Atlanta-based Flock Safety continues to stir controversy as communities across the country debate whether the extensive camera network makes their homes safer — or more exposed.
Flock cameras, or automated license plate reader cameras, are able to identify vehicles by more than just their tag. The cameras can pick up on a vehicle's color, the dings and dents and even bumper stickers that make a vehicle unique. While they are most commonly found along major roadways or near busy intersections, they have also been installed in quieter neighborhoods and even pointed toward college campuses that don't allow vehicle traffic.
Georgia has tens of thousands of cameras across the state and Atlanta has become one of the most surveilled cities in America,
with roughly one camera for every eight residents.
Law enforcement officials have argued the cameras have changed the game in investigations like Amber Alerts or following a shooting, including here in Atlanta. The cameras and their associated database work faster than using something like a stoplight camera, and the shared network allows multiple jurisdictions to work together in a single search.
But, one of the largest problems the company faces in their home state is misuse by the very officers trusted to access the Flock database.
More than two dozen law enforcement officials, both sworn officers and civilian employees, have been charged with violation of their oath of office through unauthorized searches of Flock Safety technology. And that number continues to climb.
Norcross, Forest Park officers accused of misuse
Three Atlanta-area officers, one from Forest Park and two from Norcross, have been charged with misuse of license plate reader systems and other charges this week, according to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.
Michael Braswell, 28, was charged with five counts of ALPR technology misuse, five counts of computer invasion of privacy and five counts of violation of oath of office following an investigation requested by the Clayton County District Attorney's Office.
Tyler Reiss, 32, was charged with three counts of ALPR technology misuse, four counts of computer invasion of privacy and seven counts of violation of oath of office following an investigation requested by the Clayton County District Attorney's Office.
Vincent Cardwell, 60, was charged with two counts of ALPR technology misuse and two counts of violation of oath of office in the same district as Reiss.
Cardwell and Reiss turned themselves in to law enforcement officials on Nov. 12 and Nov. 16, respectively, while Braswell was taken into custody on Nov. 16.
All three officers are no longer employed by their police departments. The GBI did not release what their searches entailed.
Where have officers been arrested for misuse?
In a growing, and non-exhaustive list, law enforcement officials from across the state have been charged or accused of Flock misuse.
In Athens, a crime analyst who had previously touted the guardrails of the Flock Safety system later was charged with misuse. In Dallas, a former 911 director searched for her ex-husband's vehicle, and his new girlfriend, thousands of times. In Braselton, the police chief himself tracked a woman and her teenage daughter hundreds of times, a Washington Post investigation found.
- Three deputies, two investigators, Hall County Sheriff's Office
- Criminal analyst, Athens-Clarke County Police Department
- 911 director, Dallas Police Department
- Five police officers, Albany Police Department
- Two supervisor-level officers, Cherokee County Sheriff's Office
- Sheriff's deputy, Greene County Sheriff's Office
- Sheriff's deputy, DeKalb County Sheriff's Office
- District Attorney investigator, Effingham County Sheriff's Office
- Four officers, Richmond County Sheriff's Office
- Four officers, two civilian staff members, Savannah Police Department
- Police Chief, Braselton Police Department
- Officer, Clayton County Sheriff's Office
- Corrections officer, Georgia Department of Corrections, Eatonton
- Two police officers, Norcross Police Department
- Police officer, Forest Park Police Department
USA TODAY investigations have also found misuse in Warner Robins, Baldwin County, Butts County, LaGrange, Baldwin County, Milton and Perry.
Bottoms, Miller suggests state action on campaign trail
Tanya Miller, Georgia's Attorney General-Elect, said on the campaign trail the necessary checks and balances on law enforcement to avoid overreach have not been enforced under the current administration. Miller won the election for Attorney General during the midterm cycle with 55% of the vote.
When asked about the future of Flock in Georgia during a midterm debate, Miller said the current trend is "not what this technology is supposed to be used for," and instead it's "supposed to be used for solving crimes."
"What we cannot have is departments who are not effectively responding to the public. We cannot have private companies having control of this information. The Attorney General's job is to enforce the Open Records Act," Miller said.
While her opponent, Brian Strickland, said the need for Flock came from previous "soft on crime" policies in Atlanta, he agreed state action may be needed if the private company did not address the misuse internally.
Keisha Lance Bottoms, the former mayor of Atlanta and governor-elect of Georgia, told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution in a platform interview she understands "people are deeply concerned about their right to privacy."
"Whatever guardrails we need to put around to make sure that these cameras are being used for purely law enforcement purposes and not personal purposes, we need to take a look at that," she told the outlet. She echoed this idea during her town hall-style debate with former opponent Rick Jackson, and again during a solo debate appearance at the Atlanta Press Club.
Miller and Bottoms will be sworn into their roles in the first few weeks of January.
Will Georgia jurisdictions cut ties with Flock?
More than 100 law enforcement agencies across the country have ended their contracts with Flock Safety in recent months over privacy concerns, but the company and the state of Georgia are deeply tied to one another. Flock Safety was born from concern about thefts from vehicles near the Georgia Tech campus, and was started by Tech students who believed law enforcement was not acting effectively. The company is still headquartered in Atlanta.
In data aggregated by USA TODAY, Georgia law enforcement agencies conduct some of the highest number of Flock searches on specific vehicles per month of anywhere in the country.
In April, Flock Safety opened a 97,000-square-foot manufacturing facility in Smyrna that is intended to create more than 200 jobs over the next three years as part of a $10 million investment.
“In Georgia, we foster a business environment where innovative companies can get off the ground and grow into leaders in their industry while operating in safe communities,” current Governor Brian Kemp said about the expansion. “Flock Safety is a great example of the success that approach has created, and we're proud to celebrate this milestone with them. We look forward to many years of partnership with Flock Safety in their efforts to help keep Georgians safe.”
Irene Wright covers Flock Safety as the Atlanta Connect reporter with USA Today’s Deep South Connect team. Find her on X @IreneEWright or email her at ismith@usatodayco.com.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Flock misuse still happening as debate rages on. ATL officers accused













