In Week 10 of the NFL, we were panicking on Jalen Coker and Kyren Williams in fantasy football. Those guys put up duds again this week, so the panic was warranted. Meanwhile, we're pumping the breaks on the Nico Collins panic as he went out in Week 10 and earned a 44.4% target share en route to 24.4 fantasy points.
Drake London suffered a concussion late in the Falcons' game against the Chiefs, but there's no need to panic on Atlanta's clear-cut WR1. He produced 109 yards on 12 targets, or a 28.9% target share, before exiting late. London should be back to his dominating ways on the other side of the Falcons' Week 11 bye. However, exercise caution in Week 12 against a stifling Vikings secondary.
As a reminder, this article will highlight the duds
from the previous week. I'll provide a score (0-5) on the panic meter. Zero means no panic whatsoever, while five means alarm bells are going off. Let's see who's on the panic meter heading into Week 11.
Week 11 Panic Meter
Chris Olave, WR, New Orleans Saints
Panic Meter: 2/5
Jordyn Tyson was a "full go" in Week 10. That ended up spelling trouble for Olave, who was out-targeted 13-4 by the rookie. Olave had 12 targets in Week 9 in Tyson's first NFL game, however, Tyson played just 24% of the snaps in that one (still earning five targets).
In two games played together, Tyson has earned 18 targets on just 47 routes (0.383) to Olave's 16 targets on 86 routes (0.186). Even with Travis Etienne Jr. back in the mix in Week 10, the Saints still needed to lean on the passing game with the rushing attack struggling mightily.
Both Olave and Tyson can be successful in this offense, but it's probably not a fluke that Tyson, the eighth overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, is thriving early on. That spells trouble for Olave, but we're not in full panic mode because the Saints will need to throw the ball and because Olave has shown a keen target-earning ability throughout his career (double-digit targets in 15 of his past 25 games).
Jonathan Taylor, RB, Indianapolis Colts
Panic Meter: 3/5
The trade deadline came and went, and JT is still a Colt. That's great for Indianapolis fans, but that's about where it stops. For Taylor fantasy managers, the only thing saving his fantasy value this season was a trade to a much better team. Not only did that not happen, but the Colts seem comfortable putting Taylor in somewhat of a timeshare with rookie Seth McGowan.
McGowan carried the ball a season-high 12 times for 77 yards and a score in Week 10. It's the second week in a row he's vultured a touchdown from Taylor. JT still played a majority of the snaps this week (68%), but his RB opportunity share dwindled (72% in Week 9 vs. 62.5% in Week 10). He hasn't scored a touchdown in his past three games and faces a hungry Texans defense on a short turnaround in Week 11. Not to mention his rest-of-season schedule appears unfavorable for opposing running backs. Selling on name value might not be the worst idea.
Malik Nabers, WR, New York Giants
Panic Meter: 1/5
I've heard rumblings that Nabers' fantasy managers are starting to panic a little bit. I'm here to tell you there's no reason whatsoever to do that. Sure, he hasn't scored a touchdown since J.J. McCarthy took over as quarterback, but the peripheral usage is there.
In the three games McCarthy has started, Nabers is averaging eight targets per game with a 30.1% first read target share. Per Fantasy Points Data, he also has eight deep targets and a 35.8% air yards share. The next-closest pass-catcher has just three deep targets from McCarthy (Darnell Mooney).
Isaiah Likely went off in Week 10 against the Commanders, but Week 11 could be Nabers' turn against a Jaguars team that is better against opposing tight ends than they are against opposing wide receivers. If the Nabers manager in your league is panicking, it's time to take advantage and buy low.
Jaylen Warren, RB, Pittsburgh Steelers
Panic Meter: 2/5
Week 10 was not friendly to Warren or the Steelers. Pittsburgh's starting running back rushed just seven times for 15 yards and added five grabs for another 26 yards on six targets. Sure, the Steelers found themselves trailing for the entirety of this game vs. the Bengals, but the usage is eye-opening.
Not only did Warren play fewer snaps than backfield teammate Rico Dowdle (23 vs. 30), but he also ran fewer routes (13 vs. 20). He ended up with more carries and targets than Dowdle, but it's at least notable that Dowdle was on the field more in a negative game script coming out of the team's bye week. However, Warren still led the way with a 62% RB opportunity share against the Bengals, reassuring fantasy managers that he's still the lead back despite the reduced snap share.
After the Eagles in Week 11, the Steelers have a handful of matchups that could lead to more negative game scripts (Broncos, Texans, Jaguars and Ravens), paving the way for less usage for Warren if Week 10 was any indication of his workload when trailing.
Trey McBride, TE, Arizona Cardinals
Panic Meter: 3/5
Carson Beck got the nod in Week 10, and that spelled trouble for the entire Cardinals offense (when they even had the football). They possessed the football for just under 18 minutes against the Rams and recorded only six first downs. They were 0 for 6 on third downs and produced just 123 total yards of offense.
McBride still led the way with five targets (27.8% target share) but was tied with Devin Duvernay and Hunter Long with two first read targets. Per Fantasy Points Data, McBride had a 14.4% air yards share that led to just 7.5 expected fantasy points for the game.
With Marvin Harrison Jr. gone and Michael Wilson out for the season, defenses can game plan to stop the Cardinals' only legitimate weapon in the passing game. Next up is a brutal matchup against the Chiefs in Kansas City, a game which features an implied point total of just over 12 points. After that, the matchups get a little softer, which is why the panic meter sits at a 3 instead of a 4 or 5.
Bonus names: Brock Bowers (3/5), Kyren Williams (2/5), Rhamondre Stevenson (3/5), Tyler Warren (4/5), Dalton Kincaid (4/5)
For more fantasy football advice, subscribe to The Weekly Lineup newsletter.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Fantasy football Week 11 Panic Meter: Sell Jonathan Taylor, buy Malik Nabers?













