If we’re being intellectually honest, the paths to the postseason are not only different, they’re fundamentally flawed.
It’s not just Utah and UCLA with easier roads to the College Football Playoff, it’s Miami and Notre Dame and Wake Forest and Texas Tech.
But these are the perfectly imperfect flaws of a 12-team CFP, the unknown of season to season, team to team, schedule to schedule. The flaws that will be eliminated when the CFP expands to 24 teams in 2027.
There's no reason to schedule difficult nonconference games moving forward. Soon enough, everyone will be scheduling to reach the top
24.
UCLA and Utah’s road now is drastically different than Georgia and Alabama. Wake Forest and Miami’s road isn’t close to what Ohio State and Texas have endured.
The USA TODAY Sports Playoff Predictor takes these nuances into consideration, unlike the 13-member CFP selection committee — which forever sees wins as the No. 1 metric to a team ranking. Unless you’re Alabama — but that’s another story for another time.
The problem: those scheduling nuances are the exact reason teams are dropping Power conference nonconference games instead of adding them. Beginning next season, the majority of teams scheduling difficult nonconference games will be Group of Six schools trying to impress the selection committee.
If you're a Power conference school, the formula is simple: find three nonconference wins, win five games in your conference, and hope your CFP metrics hold more weight than others. Welcome to the playoff ― and enjoy your first-round road loss.
Now onto this week’s Playoff Predictor, or how the CFP selection committee should vote, but won't:
College Football Playoff field if I was in charge:
- Georgia: The key is withstanding the onslaught to start every game. The Auburn outlier is the only flaw of the season. Next: at South Carolina.
- Tennessee: Doesn’t matter who plays quarterback, the run game and defense will carry Vols to the fourth quarter with a lead or chance to win. Next: vs. LSU.
- Texas: Longhorns are 5-0 vs. ranked teams because the defense is among the best in the nation — not because of QB Arch Manning and coach Steve Sarkisian’s offense. The last four LSU possessions Saturday were all punts. Next: vs. Arkansas.
- Alabama: Perfect spot to play QB Austin Mack, allowing Keelon Russell’s nagging ankle injury to heal. Next: vs. Chattanooga.
- Notre Dame: Keep winning, keep rolling through a fortunate schedule, and hope those in front lose so Irish secure a first-round bye. Next: vs. SMU.
- Miami: The concern isn’t on the field for the final three weeks of the regular season, it’s off the field: Will WR Malachi Toney be healthy for the CFP? Next: Virginia Tech.
- Utah: Utes keep finding ways to win, keep moving toward third unbeaten regular season since 2004 ― with three different coaches. Next: at TCU.
- UCLA: How can you not be impressed by the Bruins’ turnaround? But how many other FBS teams would be unbeaten vs. that schedule? Next: at Michigan.
- Indiana: Do we have too critical an eye for defending national champs, or is it a matter of time before they get exposed in the first round of the CFP? Next: at Washington.
- BYU: Two losses on the last play of the game, with a combined five turnovers in the losses. Cougars could easily be unbeaten. Next: at Kansas.
- Wake Forest: Since a 33-20 loss to Miami in September, Wake Forest has outscored FBS opponents by a combined average of 33.5 points. That’s not a misprint. Next: at Georgia Tech.
- Boise State: The last remaining question: Will Pac-12 flex schedule protect Boise State — or produce the best matchup possible? Next: vs. San Diego State.
CFP first round byes
- Georgia
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Alabama
CFP first round matchups
- Boise State (12) at Notre Dame (5)
- Wake Forest (11) at Miami (6)
- BYU (10) at Utah (7)
- Indiana (9) at UCLA (8)
CFP Quarterfinals
- Georgia (1) vs. Indiana-UCLA winner
- Tennessee (2) vs. BYU-Utah winner
- Texas (3) vs. Wake Forest-Miami winner
- Alabama (4) vs. Boise State-Notre Dame winner
Matt Hayes is the senior national college football writer for USA TODAY Sports Network. Follow him on X at @MattHayesCFB. Listen to him daily, from 12-2 p.m., on 1010XL-Jacksonville.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: College football’s playoff formula is a joke: Play nobody, win eight, pray













