A top prosecutor has declined to charge a Madison, Wisconsin police officer in the July shooting of a 38-year-old man that shocked many in the state's capital and reignited protests Nov. 19 in the city
where the shooting occurred.
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said he declined to file charges against officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson because Corey Ruiz was armed with a knife, resisted arrest and was not subdued by officers' attempts to use a stun gun, according to a statement announcing his decision.
"A person does not have to like and [or] agree with the law, however I am sworn to apply the law to the facts at hand," Ozanne said in the statement released Nov. 19.
Baitinger-Peterson shot Ruiz during a July 22 encounter where four Madison Police Department officers attempted to arrest Ruiz after he fled. Police sought him after receiving a report that he had tried to open vehicle doors and commit a burglary.
An initial responding officer familiar with Ruiz called for backup before attempting to make contact with him, Ozanne said.
Baitinger-Peterson shot at the officer three times, and struck him twice, as the other officers attempted to restrain him. Officials said two other officers used a stun gun on Ruiz, but it was ineffective.
No charges will be filed against the other officers involved as well, Ozanne said.
Graphic and startling footage of the shooting spread rapidly on social media and protests roiled Madison after it occurred.
Madison Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway, who called the prosecutor's decision "disheartening," said the four officers involved in the shooting remaining employed by the department made it difficult for the community to trust the city's police.
Only the city's Police and Fire Commission have authority to fire a police officer.
"The narrow focus of whether criminal charges were warranted for this incident doesn't change the fact that Corey Ruiz should be alive and that, in a perfect world, no encounter with the police should end in death," the mayor said.
Madison Police Chief John Patterson said Ruiz's shooting will now undergo an internal use-of-force review by an outside expert. A review of the incident by an outside organization will focus on the department's handling of the shooting.
Patterson said Ruiz's family deserves compassion and empathy, but he defended the department's officers.
"I trust our officers to make the best possible decisions in the worst possible moments," Patterson said.
Ruiz's family is represented by prominent civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who said he was exploring other legal avenues, including a civil rights lawsuit. In a statement, he said the officer shooting Ruiz was "clearly an excessive use of force."
"We believe the district attorney should've charged this officer for killing Corey Ruiz," Crump said at a Nov. 19 news conference.
Details of Ruiz's shooting outlined in statement, investigative files
In his four-page statement, Ozanne, who described the shooting as a tragedy, included a description of the events that preceded Ruiz's shooting and how the prosecutor came to his decision on the charges.
"Any person may use deadly force to respond to a genuine fear of deadly force to that person or any other person," Ozanne wrote.
The state Department of Justice's Division of Criminal Investigation released its nearly 1,800-page investigative file following Ozanne's announcement. Included in that were details from a July 31 interview with Baitinger-Peterson, who told state investigators he feared Ruiz would stab him and other officers.
"PO Baitinger-Peterson was not sure what would happen because he knew the subject had a deadly weapon," the file reads. "PO Baitinger-Peterson transitioned to his handgun as [he] believed deadly force was his only option. PO Baitinger-Peterson feared for his life and the lives of the other officers because they were so close to the subject with the knife."
Results from a toxicology report included in Ozanne's statement showed Ruiz had methamphetamine and substances that indicate cocaine use in his system.
Ozanne's statement made no reference to Baitinger-Peterson being injured by a knife Ruiz wielded during the struggle. That is in contrast to the public's original understanding of the shooting, where Madison officials previously said the officer was injured by the knife during the struggle.
Patterson said at a press conference Nov. 19 that he saw wounds to both of one officer's hands, but did not identify which officer. The DOJ's investigative files indicate Baitinger-Peterson was injured, but the specifics of those injuries are redacted.
Ruiz family, attorney criticizes decision
Crump said county medical staff told him and Ruiz's family that Ruiz would have survived had the second gunshot, which struck him in the head, not been fired.
He disputed there was any relevance to the events that occurred before Ruiz was shot and argued the stun guns did work. Ozanne showed Crump and the family various videos and commentary to explain his decision.
"In the video you see that they tackle him, they tase him, they kick him and then the police officer executes him," Crump said. "The video is the unbiased objective witness."
Wisconsin Gov.-elect David Crowley said Ruiz's shooting raises "serious questions" about officers' use of force. He said he would work to improve police use of force and how police shootings are investigated.
"We cannot change what happened to Corey, but we can take responsibility for making sure his death leads to a serious conversation about how we move forward so that every Wisconsinite can have confidence that they will be treated with dignity and fairness, regardless of their race or ZIP code," Crowley, a Democrat, said in a statement.
Ozanne's decision was also criticized by state Sen. Kelda Roys, D-Madison, who described it in a statement as a "miscarriage of justice." State Sen. Dora Drake, D-Milwaukee, also criticized the decision.
Who was Corey Ruiz?
Family members remembered Ruiz at a funeralas a lover of music and beloved family member who struggled with mental health issues and drug use at points in his life.
His family has been harshly critical of the shooting and denounced the prosecutors decision.
"This is so wrong. They have no idea what I have to live with every day, him not being here," Ruiz's mother, Elsa, said Nov. 19. "It hurts so bad."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Wisconsin officer won't be charged in shooting of Corey Ruiz, DA says





