoped.
looking for answers after unraveling at Memphis
To the extent that alarm bells can be sounded at this extremely early stage in the 2026-27 season, Pope and Kelsey are hearing them.
A potential make-or-break season for Pope has gotten off to an inauspicious start, with the Wildcats getting blown out by 20 in the Champions Classic to a Kansas team led by freshman superstar Tyran Stokes, a Kentucky native Pope and his staff tried tirelessly to get. Perhaps even more damning was what unfolded three nights later, when Kentucky needed a last-second 3-pointer from Alex Wilkins to avoid a home loss to a Northern Arizona team picked to finish last in the Big Sky Conference that it was favored to beat by 30. In his post-game news conference, Pope only added to the growing ire around him by saying he hoped everybody in Rupp Arena “had fun” after watching a “really entertaining game.”
The Cardinals’ first test of the season didn’t go much better, as they blew an early 18-point lead in a 98-78 loss at rival Memphis in which they were outscored 57-26 in the second half while allowing the Tigers to shoot 74% from the field in the final 20 minutes. Over the past 15 years, it’s the most lopsided loss an AP top-10 team has suffered after leading by at least 15 points.
The Wildcats are down to No. 54 on KenPom, the lowest they’ve been in the website’s rankings outside of the COVID-19-affected 2020-21 season since they ended the 2012-13 season with a loss to Robert Morris in the first round of the NIT. Louisville’s humbling loss at Memphis dropped it from No. 19 to No. 35. When preseason expectations are stripped from the formula, the Cardinals are No. 75 on Bart Torvik (just one spot ahead of Kelsey’s former employer, Charleston) while Kentucky is No. 121, ranking it fifth among schools in its own state.
While those early faceplants would have been cause for concern at two programs with justifiably lofty expectations, they’re magnified in the NIL era, when there’s a rough idea of how much these schools are shelling out to assemble a squad.
Kentucky and Louisville were two of the biggest spenders of the offseason, with the archrivals among 11 teams nationally that reportedly spent at $20 million on their rosters, according to CBS Sports. They landed arguably the top two players in the transfer portal, with the Cardinals getting former Kansas big man Flory Bidunga and the Wildcats nabbing former Iowa State sharpshooter Milan Momcilovic.
The underwhelming early returns show that all that money may not be able to mask over deficiencies the two coaches have displayed early in their tenures.
After barely advancing to the second round of the NCAA tournament last season with what was believed to be the most expensive roster in the sport, Pope very publicly missed out on a number of his top transfer targets, as well as Stokes, a jarring new reality for a Kentucky program that got seemingly whoever it wanted in 15 seasons under John Calipari. Pope was able to hold on to promising big man Malachi Moreno and add intriguing pieces like Wilkins, but those whiffs put the program in a position where it had to overpay for Momcilovic, an excellent marksman who has trouble creating his own shot and isn’t the kind of player around which you build an offense.
Louisville didn’t have those same offseason woes, picking up three of the top 25 players in the portal according to 247Sports’ rankings, but through three games has displayed much of what ailed Kelsey’s first two teams at the school — blowout losses in the biggest games on their schedule, defensive shortcomings, and a general lack of poise and toughness in the face of adversity. Those traits are especially worrisome given what appeared to be a philosophical shift from Kelsey in the offseason to prioritize defense and athleticism at the expense of his fast-paced, 3-heavy offense. If the Cardinals don’t have the same bevy of shooters they did in Kelsey’s first two seasons and aren’t able to play elite defense, what exactly are they?
For all their similarities, the coaches aren’t operating on similar timelines. Pope is squarely on the hot seat, likely needing to make the second week of the NCAA tournament to feel confident about his job status. Unlike Pope, who took over at a school that was a No. 3 seed in that year’s NCAA tournament, Kelsey inherited a program that had won 12 games the previous two seasons combined under Kenny Payne. But if a team with a top-five roster budget doesn’t deliver something remotely resembling top-five results this season, the pressure on him at his first power-conference job will ramp up.
Come March, the mid-November conversation around Kentucky and Louisville may seem hyperbolic. Both the Wildcats and Cardinals have the potential to overcome early slip-ups to earn desirable seeds to the NCAA tournament and deliver the kinds of results their fans and universities expect.
If they don’t, though, Pope will likely be out of a job and Kelsey may find himself where Pope is now — trying to convince an anxious fan base in a basketball-mad state that their coach is truly up for the prestigious perch he occupies.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Kentucky and Louisville's starts have raised uncomfortable questions about Mark Pope, Pat Kelsey













