The nursery had been freshly painted blue.
Missy MacIvor was eight months pregnant and she and her husband Mike were buzzing with excitement about their unborn son. They had been working to put the finishing touches on the baby's room.
All the while, a killer was planning the unthinkable. He had met Missy MacIvor at the gas station where he worked, became fixated on her and figured out where she lived, court records say. He plotted for weeks, and on the night of Aug. 21, 1991, he struck.
Thomas Mitchell Overton, then 35, climbed up a ladder and into the nursery of the MacIvor home in the Florida Keys, according to court records and details provided to USA TODAY by Mike MacIvor's sister. There he laid in wait as Missy MacIvor slept in the next room
and her husband was walking back to bed with a glass of milk, court records say.
What ensued was every family's worst nightmare. Overton raped Missy MacIvor and killed both her and her husband. Their unborn son, whom they were planning to name Kyle Patrick, died in the womb not long after his mother stopped breathing, court records say.
"They were a delightful, wholesome couple who had their whole lives ahead of them," Mike MacIvor's sister, Sharon MacIvor, told USA TODAY. "This guy was just an animal."

Now 35 years later, Florida is set to execute Overton by lethal injection for the murders. Though investigators say they were able to match Overton's DNA with semen recovered from Missy MacIvor's body, Overton has always maintained his innocence and claimed that police planted his sperm at the scene.
Overton's execution will mark a record 20 this year in Florida, breaking the state's modern record of 19 executions last year as Gov. Ron DeSantis began prioritizing the death penalty. Before that, the state had only ever executed eight inmates in a single year.
Overton, 71, is one of two inmates set to be executed in the U.S. on Thursday, Nov. 19. Texas plans to execute Reinaldo Dennes, 70, for the shooting death of a Houston diamond merchant during a $3.5 million jewelry heist in 1996.
As Overton lives out his last hours, USA TODAY is looking back at his crime, who Missy and Mike MacIvor were, and how their murder devastated their loved ones.
What happened to Missy and Mike MacIvor?
Missy, 29, and Mike MacIvor, 30, were last seen alive on the night of Aug. 21, 1991, when they went to a Lamaze class before returning to their waterfront home in Tavernier in the Florida Keys. Their bodies would be found the next morning.
Sometime that year, prosecutors say Thomas Mitchell Overton met Missy while working at an Amoco gas station near the young couple's home. They believe he got her address from a check she used to pay for gas.
Overton later told a cellmate that he had scoped out the MacIvors' home multiple times before he donned a "Ninja-type suit," cut their phone lines and entered their home through the second-floor nursery during the early-morning hours of Aug. 22, court records say.
Overton first attacked Mike MacIvor, hitting him in the back of the head with a pipe and knocking him unconscious. When Missy MacIvor ran from her bedroom screaming, Overton overpowered her, tied her up, raped her, and strangled her, ignoring her pleas for her husband's and baby's lives. He also strangled Mike, although accounts vary as to which of the two Overtons were killed first, according to court records.
Mike MacIvor's sister, Sharon MacIvor, told USA TODAY that Missy MacIvor had told her about a gas station attendant who gave her the creeps and came on to her in a very forward and uncomfortable way.
"I don't know the exact words he used but it was alarming. It wasn't a conversation you would normally have with a pregnant person," Sharon MacIvor recalled. "She said, 'What's wrong with you? Can't you see that I'm married and pregnant?'
"He was a predator," Sharon MacIvor added. "He looked at her like his prey."

It would take five years before police arrested Overton for the murders. During the initial investigation, MacIvor said she told police about the creepy attendant. At the time, Overton was a career criminal who lived nearby and was suspected in the 1990 strangling murder of a 20-year-old woman named Rachelle Surrett in North Key Largo. Overton worked at the movie theater where Surrett was last seen alive.
In October 1996, Overton was in the middle of committing a burglary when police who had been monitoring his movements arrested him. The next day, Overton attempted suicide by using a razor to slice into his neck.
Overton survived and investigators were able to use the blood he lost to match his DNA to semen found at the MacIvor crime scene.
At trial, Overton's defense attorneys argued that he had been framed and strongly suggested that police had planted his semen at the crime scene. They said he had been working at the gas station during the murders and that timesheets proving as much had been destroyed. Overton alleged that police had a motive to go after him because he had had a three-month affair with a Monroe County deputy whose husband was a detective in Marathon, according to an archived report in the Miami Herald.
Overton's attorneys also criticized the use of a jailhouse snitch at trial, saying the man was a three-time felon facing rape charges and only testified to get his prison sentenced reduced from 20 to seven years, the Herald reported.
A jury found Overton guilty of murdering the MacIvoys and their unborn son, and of sexual battery and burglary. The jury recommended the death penalty 9-3 for Missy's murder and 8-4 for Mike's. A judge agreed and sentenced him to death in March 1999.
Who were Missy and Mike MacIvor?
Michael "Mike" MacIvor was the third oldest of four children who grew up sail-boating, jet skiing and flying plans in Miami, said his sister, Sharon MacIvor. She said Mike, who became an inventor and a pilot, was brilliant, quick-witted, had a bigger-than-life personality and was always the life of the party.
Missy had a happy disposition, a generous nature, and was known as "our Missy" to her whole family, her mother, Bonnie Imel, told the Miami Herald in 1999. Growing up, Missy loved children so much that she babysat, learned sign language, and volunteered at a children's shelter when she was in grade school, she told the newspaper.
Missy was about to start a job as a third-grade teacher the day after she was killed and couldn't wait to become a mom herself, Imel said.
The couple connected instantly after meeting through one of Mike's brothers, Sharon MacIvor said.
"They were in love. It was very obvious that when he met her it was meant to be and that they were going to get married," she said. "It was kind of instantaneous."

She said the couple bought their dream home in Tavernier Key, married there, and wanted at least four children. They had already set up their unborn son's nursery and had recently painted it light blue before their murders, she said.
"They were both over the moon about having a baby," she said. "Their whole world was revolving around the baby coming."
Sharon MacIvor said she will be a witness at the execution and that she felt it was important to be there because her parents couldn't be. Her dad died of a heart attack not long after Overton was sentenced to death, and her mom died a few years after that in 2004, she said.
"I feel like their lives were shortened by the grief," she said. "They were never the same. ... My mother and father would both want to be here for this day and I feel it's important for their sake that I'm present to see this through."
Contributing: C. A. Bridges, USA TODAY Network-Florida
Amanda Lee Myers is a senior crime and courts reporter who covers the death penalty, cold case investigations and breaking news for USA TODAY. Follow her on X at @amandaleeusat.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Pregnant woman, husband had just painted nursery when a killer struck













