Trying to recapture the crowd-pleasing magic of “Rocky” seems like a fool’s errand for any movie, much less a project about the making of arguably the most popular sports film of all time. Somehow, though, “I Play Rocky” pulls off quite a few surprises as an emotional and funny underdog tale all its own.
Directed by Peter Farrelly (“Green Book”), it’s also a movie that really shouldn’t work as beautifully as it does. “I Play Rocky” (★★★½ out of four; rated PG-13; in theaters nationwide Nov. 20) starts off as a Sylvester Stallone biopic. But before long, it shifts to a go-for-broke Hollywood dramedy chronicling the rough, low-budget journey to make the best picture winner of 1977. The “Rocky” nostalgia is real and palpable alongside a fantastic
cast led by Anthony Ippolito, the relative newcomer who plays Sly who plays Rocky Balboa.

The movie begins with Stallone’s quest in the 1970s, when Sly – who goes by Mike in his early acting years – is having trouble finding work. He befriends a stray dog and has to take a gig in a softcore porn movie just to keep a roof over their heads. Sly also finds odd jobs such as a movie theater usher, which is how he meets coworker/future wife Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb).
She has the idea that Sly should just write his own script and give himself the best part, which leads to a move to LA. Sly has struggles there, too, until he meets with producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). They dig his writing but don’t take him seriously as an actor, which becomes an issue when – after an epiphanous bit of inspiration watching overmatched Chuck Wepner battle Muhammad Ali on a bar TV – Sly gets the “Rocky” screenplay done in three-and-a-half days and insists that he be the lead.
“I play Rocky,” an earnest Sly tells them repeatedly as fictional studio head Sandy Maddox (an exquisitely grouchy Tracy Letts) tries to buy him off so he can cast Ryan O’Neal, Burt Reynolds or any name actor who’s not Stallone. Sly doesn’t budge, so ultimately they greenlight "Rocky" for under $1 million, which leads to a whole new onslaught of problems during the actual filming in Philadelphia, from gnarly injuries and union bosses to Sly needing to finding the right moment to really shine as Rocky.
For Ippolito, that happens early on in a standout, chameleonic performance. From the first scene, he nails Stallone’s signature voice and mannerisms, and after a while, you forget that it’s not actually Sly up on the screen. Ippolito is equally adept at deadpan humor and deep heartbreak.
His strong portrayal early on gives way to his supporting cast to thrive in the back half. Byrne crushes being the more exasperated of the producing duo, while Jay Duplass is a sarcastic delight as “Rocky” director John Avildsen. And while it’s not called “I Play Apollo,” the movie needs way more of Stephan James as the ultra-cocky Carl Weathers.

Oddly, for a flick about an iconic boxing movie, there’s not actually much boxing. Sly and Carl kind of get their butts handed to them during training, and some of the “Rocky” finale scenes are shown in the credits. But a lot of care is taken to re-create some of the most rousing moments from the 1976 original, including Rocky running through the neighborhood and Ippolito’s Stallone scaling the famous Rocky steps in Philly.
Like its cinematic namesake and OG star’s story, “I Play Rocky” is a well-crafted ode to betting on yourself and never giving up the fight – a lesson that, 50 years later, still has so much punch.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Stallone origin story 'I Play Rocky' punches above its weight – Review













