When Arch Manning hit an outbreaking Raleek Brown for a 4-yard touchdown in the final seconds to hand No. 8 Texas a 22-21 victory over No. 23 LSU, the narrative practically wrote itself.
After struggling mightily all night in his Louisiana homecoming, Manning stepped up when he needed to, guiding the Longhorns on a game-winning drive with their season on the line. It was punctuated by a perfectly thrown ball. For whatever else you might say about Manning — and given what he's shown over his team seasons as a starter, there's plenty to say — he's clutch.
To one of the most prominent voices in college football, he's even more than that.
During an appearance
on ESPN's "First Take" on Monday, Nov. 16, longtime college football analyst and pundit Paul Finebaum declared Manning the "gutsiest" quarterback he has seen since Tim Tebow, the former Florida star who's widely regarded as one of the greatest players in college football history.
"I have never seen anybody put a team on his back after screwing up as much as he has," Finebaum said. "I think that's what you have to love about this guy. He does not run away from it. Unlike the coach on the other side, he doesn't make excuses. After the game, he said, 'What people will remember was this drive, not my three picks.' That's exactly right."
"He's the gutsiest quarterback I have seen since Tim Tebow, I have never seen anybody put a team on his back after screwing up as much as he has" – Paul Finebaum on Arch Manning pic.twitter.com/z0TqnDnRsg
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 16, 2026
Finebaum's comment was something of a correction to a statement he made in July 2025, before Manning started his first college game, when he said the former five-star recruit was the best college football quarterback since Tebow.
The Florida quarterback, of course, won the Heisman Trophy in 2007 and was part of two national championship teams.
Since then, Manning has had an up-and-down career, at least relative to the massive expectations that greeted him given his recruiting profile and his famous last name. As a senior this season, he has completed 64.7% of his passes for 2,198 yards, 7.6 yards per attempt, 19 touchdowns and 10 interceptions, along with 126 rushing yards and three touchdowns on 88 attempts.
Against LSU, with his two-loss Longhorns team needing a win to bolster its College Football Playoff hopes, Manning was putrid for much of the game. Heading into the final drive, he had completed only 13 of 27 passes for 123 yards, no touchdowns and three interceptions. From there, though, he completed six of eight passes for 51 yards, along with a pair of runs on successful third-down conversions that kept the chains moving.
To Finebaum, it was the latest example of Manning's ability to come up when his team needed him to the most.
"Four weeks ago, we sat here and said he ought to be pulled and quite frankly, at the time, he probably should have been," Finebaum said. "But he has come back. I'll give (Texas coach Steve) Sarkisian credit. He called some really elite plays, especially at the end, and Arch Manning delivered."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: What do Arch Manning, Tim Tebow have in common? Paul Finebaum shares his thoughts













