If it were possible, I'd call Amy Poehler's "Dig" "good clean fun." The problem is, it's all about dirt.
The new Peacock comedy reunites Poehler with producer Michael Schur
, of "Parks and Recreation" and "The Good Place" fame. It's one of the more highly anticipated series of the year because of the promise of bringing Poehler back together with the producer who helped rise her star and make "Parks" a sensation.Schur has become a powerhouse name in the industry in his own right since that NBC comedy ran from 2009-2015, producing "Brooklyn Nine-Nine," creating "Good Place" and Netflix's more recent Ted Danson nursing home caper "A Man on the Inside." What kind of magic could he and Poehler cook up in 2026?
The answer is something sweet but without
enough bite. Terrible mud-related puns aside, "Dig" (streaming Nov. 23, ★★½ out of four) is a cute-but-not-too-twee comedy about a group of archaeologists and hapless undergrad students at a research site in Greece. The series is an adaptation of 2023 novel "Excavations" by Kate Myers, and manages to elicit laughs but not quite enough emotion. It is something of a lightweight in the boxing ring of TV comedies, not unlike Schur's "Man." But there's potential for more.
Poehler stars in the series as Elise, a workhorse archaeologist who is stuck in the shadow of her mentor Neville (Hugh Laurie, in all his pompous glory), a celebrity in their (small) world with Indiana Jones aspirations and a grandiose accent.
She wants her own dig, her own place in her academic sphere, and she almost had it collaborating with free-spirited student Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan), before the latter let the spirit take her elsewhere. Now Elise might be on the verge of a major discovery all on her own, and might just keep it secret from Neville with the help of Dylan, plus scientist Clare (Antonia Thomas) and hapless Gen Z assistant Patty (Fina Strazza).
The cast is a glowing collection of comedy journeymen ("What We Do in the Shadows" star Kayvan Novak shows up as a particularly horny Greek local, and frequen Schur and Poehler collaborator Jason Mantzoukas also makes an appearance). But the biggest strength "Dig" has is its unique setting, which is a breath of fresh (or ancient) air compared to a hundred other shows on TV in hospitals, offices, schools and shiny Los Angeles real estate.
The high jinks are comedy staples (losing a suitcase, being forced to work with your ex and his new squeeze, falling flat on your face) but the Greek statues and neck scarves are a welcome novelty, lit with the warmth of the Greek sun.
It's just the right kind of quirky setting for the kind of sitcom characters that made "Parks" such great TV: You've got a pompous Brit, a manic and nervous young woman, a perfectionist, a flake and a Gen X cynic. The show and the characters charm you, but you might not fall in love. There is something missing that prevents a true connection between the viewer and "Dig," and it's almost frustrating to be left slightly cold by a show with this big of an open heart.
Perhaps it's Poehler playing a bit too close to type, with overly perfect snark and familiar inflections. Perhaps its some characters that aren't quite developed enough, Like Laurie's Neville or Gary (Jon Pointing), Clare's fiancé and Dylan's ex. Maybe it's too many dildo jokes in just the first episode.
But whatever X factor is preventing "Dig" from reaching its full potential, it's worth remembering that "Parks" was a bit of a trainwreck in its first season, before the overwhelming advent of streaming shows, particularly comedies that rely so heavily on ensemble chemistry, had time to find their footing. We expect glossy and expensive streaming shows to come out perfect the first time. But that's not always how the best TV gets made.
Perhaps Poehler and Schur just need to dig a little deeper.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Can Amy Poehler strike sitcom gold again with Peacock's 'Dig'?












