There's a reason the saying goes: "American as apple pie."
Regional American food marketplace Goldbelly found that Americans order more apple pie for Thanksgiving than autumnal classics such as pumpkin and pecan.
The "State of the Pie" report, based on "full Thanksgiving season" of Goldbelly sales data, found that apple pie outsold pumpkin pie by over 20%. Goldbelly CEO Joe Ariel told USA TODAY in an interview that while he expected apple, which he called the "king of pies," to lead the tally, he was "surprised" by the margin.
He added that apple's margin has grown over recent years. According to Ariel, the company's data shows that apple and pecan pies were tied for the top sales spot in 2016. Apple began pulling ahead in 2018, while pecan held
steady.
What pies have Americans ordered?
Here are the top five pies Americans have ordered, according to Goldbelly data:
- Apple – 33%
- Pecan – 24%
- Pumpkin – 10%
- Key Lime – 7%
- Cherry – 5%
The data also shows that for every pumpkin pie ordered in July, 250 are ordered in November.
Despite the spike, pumpkin pie did not lead in orders in any state in the report. Most states favored apple or pecan.
But a few states broke from the apple-and-pecan trend: Key lime pie was the most ordered in Wyoming, coconut cream in Iowa and berry pie in Michigan.
Why apple pie?
Ariel, who is also the official food curator for America250, said apple pie makes anyone who eats it "feel American."
"When you have that turkey, you have that apple pie, it brings people together," Ariel said. "We need more of these wholesome moments that unify people."
Ariel said apple pie's versatility may also help explain its dominance. He called it a "creative canvas" for chefs and bakers, pointing to versions baked in a paper bag, made with sour cream and walnuts, or a pie containing 18 apples in it as examples of the "showstopper" desserts possible with apple pie.
He noted that the popularity of the dessert is likely a contributing factor to its strong position in the report, as customers order it for parties and as gifts. Ariel also recognized that the "showstopper" apple pie may be more likely to be ordered from Goldbelly, while pumpkin pie may be a dessert that is more likely to be made at home or purchased at a grocery store.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: What's the top Thanksgiving pie? Hint: It's not pumpkin













