The goal posts appear to be moving when it comes to determining the College Football Playoff rankings.
While there was minimal movement within the top 12 of the rankings released on Tuesday, Nov. 17, the focal point was Alabama staying put at No. 3, still one spot ahead of undefeated UCLA.
The Crimson Tide won in Week 11, but their resume didn't get any better for it. In addition to the uninspiring win over Vanderbilt, all five teams Alabama has beaten in the SEC lost, a coincidental yet concerning outcome that dampened the quality of the schedule. Kentucky, at No. 16, is now the only ranked team it has beaten.
It's a similar instance to what happened with Indiana in Week 10, when all of the teams the Hoosiers beat in conference play lost while
it was on a bye. As a result, they fell from No. 4 to No. 9, as CFP committee chair Hunter Yurachek noted the losses − mixed with teams getting signature wins − led to Indiana's drop.
Using that same logic, Alabama should have slipped a spot. So why didn't it?
CFP chair explains Alabama not falling in rankings
When asked by ESPN's Rece Davis about why Alabama didn't drop, Yuracheck noted Alabama "faced a similar circumstance" to Indiana, but not only did it play a game and win, "it didn't have the same impact on their strength of schedule" compared to the Hoosiers.
"Actually, is very minimal for Alabama because of the quality of the strength of schedule those five teams had lost. There weren't any games within the top 10, so there couldn't be much movement around Alabama. Then Alabama went on the road, didn't play their best, especially in the offensive side of the ball, but found a way to win 21-6 at Vanderbilt.
"We've seen throughout this college football season, after a big win like Alabama had at LSU, a team let down and lose those games. Credit to Alabama not playing their best in Nashville on Saturday, but finding a way to win. Alabama still in the top five and a record strength, top five in schedule strength, top five in relative offense, and they've won their six SEC games by an average of 22 and a half points. Only Georgia is better at 23," he added.
Regardless of the explanation, not many people believed it was the right decision for Alabama to stay put, with a strong sense of favoritism being felt with the Crimson Tide and selection committee.
Last week:
— CFB Kings (@CFBKings) November 18, 2026
All five of 8-1 Indiana’s best wins lost while the Hoosiers had a bye week. Indiana dropped five spots from 4th to 9th.
This week:
All five of 8-2 Alabama’s best wins lost while the Tide looked very average against 4-6 Vanderbilt. Alabama didn’t drop a single spot.… pic.twitter.com/Z9AFTWaLWy
MAKES NO SENSE: Alabama only has ONE win vs. teams with a winning SEC record this season, and ZERO wins vs. top 12 teams
— BetMGM 🦁 (@BetMGM) November 17, 2026
They're currently ranked 3rd in the CFP poll... pic.twitter.com/UGaUGcEgaK
And Alabama stays at 3. It’s time to ask legit questions about the 2026 CFP selection committee. https://t.co/Zk1bGzCQYw
— Jeff Rabjohns (@JeffRabjohns) November 18, 2026
After eviscerating Indiana's ranking because a few of their opponents lost, the committee was faced with nearly the exact same scenario with Alabama and did nothing. https://t.co/fhk4OcUDMH
— CFBudge (@CF_Budge) November 18, 2026
How it feels knowing the CFP committee loves Alabama and they’ll never drop us in the rankings pic.twitter.com/qL1zIQ6B2v
— SPG (@SPG9814) November 18, 2026
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Why didn't Alabama drop in CFP rankings? Committee's Yurachek on Crimson Tide staying pat













