An Ohio judge has thrown out a defamation lawsuit filed by outgoing GOP Rep. Max Miller accusing his ex-wife of falsely claiming he once threw boiling water on her, finding her claim to be "substantially true."
Judge Joy Kennedy in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, dismissed the case and ordered Miller to pay about $77,000 in attorney's fees to his ex-wife, Emily Moreno.
Miller lost his re-election bid on Nov. 3 after Moreno's extensive allegations of domestic abuse surfaced over the summer and roiled his campaign. Lawyers for Moreno have consistently questioned Miller's credibility in court proceedings.
Miller has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing and has not been criminally charged.
"Emily Moreno has been thoroughly vindicated," Subodh Chandra, Moreno's lawyer,
told USA TODAY. "He himself had produced an audio recording in which he admitted dousing her with hot water."
Jennifer Freyd, an Oregon State University professor, told USA TODAY in September that Miller's defamation lawsuit reflected a strategy common among domestic abusers called Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender, or DARVO.
"This is public," she said. "He’s doing it in front of everybody." She said the strategy "basically manipulates the perceptions of outsiders. That’s why people do it. They do it because it’s actually an effective strategy."
Aaron Minc, a lawyer for Miller, told USA TODAY in a statement: "This lawsuit was not brought as part of any so-called 'tactic.' Anyone suggesting otherwise is simply wrong. The lawsuit was entirely warranted and was brought based on egregious facts and defamatory statements. We are confident that this decision will be overturned on appeal."
Miller and Moreno divorced in 2025 and share a toddler. Moreno is the daughter of Ohio Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno, who has vouched for his daughter's credibility in news interviews and raised concerns for his granddaughter.
In February, Moreno told police that Miller abused her during a police investigation that began after the pair's daughter was found with a broken collarbone underneath a hand-shaped bruise, documents show. A child services investigation into Miller found the abuse "unsubstantiated," according to a document.
The redacted police report says Moreno said someone "threw hot water." She also described separate incidents of someone holding a gun to her, grabbing her and pushing her.
At one point in the police interview, Moreno "began crying, covered her face with her hands, and stated that she did not want to talk about it," the police report says. At another point, when an officer asked if she wanted help making a report, she "indicated that no one would believe her," the police report says.
Nikhita Ved, the chief programs officer at the National Domestic Violence Hotline, told USA TODAY that one of the biggest reasons abuse victims don't leave their spouses or come forward "is the fear of not being believed, and that’s despite the public profile that anyone would have."
In his lawsuit, Miller said that Moreno and her lawyer "engaged in a defamatory campaign against (Miller) to malign his character, undermine his odds at re-election to Congress, and falsely portray him as a violent and abusive father and husband."
Miller's lawsuit said that he "has never hurled boiling water on Moreno or otherwise battered her, nor has he ever apologized for such acts that he never committed." He said Moreno and her lawyer were the reason tabloids such as the Daily Mail and the New York Post ran stories with the hot water allegation.
But in her Nov. 16 decision, Kennedy wrote, "Construing the evidence in the light of most favorable to Plaintiff, the Court finds that there is no credible evidence in support of Plaintiff's claims against Defendant Moreno."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Ohio Judge tosses Max Miller defamation lawsuit over abuse claim













