The defending national champions are in position to miss the College Football Playoff entirely.
No. 8 Indiana made a quarterback change back to Josh Hoover but still lost 27-24 to Washington in overtime, giving the Hoosiers a second Big Ten loss and giving them only a slim chance of returning to the conference championship game.
With the loss, Indiana drops into a tie for second place in the conference with Oregon and Iowa. Unfortunately for the Hoosiers, they lose the tiebreaker to both teams and would have just one path to the title game: beating Purdue while the Hawkeyes lose to Nebraska and the Ducks to the Huskies.
The playoff selection committee has already made its feelings on Indiana known. The Hoosiers debuted at No. 4 in this year's rankings
but dropped five spots to No. 9 one week later after needing overtime to beat Minnesota. While they rebounded to No. 8 after beating No. 19 Southern California, the Hoosiers are clearly not a darling of the committee and could drop out of the top 12 on Tuesday night. That perception won't be changed by a win against Purdue.
It’s been a tough year for a team that basically cruised to last year’s national title. After failing to give even a loose approximation of Fernando Mendoza’s impact in 2025, Hoover is the face of the Hoosiers’ weekly struggle to even reach this point.
Since beating Rutgers 47-15 in early October, Indiana has scored more than 24 points in a game just once, in last week’s 27-13 win against Southern California. The wins against the Scarlet Knights and Trojans are its only Big Ten games decided by double-digit margins.
Still, the Hoosiers could’ve overcome their relatively anemic strength of schedule and lack of marquee wins by continuing to win ugly. Saturday’s loss makes official what was already expected: there will be a new national champion in 2026.
The Hoosiers, Nebraska and No. 4 UCLA lead Saturday’s biggest winners and losers:
Winners
Nebraska
No Power Four program needed this more than the Cornhuskers. After a miserable run of heartbreaking losses against No. 8 Indiana, No. 14 Oregon and Washington, Nebraska won the fourth quarter and beat No. 17 Ohio State 31-28 to snap the program’s 31-game winless streak against ranked competition. This is an exhale moment for coach Matt Rhule, who has seen his decision to replace Dana Holgorsen as offensive coordinator pay off with back-to-back wins. Defensively, the Cornhuskers were down multiple key contributors but held the Buckeyes to just 335 yards of offense and forced two turnovers. While this isn’t a vintage OSU team, this is the type of reputation-changing win that could be the spark the Cornhuskers needed.
Liberty
Liberty hit a speed bump in last year’s four-win finish but has rebounded under coach Jamey Chadwell to line up just behind No. 17 Boise State in the Group of Six playoff race. The Flames won their 10th in a row by beating Western Kentucky 41-14 behind 344 passing yards and three total touchdowns from quarterback Deshawn Purdie, who improved his record as the starter at three schools (also Charlotte and Wake Forest) to 15-3. Since losing to James Madison in the season opener, the Flames have done more than enough to earn a spot in this week’s US LBM Coaches Poll and should be under heavier consideration for the newest playoff rankings.
Iowa
It’s time for the No. 13 Iowa to climb in the rankings. Since a 13-10 loss to Minnesota last month, the Hawkeyes have taken care of business with a four-game winning streak against Wisconsin (30-0), Northwestern (24-10), Purdue (28-7) and, on Saturday, Illinois (34-17). While they’ve remained stuck at No. 15 in the playoff rankings, the Hawkeyes will rise at least one spot in this week’s poll because of the Ohio State loss. Clearly, Iowa will need more help to land an at-large bid. But a win next week against the Cornhuskers will boost Iowa’s résumé and potentially it within striking distance of the top 11 heading into conference title games. Should tiebreakers play out their way, the Hawkeyes could play in Indianapolis to clinch a spot.
Losers
UCLA
The Bruins lost 18-16 in triple overtime to Michigan, putting them in real danger of missing not only the playoff but the Big Ten championship game, too. Now UCLA needs to beat Southern California next weekend to finish in the top two, and may need to do so without quarterback Ty Dieffenbach. Already playing without starter Nico Iamaleava, who suffered a season-ending injury earlier in the year, Dieffenbach was carted off the field in overtime with an apparent leg injury. If he can’t go, Bob Chesney will need to roll with third-stringer Madden Iamaleava in a must-win game.
Ohio State
There will be no playoff trip for the four-loss Buckeyes, but don’t blame Jeremiah Smith. He might’ve increased his chances at the Heisman Trophy with 165 yards and two touchdowns, becoming the first player in Big Ten history with 4,000 receiving yards. The overall outlook isn’t good: Ohio State is rudderless and headed for a potentially disruptive offseason, full of questions about personnel (quarterback, to start) and the coaching staff. Look for Ryan Day to deflect some of the heat by making staffing changes, up to replacing both coordinators, and bringing in some fresh ideas to jumpstart another playoff run next season. For Day, though, the way this season unraveled after losing Julian Sayin will put him back on the hot seat two years after he responded to his critics by delivering a national championship.
Brigham Young
When a win almost feels like a loss: No. 12 Brigham Young 31, Kansas 29 in triple overtime. Now, every win counts, especially given the weekly culling of playoff contenders from around the Power Four. In two weeks, that BYU barely survived against one of the weaker teams in the Big 12 might be forgotten; instead, the selection committee could look almost entirely at the Cougars’ big win against the Fighting Irish. But there are multiple teams nipping at their heels for an at-large berth, including Wake Forest, No. 11 Texas Tech and even Oregon, so this narrow win might lead to a drop in this week’s playoff rankings.
North Carolina
The wheels have come off for Bill Beliechick and the Tar Heels, who dropped a fourth ACC game in a row with a 41-24 loss to Virginia and will need to beat rival North Carolina State next Saturday to secure bowl eligibility. This one wasn’t close: Virginia took a 27-10 lead late in the third quarter and then pushed things to 34-10 a few minutes into the fourth. Not too long ago, UNC was 4-2 with wins against Pittsburgh and No. 24 Duke along with competitive losses to Clemson and Notre Dame. Now, a loss to the Wolfpack would leave the Tar Heels in a tie for last place in the ACC and potentially signal the end of the forgettable Belichick era.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Indiana's flimsy CFP case leads college football winners and losers from Week 12













