The 2026 midterms have been called a “blue tsunami” for Democrats, an “extinction-level event” for Republicans and a “thrashing.” Democrats flipped nine Senate seats and more than 40 House seats. In Maine, five-term Republican Sen. Susan Collins fell to Democrat Troy Jackson.
But the blue wave that unseated Collins did not stretch to Maine's northern, rural 2nd Congressional District.
The district, currently represented by Rep. Jared Golden, D-Maine, was the only seat the GOP flipped without the help of redistricting. Former Maine Gov. Paul LePage, a Republican, defeated Democratic State Auditor Matt Dunlap by just over 5,000 votes in a race ultimately decided by ranked-choice voting.
While Democrats flipped seats in states seen as Republican strongholds,
including Mississippi and Texas, and held seats in districts redrawn to favor Republicans, they failed to win in one of just two districts in Maine, a state that voted against Trump three times.
The race for Maine’s 2nd district, rated "Lean R" by the Cook Political Report, was expected to be close. The more conservative half of the state has given President Donald Trump his only electoral college vote from New England in the past three presidential elections. Trump carried it by nearly 10 percentage points in 2024.
Golden's background as a veteran, reputation as a moderate Democrat and habit of bucking the party helped him appeal to the conservative-leaning district.
Before the election, Maine political experts said Dunlap was the strongest Democratic primary candidate to take on LePage, a well-known political figure in the state. While Dunlap has some progressive positions such as supporting Medicare for All, his campaign focused on his backing of gun rights and affordability.
While some mused that Dunlap was too progressive, political experts, activists and officials largely say it was more the strength of LePage's campaign and the makeup of the district that allowed Republicans to flip the seat. LePage had higher name recognition and effective ads in the state with an independent and ticket-splitting streak.
"I really think LePage won the race more than Dunlap lost it,” Jim Melcher, University of Maine, Farmington, political science professor, said in an interview with USA TODAY.
The Republican's successful campaign sticks out in a cycle where others in the party suffered blistering losses.
LePage's storied background and name ID stuck with voters
LePage, 78, was governor of Maine from 2011 until 2019, when he left office due to Maine's consecutive two-term limit. During that time, he gained a national reputation for his brash style. LePage once said he was "Donald Trump before Donald Trump became popular," and in 2016 caused controversy for an expletive-laden voicemail to a Maine legislator.
As governor, LePage vetoed a record of over 640 bills from the Democrat-controlled legislature, and sought to shrink the government, making dramatic cuts to Maine's health care programs and welfare system.
He ran again to challenge Gov. Janet Mills in 2022, but lost to her by about 13 percentage points.
While the widespread wins by Democrats across the country were widely seen as a rebuke of President Donald Trump, whose approval ratings sunk to an average of 39% on Nov. 1, according to RealClearPolitics polling aggregator, LePage touted his personal relationship with the president, saying during one debate that it would allow him to get into the Oval Office. Vice President JD Vance and Speaker of the House Mike Johnson traveled to Maine to appear with LePage. (Trump made more than 30 campaign stops, but Maine was not one of them.)
Still, Melcher said LePage ran a more moderate-style race than ever before. He distanced himself from some of Trump's policies, including the Iran war and tariffs, and emphasized his willingness to work with anyone to advance Maine's best interests.
"If it’s good for Maine, I will work with anyone to get it done," he often repeated.
Fox News Digital asked LePage after he declared victory in an interview that aired Nov. 9 why he thought he won in the face of a losing night for his party.
"I think it's my brand," he said. "I've been governor twice, I've won this district now for the fourth time. ... People know me and people trust me and they know what I say I'll do."
Brent Littlefield, a political consultant for LePage's campaign, said that familiarity was reflected in the conversations LePage had with voters as he traversed the expansive district. But he also pointed to their advertisements: The New York Times listed one of their ads, where LePage speaks his first language of French to demonstrate his support for immigration while taking a hard line against illegal immigration, one of the "10 ads that defined the midterms." LePage grew up in Lewiston, the district's biggest city, in a family of French-Canadian descent. Littlefield said the bilingual ad helped him stand out and showed a long history with the district. Melcher called another ad about LePage's difficult childhood in Lewiston "extremely effective."
According to data from advertising analysis firm AdImpact, $13.33 million was spent in broadcast ads for Dunlap, compared to $16.87 million for LePage.
Was Dunlap too progressive for rural Maine?
Dunlap's campaign manager, Harry Burke, said Dunlap, 61, ran on a platform similar to the one Golden ran on in 2018: Medicare for All, pro-labor, pro-choice. (Golden later backed off on Medicare for All.) Dunlap highlighted his experience as a sportsman and his belief in the right to own guns.
In the Democratic primary, Dunlap beat out state Sen. Joe Baldacci, D-Bangor, social worker Paige Loud and former congressional staffer Jordan Wood.
But Melcher acknowledged some people might have still felt Dunlap was too progressive: he served as a Maine co-chair for Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders' 2016 presidential campaign and the Sportsman’s Alliance of Maine, a prominent hunting group in the state he once led, declined to endorse him, although they didn’t endorse LePage either.
Burke expressed frustration with the idea that Dunlap might have been too progressive to win.
"There's not really anything to back that up other than just the fact that people have just been saying it," Burke said. "It's really vibes for me, is where I'm getting a lot of this from, than in his actual like stances on issues."

Baldacci, who came in second in the primary, said in an interview that he thinks it was a “winnable race.” He felt Dunlap didn’t do enough to reach out to undecided and independent voters in the district, pointing to things like campaigning with Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., a prominent progressive whose Bay Area district overlaps with Silicon Valley.
“I think it's important that if you are the Democratic candidate, that you show that you're independent-minded and not going to just be voting for your party 100% of the time,” Baldacci said. “You have to show that you're going to be somebody who's attuned to the district, who's not going to be too far to the left.”
He said he thinks that he or Golden could have defeated LePage, in part because they would’ve connected more with those voters “in the middle.”
Melcher, though, said he would not "take it for certain" that Baldacci or Golden could've performed better than Dunlap.
Both Baldacci and Melcher put some blame on the relationship between Golden and Dunlap for the loss. In Golden’s op-ed announcing his decision not to run for another term, he decried party polarization, said younger generations should lead the way and called for a competitive primary. He wrote that both LePage and Dunlap were a “far cry from being standard bearers of the generations that will inherit the legacy of today’s Congress," and said the district's "ideological diversity requires elected officials who are willing to represent the district as it truly exists – not as their party’s most vocal extremes might wish it did."
Golden, 44, did not endorse any federal Maine candidates. Dunlap criticized Golden during his campaign for frequently breaking with Democrats on issues that would affect Maine.
After the election, Golden tipped his hat to LePage on social media “for winning in the midst of this Blue Tsunami” in a post that did not mention Dunlap.
“The tension with Golden only added to that effort by LePage to portray him as too far to the left, because he was basically, you know, out of sync with the sitting Democratic incumbent congressman,” Baldacci said.
Golden did not return a request for comment.
Staffers on both sides of the general election campaigns, however, disputed that a different Democrat would have performed any better.
"I think they ran a good, solid campaign on the other side," Littlefield, the LePage campaign consultant, said. "I think the voters just chose Paul to be their member."
'The tale of two Maines.' Blue wave doesn't stretch north
In Maine, the blue wave did help Democrats unseat Collins. Former state Senate president Troy Jackson had just a few months to run his senatorial campaign after replacing the former candidate Graham Platner, who dropped out due to alleged sexual misconduct, which he denies.
But much of Jackson's campaign focused on the 1st Congressional District in the South, the more densely populated, liberal part of the state that feels more like other coastal areas in New England.
Voters in the 2nd District told USA TODAY that their rural region is struggling economically and far more conservative. While Golden has managed to keep hold of the district, most of his past elections have been close: three out of four were decided by ranked-choice voting, and he won by less than 3,000 votes in 2024.
"I've heard of the tale of two Maines, right? Like the Southern Maine and Northern Maine are very different. And I think that still definitely rings true," said Mitchell Cooper, a canvassing organizer with People Powered Maine, an activist group formed by former Platner campaign volunteers.
Melcher pointed out that Dunlap "massively outran" Jackson in the 2nd district, meaning he got a significantly higher share of the vote there than Jackson did for Senate.
Melcher said that there was so much attention on the Senate race that the 2nd district race may have “slipped under the radar.” About 6,000 people from the 2nd district who voted in the Senate race did not vote for the House.
“It was easy for people to coalesce around the Senate race and less so around the House race,” Cooper said. “We were seeing a lot of people that were voting for Troy, but not because they were excited about Troy, you know, it was because they were unhappy with Susan. And so I think that that drove a lot of success for Troy and that didn't necessarily carry over for Matt."
The 2nd district is also uniquely independent, another factor that may have allowed it to buck the blue wave. After all, its ticket-splitting tendency is what allowed both Golden and Trump to win in 2020 and 2024.
"Whether it was blue wave or red wave, it's going to decide on its own merits," Baldacci said. "Maybe because it's more rural, it's less affected by the so-called wave for either party that might come in."
Kinsey Crowley is the Trump Connect reporter for the USA TODAY Network. She is reporting from Maine for the 2026 midterm elections. Reach her at KCrowley@usatodayco.com. Follow her on Instagram and TikTok.
Margie Cullen is the New England Political Reporter for the USA TODAY Network. You can find her at mcullen@usatodayco.com and on X. For more New England political news, sign up for her newsletter.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Why a House district in Maine defied the blue wave and went Republican













