Whether we’re powering through a workday, squeezing in a workout between meetings or trying to avoid an afternoon slump, most of us want food that keeps us energized and satisfied.
Protein bars usually fit the bill, which is one reason they “used to have strong associations with bodybuilders and other fitness enthusiasts,” says Perri Halperin, a registered dietitian and clinical nutrition coordinator for the Mount Sinai Health System. She adds, however, that today “they’ve moved beyond the gym, and are now also used by busy professionals, parents, travelers, people trying to manage their weight and anyone looking for a convenient, filling snack.”
At the same time, she notes that convenience and a feeling of fullness − and even the presence of important
nutrients − don’t mean protein bars are always good for you. Here’s what to know before turning their consumption into a daily habit.
What are protein bars?
A protein bar is a packaged snack designed to deliver key nutrients and a concentrated amount of protein in a convenient serving − usually around 10 to 25 grams, Halperin explains. That protein typically comes from ingredients such as whey, milk, soy, peas, rice, eggs, nuts or seeds.
And unlike protein powder, which typically requires mixing, a bar is easy to carry in a purse, backpack or gym bag, making it a convenient “grab-and-go snack,” says LeeAnn Weintraub, a registered dietitian and nutrition consultant based in Los Angeles.
These bars are generally made by combining protein-rich ingredients with binders such as nut butter or syrups, then shaping the mixture into individual servings. Some are baked, while others are pressed or coated in chocolate.
Are protein bars healthy?
Protein bars can be healthy for several reasons but, unsurprisingly, their protein content is their most sought-after benefit. This nutrient supplies amino acids the body needs to maintain and repair muscles and other tissues, “which is especially important in middle-aged adults who experience more rapid muscle loss,” says Weintraub.
While a protein bar can certainly help meet your protein needs after exercise when a meal isn’t readily available, the protein it provides isn’t uniquely beneficial, “and there are generally no special muscle-building advantage to getting that protein from a bar rather than a nutritionally comparable whole food,” says Halperin.
Fiber is another potential benefit, though, as Weintraub points out that bars “can range from having 3 grams to 12 grams of fiber apiece.” She explains that “fiber is necessary to absorb water during digestion and can contribute to the bulk of your stool,” while also helping improve blood sugar regulation.
And protein bars made with dairy proteins “can also be meaningful sources of calcium,” says Halperin, “which is essential for maintaining bones and teeth, but also has important roles in muscle contraction, nerve signaling and normal blood clotting.”
Weintraub adds that many bars may also contain added iron and vitamin C, with the iron helping red blood cells transport oxygen and the vitamin C supporting collagen production, tissue repair and wound healing.
Some bars also contain potassium, “which is needed for heart health and normal cell functioning,” says Weintraub. But she’s quick to point out that whether a bar supplies meaningful amounts of these or other nutrients depends on its ingredients and whether it has been fortified.
To compare options, she recommends checking the serving size and associated protein, fiber and other nutritional content. As a general guide, she explains that 5% Daily Value or less per serving is considered low, while 20% or more is high − though these thresholds apply only to nutrients with a listed Daily Value. Protein is often listed only in grams.
Can you eat protein bars every day?
Despite the presence of many important nutrients, there are several considerations to keep in mind before making protein bars a regular habit.
Among the biggest considerations is calorie content, notes Weintraub. Indeed, among some of the most popular protein bar brands, a single bar can contain anywhere from 250 calories to 700 calories, though bars in the 300-calorie range are more typical. For comparison, three large egg whites provide more than 10 grams of protein for only about 50 calories. And a half cup of plain nonfat Greek yogurt can provide roughly 12 grams of protein for about 60 calories.
Added sugars is another consideration, as some bars contain amounts comparable to dessert, Halperin says. She cautions that “regularly consuming a lot of added sugar adds calories with relatively little nutritional value and can contribute to weight gain, dental cavities, elevated triglycerides and poor metabolic health.”
Because of these factors, “consumers should avoid protein bars with more than 8 grams of added sugar,” advises Weintraub.
At the same time, she cautions that low-sugar options can have their own drawbacks. For example, sugar alcohols such as maltitol, sorbitol, xylitol and erythritol may cause digestive discomfort like gas, bloating or diarrhea in some people, particularly in larger amounts.
The high fiber content of some bars can create similar concerns for other individuals. People with sensitive digestive systems or conditions such as functional bloating or irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) may need to pay particular attention to fiber type and quantity to avoid bloating, gas or abdominal discomfort.
The protein itself is another consideration for some people, as “consuming too much protein can increase the risk for kidney stones, so those with kidney complications should avoid overconsumption of the bars,” says Weintraub.
She adds that the bars should never replace getting plenty of fruits and vegetables. In fact, “contrary to popular belief, protein bars can have the reverse effect and actually weaken our bones if they are consistently consumed without fruits and vegetables,” she cautions. And when fruits and vegetables are combined with protein sources such as plain Greek yogurt, eggs, tofu, beans, lentils and nuts, you’re also going to get a host of other valuable nutrients.
Protein bars can, of course, still be a practical choice when a busy schedule, travel or limited food access makes a meal or another snack harder to manage, says Halperin, “but it may be helpful to think of protein bars as a backup or convenience tool rather than the foundation of someone’s protein intake.”
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Protein bars promise energy and fullness. But are they healthy?













